발생비평이란 무엇인가?—프루스트․조이스․베케트 발생비평의 발전양상을 중심으로
What is Genetic Criticism?: Focusing on the Cases of Genetic Proust, Joyce and Beckett Studies
1
조회
0
다운로드
2
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
This study briefly charts how genetic criticism, the study of writing process, has developed in the western European context. For the purpose of illustration, it provides a comparative account of the cases of Proust, Joyce and Beckett Studies. Scholars had been consulting modern writers’ manuscript material in a traditional philological approach since the early 20th century, and it was with the development and dissemination of French critique génétique over the latter part of the century that genetic criticism has become an independent and self-contained study of literary scholarship. Proust, Joyce and Beckett Studies feature their own different ways of addressing the conflict between the empirical and critical elements of genetic criticism, as well as the problems that their authors’ distinctive textual characters pose. This comparative historical account testifies to the fact that flexible empirical approach in applying genetic criticism contribute to the progress of both the empirical scholarship and the theoretical criticism.
Abstract
This study briefly charts how genetic criticism, the study of writing process, has developed in the western European context. For the purpose of illustration, it provides a comparative account of the cases of Proust, Joyce and Beckett Studies. Scholars had been consulting modern writers’ manuscript material in a traditional philological approach since the early 20th century, and it was with the development and dissemination of French critique génétique over the latter part of the century that genetic criticism has become an independent and self-contained study of literary scholarship. Proust, Joyce and Beckett Studies feature their own different ways of addressing the conflict between the empirical and critical elements of genetic criticism, as well as the problems that their authors’ distinctive textual characters pose. This comparative historical account testifies to the fact that flexible empirical approach in applying genetic criticism contribute to the progress of both the empirical scholarship and the theoretical criticism.
참고문헌 (60)
- 조이스, 제임스, "율리시즈" (2016), 어문학사
- Barnard, Megan, "Collecting the Imagination: The First Fifty Years of the Ransom Center" (2007), Texas UP
- "Beckett and Brain Science"[URL]
- Bourdieu, Pierre, "Les règles de l’art: Genèse et structure du champ littéraire" (1991), Seuil
- Compagnon, Antoine, "A New History of French Literature", pp.819~824 (1994), Harvard UP
- "Philology"[URL]
- Compagnon, Antoine, "Ce qu’on ne peut plus dire de Proust", Littéraire, 88, pp.54~61 (1992)
- "‘The Threat to Proust’: An Exchange" (1999)[URL]
- Connor, Steven, "Samuel Beckett: Repetition, Theory and Text" (1988), Blackwell
- Dembowski, Peter F, "The ‘French’ Tradition of Textual Philology and Its Relevance to the Editing of Medieval Texts", Modern Philology, 90(4), pp.512~532 (1993)
- Deppman Jed, "Genetic Criticism: Textes and Avant-textes" (2004), Pennsylvania UP
- Dowd, Garin, "Prolegomena to a Critique of Excavatory Reason", Samuel Beckett Today, 2008, pp.20, 375~388
- Eliot, T. S, "On Poetry and Poets", pp.103~118 (1957), Faber and Faber
- Ellison, David, "The Cambridge Companion to Proust", pp.200~215 (2001), Cambridge UP
- Falconer, Graham, "Genetic Criticism", Comparative Literature, 45(1), pp.1~21 (1993)
- Feldman, Matthew, "Beckett and Popper, or, ‘What Stinks of Artifice.’", Samuel Beckett Today, 2006, pp.16, 373~391
- Feldman, Matthew, "In Defense of Empirical Knowledge", Samuel Beckett Today, 2008, pp.20, 389~399
