新民事证据规定下的自认制度研究
Studies on Self-admission under the New Rules of Evidence in Civil Proceedings
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
2019年最高人民法院颁布的《新民事证据规定》大幅修改了2001年的证 据规定，其中作为亮点之一就是对自认制度的修订. 自认制度作为以当事 人主义民事诉讼模式下的辩论原则的核心内容，其最大的作用是约束法 院的效力，但在《新民事证据规定》中没有完全体现辩论主义的核心内 容. 而作为具体的规定，《新民事证据规定》有拟制自认制度尚需完善、 未明确附条件自认和限制自认的含义和类型、撤回自认和撤销自认的规 定不明确、不适用自认的规定不够合理等问题.
Abstract
The contents of the newlyrevised Rules of Evidence in civil proceedings (RECP) have undergone profoundchanges to Rules of Civil Evidence in 2001, one of the highlights is therevision of the self-admission system. The system of self-admission is the core contentof the debate principle under the mode of litigant civil procedure, its biggestfunction is to bind the court. However, this function is not fully reflected inRECP. Also, for the specific provisions, RECP has some issues, such as theimplied admission, conditional admission and restricted admission, withdrawaland revocation of self-admission, and the situation that do not apply toself-admission.
참고문헌 (13)
- 张卫平, "转换的逻辑：民事诉讼体制转型分析" (2007), 法律出版社
- 张卫平, "德国民事诉讼法" (2016), 厦门大学出版社
- 张卫平, "日本民事诉讼法典" (2017), 厦门大学出版社
- 最高人民法院民事审判第一庭, "最高人民法院新民事诉讼证据规定理解与适用(上)" (2020), 人民法院出版社
- 郑永焕, "新民事诉讼法" (2019), 法文社
- 李时润, "新民事诉讼法" (2016), 博英社
- 罗森贝克, "德国民事诉讼法" (2007), 中国法制出版社
- 伊藤真, "民事诉讼法" (2019), 北京大学出版社
- 新堂幸司, "新民事诉讼法" (2008), 法律出版社
- 段文波, "我国民事自认的非约束性及其修正", 法学研究, (1) (2020)
- 郑学林, "新民事证据规定理解与适用若干问题", 法律适用, (13) (2020)
- 江必新, "关于理解和适用新民事证据规定的若干问题", 法律适用, (13) (2020)
- 占善刚, "德国、日本民事诉讼中不知的陈述规制之比较及其启示", 法学评论, (3) (2014)