≪白虎通義≫와 ≪風俗通義≫에 반영된 舌音類의 구개음화 여부
The Initials of zhang series, yi, and xie; Is their Palatalization reflected in Baihutongyi and Fengsutongyi?
0
조회
0
다운로드
7
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
This study is designed to discuss whether zhang series[章組] words, yi initial[以母] words, and xie initial[邪母] words, which we will simply address as “dental initials”, have been palatalized into affricates or fricatives in Baihutongyi and Fengsutongyi of the Eastern Han. South Coblin, in his work A Handbook of Eastern Han Sound Glosses initially asserted that Paranomastic Glosses in those documents reflected the palatalization of the initials in question. He believed that palatalization of the dental initials is responsible for their frequent contacts with jing series[精組] words, and his view has not been challenged for well over 30 years. However, there is convincing evidence which shows that the dental initials were not yet palatalized in the glosses. They had a plenty of contacts with plosives or the liquid sound l’s. Our discussion also revealed that the dental initials had only a handful of contacts with jing series, which enables us to confirm that the phonological systems in terms of initials are almost same as those reflected in other scholars’ glosses which Coblin viewed as reflection of unpalatalized *tj-type initials. This study along with my two previous ones revealed that palatalization of the dental initials was not reflected in the sound glosses represented in the works produced all through the Eastern Han time. But the Buddhist Transcriptions of that time reflected the palatalization of the dental initials, which is believed to have represented the actual phonological system of the period. That means that the phonological systems of the scholars of the period still stood behind the actual phenomena and that their systems reflected the literary readings which had been handed down from their teachers and through academic tradition.
Abstract
This study is designed to discuss whether zhang series[章組] words, yi initial[以母] words, and xie initial[邪母] words, which we will simply address as “dental initials”, have been palatalized into affricates or fricatives in Baihutongyi and Fengsutongyi of the Eastern Han. South Coblin, in his work A Handbook of Eastern Han Sound Glosses initially asserted that Paranomastic Glosses in those documents reflected the palatalization of the initials in question. He believed that palatalization of the dental initials is responsible for their frequent contacts with jing series[精組] words, and his view has not been challenged for well over 30 years. However, there is convincing evidence which shows that the dental initials were not yet palatalized in the glosses. They had a plenty of contacts with plosives or the liquid sound l’s. Our discussion also revealed that the dental initials had only a handful of contacts with jing series, which enables us to confirm that the phonological systems in terms of initials are almost same as those reflected in other scholars’ glosses which Coblin viewed as reflection of unpalatalized *tj-type initials. This study along with my two previous ones revealed that palatalization of the dental initials was not reflected in the sound glosses represented in the works produced all through the Eastern Han time. But the Buddhist Transcriptions of that time reflected the palatalization of the dental initials, which is believed to have represented the actual phonological system of the period. That means that the phonological systems of the scholars of the period still stood behind the actual phenomena and that their systems reflected the literary readings which had been handed down from their teachers and through academic tradition.
