The Limits of Eudaimonia in the Nicomachean Ethics
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
In Book I of his Nicomachean Ethics (NE) Aristotle defines happiness, or eudaimonia, in accordance with an argument he makes regarding the distinctive function of human beings. In this paper, I argue that, despite this argument, there are moments in the NE where Aristotle appeals to elements of happiness that don’t follow from the function argument itself. The place of these elements in Aristotle’s account of happiness should, therefore, be a matter of perplexity. For, how can Aristotle appeal to elements of happiness not entailed by his argument for what happiness involves? I will examine two instances that exemplify the sort of appeal to outside elements that I have in mind. The first deals with Aristotle’s reference, in NE, I, 8, to certain goods—ancestry, children, beauty—goods unrelated to man’s function or his fulfillment of it, but nevertheless required for his happiness. The second instance involves pleasure. Aristotle makes various arguments, both in Books I and X of the NE, that tie pleasure to the activity of the soul, and the function argument in turn. However, none of these arguments succeeds in demonstrating that pleasure would necessarily follow from this activity. Taken together then, these two examples demonstrate the extent to which Aristotle’s definition of happiness is more inclusive than his function argument permits.
Abstract
In Book I of his Nicomachean Ethics (NE) Aristotle defines happiness, or eudaimonia, in accordance with an argument he makes regarding the distinctive function of human beings. In this paper, I argue that, despite this argument, there are moments in the NE where Aristotle appeals to elements of happiness that don’t follow from the function argument itself. The place of these elements in Aristotle’s account of happiness should, therefore, be a matter of perplexity. For, how can Aristotle appeal to elements of happiness not entailed by his argument for what happiness involves? I will examine two instances that exemplify the sort of appeal to outside elements that I have in mind. The first deals with Aristotle’s reference, in NE, I, 8, to certain goods—ancestry, children, beauty—goods unrelated to man’s function or his fulfillment of it, but nevertheless required for his happiness. The second instance involves pleasure. Aristotle makes various arguments, both in Books I and X of the NE, that tie pleasure to the activity of the soul, and the function argument in turn. However, none of these arguments succeeds in demonstrating that pleasure would necessarily follow from this activity. Taken together then, these two examples demonstrate the extent to which Aristotle’s definition of happiness is more inclusive than his function argument permits.
참고문헌 (19)
- Bartlett, R. C., "Aristotle’s Nicomachean Ethics" (2011), The University of Chicago Press
- Crisp, Roger, "Nicomachean Ethics" (2000), Cambridge University Press
- Irwin, Terence, "Nicomachean Ethics" (1985), Hackett Pub
- Kant, Immanuel, "Practical Philosophy" (1996), Cambridge University Press
- Ross, W. D., "The Nicomachean Ethics" (1980), Oxford University Press
- Thomson, J. A. K., "Aristotle: The Nicomachean Ethics" (2004), Penguin
- Achtenberg, Deborah, "The Role of the Ergon Argument in Aristotle’s Nicomachean Ethics", Ancient Philosophy, 9(1), pp.37~47 (1989)
- Ackrill, John L., "Aristotle’s “Nicomachean Ethics”", pp.33~52 (2010), Brill Academic
- Annas, Julia, "Happiness as Achievement", Daedalus, 133(2), pp.44~51 (2004)
- Anscombe, G. E. M., "Modern Moral Philosophy", Philosophy, 33(124), pp.1~19 (1958)
- Cooper, John M., "Aristotle on the Goods of Fortune", The Philosophical Review, 94(2), pp.173~196 (1985)
- "Eudaimonism: A Brief Conceptual History" (2013)[URL]
- Korsgaard, Christine M., "The Constitution of Agency", pp.129~150 (2008)
- Mackay, A. F., "Aristotle’s Dilemma", The Journal of Ethics, 9(3-4), pp.533~549 (2005)
- Nussbaum, M. C., "The Fragility of Goodness: Luck and Ethics in Greek Tragedy and Philosophy" (1986), Cambridge University Press
- Ross, W. D., "Aristotle" (1995), Routledge
- Yu, Jiyuan, "Rationality and Happiness: From the Ancients to the Early Medievals", pp.51~74 (2003), University of Rochester
- "Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy Archive (Summer 2014 Edition)" (2014)[URL]