본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

중국의 영향과 동남아의 대응: 상호적 접근시각

Chinese Influence and Southeast Asian Response: An Interactive Approach

박사명
한국동남아학회|2011.06|동남아시아연구 (The Southeast Asian Review)|제21권 제2호|pp. 217-261|DOI 10.21652/kaseas.21.2.201106.217

1

조회

0

다운로드

3

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

자율성autonomy민족주의nationalismSinocentrism자본주의capitalism중화주의dependence사회주의socialism타율성상호적 접근시각주동적 영향반사적 영향interactive approachactive influencereactive influence
주제분류지역학

초록

This study is an attempt to construct a basic framework of analysis about China's political and economic influence on Southeast Asia through traditional Sinocentrism, anti-colonial nationalism, Cold War socialism and post-Cold War capitalism. As to the historical status of Southeast Asia vis-a-vis external forces such as India, China and the West, the colonial discourse tends to put excessive emphasis upon its dependence, and the posy-colonial discourse upon its autonomy. However, this study elucidates the political and economic interactions between China and Southeast Asia in a dynamic perspective, focusing on their reciprocal interactions beyond the essentially static dichotomy of autonomy and dependence. Chinese influence on Southeast asia can be divided into active and reactive one, with the former referring to direct and intended consequences and the latter to indirect and unintended consequences. In the historical process of active and reactive influence, both China and Southeast Asia were fundamentally proactive actors. Thus, the autonomy or dependence of Southeast Asia is just a question of relative one, with its actual extent and degree varying with specific spatial and temporal conditions.

Abstract

This study is an attempt to construct a basic framework of analysis about China's political and economic influence on Southeast Asia through traditional Sinocentrism, anti-colonial nationalism, Cold War socialism and post-Cold War capitalism. As to the historical status of Southeast Asia vis-a-vis external forces such as India, China and the West, the colonial discourse tends to put excessive emphasis upon its dependence, and the posy-colonial discourse upon its autonomy. However, this study elucidates the political and economic interactions between China and Southeast Asia in a dynamic perspective, focusing on their reciprocal interactions beyond the essentially static dichotomy of autonomy and dependence. Chinese influence on Southeast asia can be divided into active and reactive one, with the former referring to direct and intended consequences and the latter to indirect and unintended consequences. In the historical process of active and reactive influence, both China and Southeast Asia were fundamentally proactive actors. Thus, the autonomy or dependence of Southeast Asia is just a question of relative one, with its actual extent and degree varying with specific spatial and temporal conditions.

참고문헌 (108)

