고대 돌궐 비문에 나오는 B²ẄK²L²I에 대하여
On B²ẄK²L²I in Old Turkic Inscriptions
1
조회
0
다운로드
1
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
The Turkic languages and dialects are spoken across a vast area from Eastern Europe and the Mediterranean to Siberia and Western China. The Orkhon Turks are the first nomadic people in present Mongolia who left their own written records down to us. These records are the inscriptions found in present-day Outer Mongolia, mainly in the basin of the Orkhon River, thus being conveniently called ‘the Orkhon inscriptions’. These are the Kül Tegin, Bilgä Kagan, Tuñukuk, Išbara Tarkan (Ongi), and Küli Čor (Ikhe-Khüshötü) inscriptions. Since the well-known Danish scholar Vilhelm Thomsen succeeded in deciphering the Old Turkic script used in the Orkhon and Yenisei inscriptions of the ancient Turks, many researchers tried to interpret the texts of the inscriptions. Most parts of the inscriptions are already well read. Many parts of the Kül Tegin (= KT) and Bilgä Kagan (= BK) inscriptions are almost identical. The letter group of B²ẄK²L²I is found once in KT E 4 and BK E 5 and once again in KT E 8 and BK E 8. The Japanese scholar Iwasa Seiichirō had already read B²ẄK²L²I as bökli 貊句麗 ‘句麗 of the 貊 mäk people’. It is also possible to read B²ẄK²L²I as bökküli or bökköli. The name bökküli or bökköli can be analyzed as bökküli (< *bäkküli < *mäkküli 貊句麗) or bökköli (< *bäkköli < *mäkkoli 貊高麗). This letter group of B²ẄK²L²I has been usually treated together with the next letter group of ČẄL²G²L² (or ČẄL²G²IL²). However, none of the readings and translations so far of B²ẄK²L²I together with ČẄL²G²L² (or ČẄL²G²IL²) are satisfactory. Moreover, all of the researchers overlooked that there were two Tabgač states in northern China in 552 ~ 577, i.e. in the first 25 years of the Turkic Kaganate. In all probability, ČẄlgl (or ČẄlgIl) and Tabgač are the Northern Zhou and the Northern Qi, respectively. Now, the letter groups B²ẄK²L²I : ČẄL²G²L² (or ČẄL²G²IL²) : T¹B¹G¹Č in this passage should be read as Bökküli (or Bökköli), Čülüg el, Tabgač “Bökküli (or Bökköli = Goguryeo), Čülüg el (= the Northern Zhou), Tabgač (= the Northern Qi)”
Abstract
The Turkic languages and dialects are spoken across a vast area from Eastern Europe and the Mediterranean to Siberia and Western China. The Orkhon Turks are the first nomadic people in present Mongolia who left their own written records down to us. These records are the inscriptions found in present-day Outer Mongolia, mainly in the basin of the Orkhon River, thus being conveniently called ‘the Orkhon inscriptions’. These are the Kül Tegin, Bilgä Kagan, Tuñukuk, Išbara Tarkan (Ongi), and Küli Čor (Ikhe-Khüshötü) inscriptions. Since the well-known Danish scholar Vilhelm Thomsen succeeded in deciphering the Old Turkic script used in the Orkhon and Yenisei inscriptions of the ancient Turks, many researchers tried to interpret the texts of the inscriptions. Most parts of the inscriptions are already well read. Many parts of the Kül Tegin (= KT) and Bilgä Kagan (= BK) inscriptions are almost identical. The letter group of B²ẄK²L²I is found once in KT E 4 and BK E 5 and once again in KT E 8 and BK E 8. The Japanese scholar Iwasa Seiichirō had already read B²ẄK²L²I as bökli 貊句麗 ‘句麗 of the 貊 mäk people’. It is also possible to read B²ẄK²L²I as bökküli or bökköli. The name bökküli or bökköli can be analyzed as bökküli (< *bäkküli < *mäkküli 貊句麗) or bökköli (< *bäkköli < *mäkkoli 貊高麗). This letter group of B²ẄK²L²I has been usually treated together with the next letter group of ČẄL²G²L² (or ČẄL²G²IL²). However, none of the readings and translations so far of B²ẄK²L²I together with ČẄL²G²L² (or ČẄL²G²IL²) are satisfactory. Moreover, all of the researchers overlooked that there were two Tabgač states in northern China in 552 ~ 577, i.e. in the first 25 years of the Turkic Kaganate. In all probability, ČẄlgl (or ČẄlgIl) and Tabgač are the Northern Zhou and the Northern Qi, respectively. Now, the letter groups B²ẄK²L²I : ČẄL²G²L² (or ČẄL²G²IL²) : T¹B¹G¹Č in this passage should be read as Bökküli (or Bökköli), Čülüg el, Tabgač “Bökküli (or Bökköli = Goguryeo), Čülüg el (= the Northern Zhou), Tabgač (= the Northern Qi)”