- Gabler, Hans Walter, "Computer-Aided Critical Edition of Ulysses", AALC Bulletin, 8, pp.232~248 (1981)
- "Introduction: Textual Criticism and Theory in Modern German Editing, Contemporary German Editorial Theory" (1995)[URL]
- "The James Joyce Archive: A Publisher’s Gift to Joyce Studies" (2002)[URL]
- Gabler, Hans Walter, "The Johns Hopkins Guide to Literary Theory and Criticism", pp.901~908 (2005), Johns Hopkins UP
- Genette, Gérard, "Narrative Discourse: An Essay in Method" (1980), Cornell UP
- Gontarski, Stanley, "The Intent of Undoing in Samuel Beckett’s Dramatic Texts" (1985), Indiana UP
- Graff, Gerald, "Professing Literature: An Institutional History" (1987), Chicago UP
- Groden, Michael, "Companion to Joyce Studies", pp.71~128 (1984), Greenwood
- Groden, Michael, "James Joyce Studies", pp.227~250 (2004), Palgrave Macmillan
- Groden, Michael, "Library Collections of Joyce Manuscripts", pp.783~785, Bowen and Carens
- Groden, Michael, "The James Joyce Archive" (1978), Garland
- Hayman, David, "From Finnegans Wake: A Sentence in Progress", PMLA, 63, pp.136~154 (1958)
- Hayman, David, "Probes: Genetic Studies in Joyce", pp.3~18 (1995), Rodopi
- Higginson, Fred, "Anna Livia Plurabelle: The Making of a Chapter" (1960), Minnesota UP
- "Textual criticism"[URL]
- Knowlson, James, "Damned to Fame: The Life of Samuel Beckett" (1996), Bloomsbury
- Knowlson, James, "Frescoes of the Skull" (1979), John Calder
- Knowlson, James, "Happy Days: Samuel Beckett’s Production Notebook" (1985), Faber
- Knowlson, James, , Journal of Beckett Studies, 1 (1976)
- Lernout, Geert, "Anglo-American Textual Criticism and the Case of Hans Walter Gabler’s Edition of Ulysses", Genesis, 9, pp.45~65 (1996)
- Lernout, Geert, "The French Joyce" (1990), Michigan UP
- Lernout, Geert, "Genetic Criticism and Philology", Text, 14, pp.53~75 (2002)
- Litz, A. Walton, "The Evolution of Joyce’s Anna Livia Plurabelle", Philological Quarterly, 36, pp.36~48 (1957)
- Litz, A. Walton, "The Genesis of Finnegans Wake", Notes and Queries, 198, pp.445~447 (1953)
- McMullan, Anna, "Staging Ireland’s Dispossessed", Samuel Beckett Today, 2017, pp.29(2), 361~374
- Moi, Toril, "How the French Read", New Literary History, 44(2), pp.309~317 (2013)
- "Metaphors for Writing" (2008)[URL]
- Nixon, Mark, "Beckett’s Manuscripts in the Marketplace", Modernism, 2011, pp.18(4), 823~831
- Pilling, John, "Beckett before Godot" (1997), Cambridge UP
- Pilling, John, "The Ideal Core of the Onion" (1992), The Beckett International Foundation
- Poe, Edgar Allan, "The Fall of the House of Usher and Other Writings" (1986), Penguin
- "Manuscript Studies: Definition"[URL]
- "The New ‘Ulysses’: The Hidden Controversy" (1988)[URL]
- Schmid, Marion, "The Birth and Development of A la recherche du temps perdu", Bales, 58~73
- Schmid, Marion, "Processes of Literary Creation: Flaubert and Proust" (1998), Legenda
- Schmid, Marion, "Teleology and Textual Misrepresentation: The New Pléiade Proust", French Studies Bulletin, 56, pp.15~17 (1995)
- Van Hulle, Dirk, "James Joyce in Context", pp.112~124 (2009), Cambridge UP
- Van Hulle, Dirk, "Holo and Unholo", Samuel Beckett Today, 2007, pp.18(1), 313~322
- Van Hulle, Dirk, "Introduction: Genetic Beckett Studies", Journal of Beckett Studies, 13(2), pp.1~9 (2014)
- Soubresauts and Comment dire, "The Making of Samuel Beckett’s Stirrings Still", pp.UPA, what is the word
- Van Hulle, "Manuscript Genetics, Joyce’s Know-How, Beckett’s Nohow" (2008), Florida UP
- Van Mierlo, Wim, "Reading Joyce in and out of the Archive", Joyce Studies Annual 2002, pp.32~63 (2002), Texas UP
- Watt, Adam, "The Cambridge Introduction to Marcel Proust", pp.114~115 (2011), Cambridge UP