참고문헌 (58)
- 揚 雄, "方言", 國際文化出版公司
- 許 愼, "說文解字", 中華書局
- 劉熙, "釋名", 國際文化出版公司
- 陳彭年, "宋本廣韻", 黎明文化事業公司影印
- "十三經注疏(重刻宋版注疏)", 藝文印書館印行
- 王念孫, "廣雅疏證", 中華書局
- 段玉裁, "說文解字注", 黎明文化事業公司影印
- 朱駿聲, "說文通訓定聲", 武漢市古籍書店影印
- 兪 越, "諸子平議" (1954), 中華書局
- 陳 立, "白虎通疏證(上, 下)" (1994), 中華書局
- 王利器, "風俗通義校注" (1981), 中華書局
- 高 亨, "古字通假會典" (1989), 齊魯書社
- 黃布凡, "藏緬語族語言詞彙" (1992), 中央民族學院出版社
- 唐文, "鄭玄辭典" (2004), 語文出版社
- 馮其庸, "通假字彙釋" (2006), 北京大學出版社
- 王輝, "古文字通假字典" (2008), 中華書局
- 周祖謨, "方言校箋" (1993), 中華書局
- 董同龢, "漢語音韻學" (1983), 文史哲出版社
- 胡繼明, "廣雅疏證同源詞硏究" (2003), 巴蜀書社
- 華學誠, "揚雄方言校釋匯證" (2006), 中華書局
- 李方桂, "上古音硏究", 淸華學報, pp.1~61 (1971)
- 李方桂, "上古音硏究" (1980), 商務印書館
- 梁敏, "侗台語族槪論" (1996), 中國社會科學出版社
- 陸志韋, "古音說略" (1979), 臺灣學生書局
- 羅常培, "漢魏晉南北朝韻部演變硏究(第一分冊)" (1958), 科學出版社
- 潘悟雲, "漢語歷史音韻學" (2000), 上海敎育出版社
- 全廣鎭, "漢藏語同源詞綜探" (1996), 臺灣學生書局
- 施向東, "漢語和藏語同源體系的比較硏究" (2000), 華語敎學出版社
- 王 力, "同源字典" (1982), 商務印書館
- 王 力, "中國語言學史" (1984), 中國圖書刊行社
- 汪啓明, "先秦兩漢齊語硏究" (1998), 巴蜀書社
- 楊劍橋, "漢語現代音韻學" (1996), 復旦大學出版社
- 兪 敏, "兪敏語言學論文集", pp.1~62 (1999), 兪敏語言學論文集
- 兪 敏, "兪敏語言學論文集", pp.63~120 (1999), 兪敏語言學論文集
- 張均如, "壯侗語族塞擦音的産生和發展", 民族語文, (1), pp.19~29 (1993)
- 鄭張尙芳, "上古韻母系統和四等、介音、聲調的發源問題", 溫州師院學報, (4), pp.67~90 (1987)
- 鄭張尙芳, "上古音系" (2003), 上海敎育出版社
- Baxter, William, "A Handbook of Old Chinese Phonology" (1992), Mouton de Gruyter
- "Baxter, W. and L. Sagart(n. d. )(2011), Baxter-Sagart Old Chinese reconstruction(Version 1. 00). Online at"[URL]
- Benedict, K, "Sino-Tibetan: A Conspectus" (1972), Cambridge University Press
- Bodman, Nicholas, "Contributions to Historical Linguistics: Issues and Materials", pp.34~199 (1980), Leiden
- Coblin, W. South, "The Initials of Wei-Chin period as revealed in the Phonological Glosses of Kuo P'u and others", Monumenta Serica, 31, pp.288~318 (1974)
- Coblin, W. South, "The Initials of Eastern Han Period as reflected in Phonological Glosses", Monumenta Serica, 33, pp.207~247 (1977)
- Coblin, W. South, "The Initials of Xu Shen's Language as reflected in the Shuowen Duruo Glosses", Journal of Chinese Linguistics, 6, pp.27~75 (1978)
- Coblin, W. South, "A Handbook of Eastern Han Sound Glosses" (1983), The Chinese University Press
- Gong, Hwang-cherng, "漢藏語硏究論文集", pp.1~30 (1980), 北京大學出版社
- Karlgren, Bernhard, "中國音韻學硏究" (1940), 商務印書館
- Karlgren, Bernhard, "Analytic Dictionary of Chinese and Sino-Japanese" (1923), Courier Corporation
- Karlgren, Bernhard, "Compendium of Phonetics in Ancient and Archaic Chinese", the Museum of Far Eastern Antiquities, ~ (1963)
- Karlgren, Bernhard, "Grammata Serica Recensa", the Museum of Far Eastern Antiquities, ~ (1957)
- Matisoff, "Handbook of Proto-Tibeto-Burman: System and Philosophy of Sino-Tibetan Reconstruction", University of California, ~ (2003)
- Pulleyblank, Edwin. G, "The Consonantal System of Old Chinese", Asia Major, 9, pp.58~144 (1962)
- Schuessler, Axel, "R and L in Archaic Chinese", Journal of Chinese Linguistics, 2, pp.186~199 (1974)
- Serruys, Paul L. -M., "The Chinese Dialects of Han Time According to Fang Yen", pp.1959
- Tian, Tjoe-som, "Po Hu T’ung, The Comprehensive Discussions in the White Tiger Hall" (1949), Hyperion Press
- Ting, Pang-hsin, "Chinese Phonology of the Wei-Chin Period: Reconstruction of the Finals as reflected in Poetry", Institute of History and Philology Academia Sinica, ~ (1975)
- 권혁준, "東漢 ≪釋名≫의 聲母에 관한 몇 가지 문제", 중국학논총, (31), pp.1~42 (2011), 중국학연구소
- 권혁준, "東漢 鄭玄의 注釋에 반영된 章組ㆍ以母ㆍ邪母의 구개음화 여부", 중국어문논총, (56), pp.1~44 (2013), 중국어문연구회