참고문헌 (50)
- Ajdarov, Gubajdulla, "Jazyk orxonskix pamjatnikov drevnetjurkskoj pis’mennosti VIII veka", ~ (1971)
- , 2005
- Amanžolov, Altaj S., "Istorija i teorija drevnetjurkskogo pis’ma" (2010)
- "Kömen Yayınları", 2012, ~
- "Kömen Yayınları", 2012, ~
- Bang, Willy, "Zu den Kök Türk-Inschriften der Mongolei", T’oung Pao, 7(4), pp.325~355 (1896)
- Berta, Árpád, "Szavaimat jól halljátok…, A Türk és Ujgur rovásírásos emlékek kritikai kiadása", Szeged (2004)
- "Türk Dil Kurumu Yayınları", 2010, ~
- Clark, Larry V., "Mongol Elements in Old Turkic?", Journal de la SociétéFinno-Ougrienne, 75, pp.110~168 (1977)
- Clauson, Sir Gerard, "An Etymological Dictionary of Pre-Thirteenth-Century Turkish" (1972)
- "Ankara Üniversitesi Dil ve Tarih-Coğrafya Fakütesi Yayımları", 1950, ~
- Erdal, Marcel, "Old Turkic Word Formation: A Functional Approach to the Lexicon I", Turcologica, 7 (1991)
- Ergin, Muharrem, (1970)
- Gabain, Annemarie von, "Alttürkische Grammatik" (1974)
- Grousset, René, "The Empire of the Steppes: A History of Central Asia" (1970)
- Li, Yong-Sŏng, "Zu QWRDNTA in der Tuńuquq-Inschrift", Central Asiatic Journal, 47(2), pp.229~241 (2003)
- Li, Yong-Sŏng, "On čẄlgl (or čẄlgIl) in the Kül Tegin and Bilgä Kagan Inscriptions", 59th Annual Meeting of the PIAC (= Permanent International Altaistic Conference (2016)
- Malov, Sergej Je., "Pamjatniki drevnetjurkskoj pis’mennosti" (1951)
- Nadeljajev, V. M., "Drevnetjurkskij slovar’" (1969)
- Nasilov, Vladimir M., "Jazyk orxono-jenisejskix pamjatnikov" (1960)
- Orkun, Hüseyin Namık, (1936)
- Orkun, Hüseyin Namık, (1941)
- "2011", 2
- Ölmez, Mehmet, (2012)
- Pulleyblank, Edwin G., "Lexicon of Reconstructed Pronunciation in Early Middle Chinese, Late Middle Chinese, and Early Mandarin" (1991)
- Radloff, Wilhelm, "Die alttürkischen Inschriften der Mongolei, Erste Lieferung" (1894)
- Radloff, Wilhelm, "Die alttürkischen Inschriften der Mongolei, Zweite Lieferung" (1894)
- Radloff, Wilhelm, "Die alttürkischen Inschriften der Mongolei, Dritte Lieferung" (1895)
- Radloff, Wilhelm, "Die alttürkischen Inschriften der Mongolei, Neue Folge" (1897)
- Radloff, Wilhelm, "Versuch eines Wörterbuchs der Türk-Dialecte III" (1905)
- Radloff, Wilhelm, "Versuch eines Wörterbuchs der Türk-Dialecte IV" (1911)
- Radlov, Vasilij V., "Drevnetjurkskije pamjatniki Košo-Cajdam, Sbornik Trudov Orxonskoj ekspedicii, T. IV" (1897)
- Sertkaya, Osman Fikri, "돌궐 비문들에 있는 한국의 이름", 광복 70주년(개천 5913년) 기념 제7회 高句麗 학술대회(국제 2회) − 高句麗와 돌궐의 관계 (터어키와 한국은 형제국) −, pp.33~48 (2015)
- Tekin, Talat, "A Grammar of Orkhon Turkic" (1968), Indiana University Publications
- "Türk Dil Kurumu Yayınları", 1988, ~
- Tekin, Talat, "A New Classification of the Turkic Languages", Türk Dilleri Araştırmaları, 1, pp.5~18 (1991)
- "Simurg Dil ve Edebiyat Dizisi", 1995, ~
- "Türk Dilleri Araştırmaları Dizisi", 2000, ~
- Tekin, Talat, "돌궐 비문 연구 — 퀼 티긴 비문, 빌개 카간 비문, 투뉴쿠크비문 —" (2008)
- Thomsen, Vilhelm, "Mémoires de la Société Finno-Ougrienne V" (1896)
- Thomsen, Vilhelm, "Alttürkische Inschriften aus der Mongolei, in Übersetzung und mit Einleitung", Zeitschrift der Deutschen Morgenländischen Gesellschaft, 78, pp.121~175 (1924)
- Tsogtbaatar, B., "Archaeological Study at the Memorial Site of “Dongoin Shiree” (Results of the archaeological excavations of the project «Ancient Turkic Historical and Archaeological research in the Eastern Mongolia» in 2015 and 2016)" (2017)
- "Kömen Yayınları", 2009, ~
- "Noten zu den alttürkischen Inschriften der Mongolei und Sibiriens, Helsingfors. (= Mémoires de la Société Finno-Ougrienne XII)" (1898)[URL]
- Vasil’ev, D. D., "Korpus tjurkskix runičeskix pamjatnikov bassejna Jeniseja" (1983)
- 김병호, "오르혼 옛 튀르크語 비문과 한반도인의 옛 이름- 퀼 테긴 碑와 빌게 카간 碑에 나타나는 ‘Bökli’ 해석", 동북아역사논총, (42), pp.7~45 (2013), 동북아역사재단
- 노태돈, "고구려의 대외관계와 북아시아 유목민 국가", 동양학, (58), pp.193~202 (2015), 동양학연구원
- 정재훈, "위구르 유목제국사 744~840" (2005)
- 정재훈, "돌궐 유목제국사 552~745" (2016)
- 탈랴트 테킨, "돌궐어 문법" (2012), 한국학술정보