  1. 박사명, "동아시아의 새로운 모색: 전장에서 시장으로, 시장에서 광장으로" (2006), 이매진
  2. 유인선, "베트남 전통사회와 유교화문제, 그리고 우리의 베트남사 연구", 동양사학연구, 50, pp.129~144 (1995)
  3. 유인선, "새로 쓴 베트남의 역사" (2002), 서울: 이산
  4. 전해종, "한중관계사연구" (1986), 서울: 일조각
  5. Seeking Security in the Dragon's Shadow, "Acharya, Amitav", Institute of Defense and Strategic Studies, Singapore, ~, pp.Working Paper Series, No. 44 (2003)
  6. Acharya, Amitav, "Will Asia's Past Be Its Future", International Security, 28(3), pp.149~164 (2004)
  7. Association of Southeast Asian Nations, "Forging Closer ASEAN-China Economic Relations in the Twenty-First Century" (2001), Jakarta: ASEAN Secretariat
  8. Benda, Harry J, "Decolonization in Indonesia: The Problem of Continuity and Change", American Historical Review, 70(4), pp.1058~1073 (1965)
  9. Bremmer, Ian, "State Capitalism Comes of Age", Foreign Affairs, 88(3), pp.40~55 (2009)
  10. Chee, Stephen, "Leadership and Security in Southeast Asia" (1991), Singapore: Institute of Southeast Asian Studies
  11. Chen Jian, "Mao's China and the Cold War" (2001), Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press
  12. Doner, Richard F., "Systemic Vulnerability and the Origins of Developmental States", International Organization, 59, pp.327~361 (2005)
  13. Duiker, William J, "Vietnam. 2nd Ed" (1995), Boulder: Westview Press
  14. Fairbank, John King, "The Chinese World Order" (1968), Cambridge: Harvard University Press
  15. Golay, Frank H., "Underdevelopment and Economic Nationalism in Southeast Asia" (1969), Ithaca: Cornell University Press
  16. Gurtov, Melvin, "China and Southeast Asia" (1971), Lexington, Massachusetts: Heath Lexington Books
  17. Hack, Karl, "The Origins of the Southeast Asian Cold War", Journal of Southeast Asia Studies, 40(3), pp.441~448 (2009)
  18. Hamashita, Takeshi, "The Intra-Regional System in East Asia in Modern Times. In: Network Power" (1997), Ithaca: Cornell University Press
  19. Hiebert, Murray, "Dissenting Voices", Far Eastern Economic Review, 2 (1993)
  20. Ho Chi Minh, "Down with Colonialism!" (2007), London: Verso
  21. Ho Khai Leong, "From 'Sino-Centricity' to 'Autonomous Narrative' in Southeast Asian Chinese Studies in China. In: Southeast Asian Studies in China" (2007), Singapore: Institute of Southeast Asian Studies
  22. Hogan, Michael J, "A Cross of Iron" (1998), Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
  23. Inoguchi, Takashi, "China's Intervention in Vietnam and its Aftermath, 1786-1802. In: Rethinking New International Order in East Asia" (2006), National Chengchi University
  24. Ishii, Yoneo, "The Junk Trade from Southeast Asia" (1998), Institute of Southeast Asian Studies
  25. Jackson, Karl D, "Cambodia 1975-1978" (1978), Princeton: Princeton University Press
  26. Johnson, Alastair Ian, "Cultural Realism" (1995), Princeton: Princeton University Press
  27. Jomo, K. S, "Southeast Asia's Misunderstood Miracle" (1997), Boulder: Westview Press
  28. Kang, David C, "China Rising" (2007), New York: Columbia University Press
  29. Kerkvliet, Benedict J. Tria, "Agrarian Transformation in China and Vietnam", China Journal, 40, pp.37~58 (1998)
  30. Kershaw, Roger, "Thailand between Democracy and Revolution", International Affairs, 58(2), pp.307~314 (1982)
  31. Kratoska, Paul, "Nationalism and Modern Reform. In: The Cambridge History of Southeast Asia. Vol. Ⅱ" (1992), Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
  32. Lee Kuan Yew, "From Third World to First" (2000), New York: Harper Collins Publishers Inc
  33. Lee Lai To, "China and the South China Sea Dialogues" (1999), Westport, Connecticut: Praeger
  34. Legge, J. D, "Sukarno" (2003), Singapore: Archipelago Press
  35. Liu Hong, "Constructing a China Metaphor", Journal of Southeast Asian Studies, 28(1), pp.27~46 (1997)
  36. Lysa, Hong, "History. In: An Introduction to Southeast Asian Studies" (1996), London: Tauris Academic Studies
  37. Mao Tse Tung, "Selected Works of Mao Tse Tung" (1977), Beijing: Foreign Languages Press
  38. Marks, Tom, "Making Revolution" (1994), Bangkok: White Lotus
  39. Medeiros, Evan S, "China's New Diplomacy", Foreign Affairs, 82(6), pp.22~35 (2003)
  40. 2008 Opinion Poll on Japan in Six ASEAN Countries, "Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Japan", ~ (2008)
  41. Mortimer, Rex, "Indonesian Communism Under Sukarno" (2006), Jakarta: Equinox Publishing
  42. Munoz, Paul Michel, "Early Kingdoms of the Indonesian Archipelago and the Malay Peninsula" (2006), Singapore: Editions Didier Millet
  43. Nguyen Tan Dung, "Economic Integration Tops State Agenda" (2004), Viet Nam News
  44. Perkins, Dwight H, "Industrial and Financial Policy in China and Vietnam. In: Rethinking the East Asian Miracle" (2001), Oxford: Oxford University Press
  45. Pham Gia Khiem, "Strengthen Cooperation, Promote Integration for the Future. In: The Future of Asia 2002" (2002), Tokyo: Nikkei Net Interactive
  46. Reonard, Jane Kate, "Extracts from Wei Yuan and China's Rediscovery of the Maritime World. In: China and Southeast Asia. Vol. Ⅳ." (2009), London: Routledge
  47. Roy, Denny, "China's Foreign Relations" (1998), Lanham: Rowan & Littlefield
  48. Roy, Denny, "Southeast Asia and China", Contemporary Southeast Asia, 27(2), pp.305~322 (2005)
  49. Sarasin Viraphol, "Tribute and Profit" (1977), Cambridge: Harvard University Asia Center
  50. SarDesai, D. R, "Southeast Asia. 4th Ed" (1997), Boulder: Westview Press
  51. Schellhorn, Kai M, "Political and Economic Reforms in Vietnam", Contemporary Southeast Asia, 14(3), pp.231~243 (1992)
  52. Schwartz, Benjamin I, "The Chinese Perception of World Order. In: The Chinese World Order" (1968), Cambridge: Harvard University Press
  53. Severino, Rodolfo C, "Southeast Asia in Search of an ASEAN Community" (2006), Singapore: Institute of Southeast Asian Studies
  54. Shao, Kuo-kang, "Chou En-lai's Diplomatic Approach to Non-Aligned States in Asia, 1953-60", China Quarterly, 78, pp.324~338 (1979)
  55. Sison, Jose Ma, "For Democracy and Socialism against Imperialist Globalization" (2009), Philippines: Aklat ng Bayan, Inc
  56. Smail, John J, "On the Possibility of an Autonomous History of Modern Southeast Asia", Journal of Southeast Asian History, 2, pp.72~102 (1961)
  57. Steinberg, David Joel, "In Search of Southeast Asia" (1971), New York: Praeger
  58. Stuart-Fox, Martin, "A Short History of China and Southeast Asia" (2003), Sydney: Allen & Unwin
  59. Stubbs, Richard, "War and Economic Development", Comparative Politics, 31(3), pp.337~355 (1999)
  60. Stubbs, Richard, "What Ever Happened to the East Asian Developmental State", Pacific Review, 22(1), pp.1~22 (2009)
  61. Tran Dong Phuong, "Vietnam's National Study on the Possible Implication of China's Accession to the WTO on Vietnam. In: ASEAN, Forging Closer ASEAN-China Economic Relations" (2001), Jakarta: ASEAN Secretariat
  62. Van der Kroef, "Communism in Southeast Asia" (1980), Berkeley: University of California Press
  63. Vo Nhan Tri, "Vietnam's Economic Policy Since 1975" (1990), Singapore: Institute of Southeast Asian Studies
  64. Vu, Tuong, "State Formation and the Origins of Developmental States in South Korea and Indonesia", Studies in Comparative International Development, 41(4), pp.27~56 (2007)
  65. Wade, Geoff, "Ming Chinese Colonial Armies in Southeast Asia. In: Colonial Armies in Southeast Asia" (2006), London: Routledge
  66. Wang Gungwu, "Early Ming Relations with Southeast Asia. In: The Chinese World Order" (1968), Cambridge: Harvard University Press
  67. Wang Gungwu, "Community and Nation" (1992), St Leonards, Australia: Allen & Unwin
  68. Whiting, Allen S, "ASEAN Eyes China", Asian Survey, 37(4) (1997)
  69. Womack, Brantly, "China and Vietnam" (2006), Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
  70. Wong, John, "China as a Catalyst for East Asian Economic Cooperation. In: The Emerging East Asian Community" (2006), Bangi, Malaysia: UKM
  71. Woo-Cumings, Meredith, "The Developmental State" (1999), Ithaca: Cornell University Press
  72. Woodside, Alexander B, "Community and Revolution in Modern Vietnam" (1976), Boston: Houghton Mifflin Company
  73. Wyatt, David K, "Thailand" (1984), Chiang Mai, Thailand: Silkworm Books
  74. Yee, Herbert, "The China Threat" (2002), London: RoutledgeCurzon
  75. Zhai, Qiang, "China and the Vietnam Wars, 1950-1975" (1975), Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press
  76. 郭大洛, "越南的社會主義市場經濟改革", 轉軌通信, 3 (2004)
  77. 鄧小平, "鄧小平文選, 第三卷" (1993), 北京: 新華出版社
  78. 丁文恩, "越南的社會主義定向市場經濟", 轉軌通信, 2 (2004)
  79. 丁文恩, "越南的經濟改革與發展", 轉軌通信, 2 (2005)
  80. 梁英明, "華僑華人學科建設與學術定位. In: 中國華僑華人硏究" (2008), 香港: 香港文匯出版社
  81. 梁志明, "關于中國東南亞學硏究的幾個問題", 東南亞硏究, 2, pp.14~19 (2007)
  82. 劉 禾, "帝國的話語政治" (2009), 北京: 三聯書店
  83. 李安山, "中國華僑華人硏究的歷史與現狀槪述. In: 華僑華人百科全書 總論卷" (2002), 北京: 中國華僑出版社
  84. 李雲泉, "朝貢制度史論" (2004), 北京: 新華出版社
  85. 馬洪, "甚麽是社會主義市場經濟" (1993), 中國發展出版社
  86. 賽代斯, "東南亞的印度化國家" (2008), 商務印書館
  87. 孫衛國, "大明旗號與小中華意識" (2007), 商務印書館
  88. 王逸舟, "市民社會與中國外交", 中國社會科學, 3, pp.28~38 (2000)
  89. 王逸舟, "中國與多邊外交", 世界經濟與政治, 10, pp.4~8 (2001)
  90. 王介南, "中外文化交流史" (2004), 太原: 書海出版社
  91. 余定邦, "中緬關係史" (2000), 北京: 光明日報出版社
  92. 余定邦, "中泰關係史" (2007), 北京: 中華書局
  93. 于向東, "中國的越南學硏究狀況及其思考", 鄭州大學學報(哲學社會科學), 6, pp.156~159 (2005)
  94. 趙汀陽, "天下體系" (2005), 南京: 江蘇敎育出版社
  95. 張曙光, "天下理論和世界制度", 中國書評, 5 (2006)
  96. 張秀明, "中國華僑華人硏究. In: 近年國內華僑華人硏究的趨勢與展望" (2008), 香港: 香港文匯出版社
  97. 庄國土, "略論朝貢制度的虛幻", 南洋問題硏究, 3, pp.1~9 (2005)
  98. 柯嵐安, "中國視野下的世界秩序", 世界經濟與政治, 10, pp.49~56 (2008)
  99. 孔遠志, "東南亞考察論鄭和" (2008), 北京: 北京大學出版社
  100. 唐世平, "中國的地域硏究", 世界經濟與政治, 11, pp.9~17 (2005)
  101. 唐世平, "中國外交討論中的的‘中國中心主義’與‘美國中心主義’", 世界經濟與政治, 12, pp.62~70 (2008)
  102. 唐希中, "中國與周邊國家關係" (2003), 北京: 中國社會科學出版社
  103. 費正淸, "中國: 傳統與變遷" (2008), 長春: 吉林出版集團有限責任公司
  104. 何芳川, "華夷秩序論", 北京大學學報(哲學社會科學版), 35(6), pp.30~45 (1998)
  105. 何芳川, "世界歷史上的大淸帝國", 史學理論硏究, 1, pp.22~34 (2004)
  106. 黃枝連, "東南亞華族社會發展論" (1992), 上海: 上海社會科學院出版社
  107. 小泉順子, "1880年代中葉におけるシャムの地域認識", Paper Presented to the First KASEAS-CSEAS Joint International Symposium (2009), Gyeongsang National University, Korea
  108. 濱下武志, "近代中國の國際的契機 3版" (1998), 東京: 東京大學出版會

관련 논문AI추천

동아시아 식민질서와 동남아시아: 서구중심적 제국공조체제박사명한국동남아학회 · 동남아시아연구2010 · 제20권 제1호중국 동남아학의 발전과 과제박사명한국동남아학회 · 동남아시아연구2010 · 제20권 제3호서구 식민지배 시기 중국인의 동남아 정착을 바라보는 상이한 두 시각정미경동남아연구소 · 동남아연구2011 · 제20권 제3호강대국 경쟁 속 동남아의 생존 전략: 역사적 관점과 통시적 비교이재현한국세계지역학회 · 세계지역연구논총2024 · 제42권 제1호탈냉전 후 중국과 아세안의 상호 전략과 그 영향윤영덕한국중국문화학회 · 중국학논총2005 · 제18호동남아 외교를 통해 본 중국의 대국굴기김진호중국연구소 · 중국연구2010 · 제50권

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (9건)

15-16세기 동남아 해상무역의 특성과 변화: 포르투갈의 진출과 영향을 중심으로김동엽pp. 1-41근대 동남아불교의 힌두문화 수용 - 태국 라마끼엔의 힌두신화와 불교적 변용김진영pp. 43-75인간의 이동을 중심으로 본 한국 속 ‘동남아 현상’김홍구pp. 77-123Two Economic Crisis and Dollarization for Cambodia, Laos, and Vietnam나희량pp. 125-153이슬람의 유입과 자바 무슬림의 능동적 대응:종교 텍스트에 대한 분석을 중심으로김형준pp. 155-182
원문 보기