인터넷 실명제에 관한 헌법학적 연구
A Constitutional Study on the Mandatory Personal Identificationon the Internet
0
조회
0
다운로드
52
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
the real name identification system of election bulletin board, so-called 'the real name identification system on the Internet' was enacted by 「the Public Official Election Act」 revised in Mar. 12, 2004. Additionally, to prevent lingual assaults such as intrusions of privacy or libels, the Government drived expanding the real name identification system to all sectors of Internet. Consequently, the real name identification system of general bulletin board was enacted in 「the Act on Promotion of Information and Communications Network Utilization and Information Protection, etc.」 by revising the Act in Jan. 26, 2007. the basic goal of the real name identification system on the Internet is controlling expression of ideas by constructing mandatory personal identification system. In other words, the Government has an intention to remove 'anonymity' which is one of the most characteristics of Internet coercely. In this context, the real name identification system on the Internet has serious constitutional problems as follows. The first problem is infringement of freedom of anonymous speech. The real name identification system allows who was identified to express one's ideas or upload one's materials on bulletin board. Therefore who was not identified cannot express one's ideas or upload one's materials on bulletin board. The second problem is infringement of freedom of political speech. Especially the real name identification system of election bulletin board has a ability to infringe freedom of political speech, in so that it aims to control expression of election, parties or candidates. The third problem is principles of the protection of right to informational self-determination or protection of personal data. Because to identify Internet user, personal data shall be used. The fourth problem is infringement of freedom of business of Internet company. If an Internet company is adopting a non-real name system as one's business policy, the real name identification system will impose some restrictions on the Internet company.
Abstract
the real name identification system of election bulletin board, so-called 'the real name identification system on the Internet' was enacted by 「the Public Official Election Act」 revised in Mar. 12, 2004. Additionally, to prevent lingual assaults such as intrusions of privacy or libels, the Government drived expanding the real name identification system to all sectors of Internet. Consequently, the real name identification system of general bulletin board was enacted in 「the Act on Promotion of Information and Communications Network Utilization and Information Protection, etc.」 by revising the Act in Jan. 26, 2007. the basic goal of the real name identification system on the Internet is controlling expression of ideas by constructing mandatory personal identification system. In other words, the Government has an intention to remove 'anonymity' which is one of the most characteristics of Internet coercely. In this context, the real name identification system on the Internet has serious constitutional problems as follows. The first problem is infringement of freedom of anonymous speech. The real name identification system allows who was identified to express one's ideas or upload one's materials on bulletin board. Therefore who was not identified cannot express one's ideas or upload one's materials on bulletin board. The second problem is infringement of freedom of political speech. Especially the real name identification system of election bulletin board has a ability to infringe freedom of political speech, in so that it aims to control expression of election, parties or candidates. The third problem is principles of the protection of right to informational self-determination or protection of personal data. Because to identify Internet user, personal data shall be used. The fourth problem is infringement of freedom of business of Internet company. If an Internet company is adopting a non-real name system as one's business policy, the real name identification system will impose some restrictions on the Internet company.
참고문헌 (34)
- 고경민, "인터넷은 민주주의를 이끄는가" (2006), 삼성경제연구소
- 정재황, "사이버공간상의 표현의 자유와 그 규제에 관한 연구", 헌법재판연구, 12 (2002), 헌법재판소
- 강경근, "인터넷언론과 선거", 헌법학연구, 9(3) (2003), 한국헌법학회
- 강경근, "인터넷언론의 선거보도와 법적·제도적 쟁점", 언론과 법, 3(1) (2004), 한국언론법학회
- 김영홍, "인터넷 실명제: 인터넷 실명제를 반대한다", 국회보, (439) (2003), 국회사무처
- 김재범, "인터넷 실명제: 정치적인 이유로 폐지되지 말아야 한다", 국회보, (452) (2004), 국회사무처
- 김재범, "인터넷 실명제: 익명성 폐해, 자정만으론 해결 어렵다", 국회보, (465) (2005), 국회사무처
- 김준호, "인터넷 게시판 실명제 추진", 시민과 변호사, (112) (2003), 서울지방변호사회
- 김혜경, "공직선거법과 인터넷실명제", 형사정책연구, 16(4) (2005), 한국형사정책연구원
- 명재진, "공공기관의 인터넷 게시판 실명제 실시에 관한 소고", CLIS Monthly, (5) (2003), 정보통신정책연구원
- 문재완, "익명 표현의 자유에 관한 연구", 언론과 법, 4(2) (2005), 한국언론법학회
- 문재완, "인터넷 실명제와 익명 표현의 자유", 인권과 정의, (352) (2005), 대한변호사협회
- 박용상, "인터넷 실명제와 ISP의 책임: 입법적 고찰", 언론과 법, 5(1) (2006), 한국언론법학회
- 방석호, "사이버공간에서의 정치 패러디 허용 한계에 대한 법적 고찰", 인터넷법률, (35) (2006), 법무부
- 성선제, "인터넷 선거보도에 대한 규제의 문제점과 개선방안", 언론중재, 24(2) (2004), 언론중재위원회
- 오병일, "인터넷 게시판 ‘강제’ 실명제의 문제점", 시민과 변호사, (112) (2003), 서울지방변호사회
- 이상배, "인터넷 실명제, 건전한 사이버문화 정착의 첫 걸음 될 것", 국회보, (479) (2006), 국회사무처
- 이은우, "인터넷 실명제: 익명으로 말할 권리는 민주사회의 소중한 가치", 국회보, (452) (2004), 국회사무처
- 이재진, "인터넷실명제의 명암과 윤리성 제고 방안: 본질적 가치인 ‘자유로운 소통’ 고려해야", 신문과 방송, (422) (2006), 한국언론재단
- 이종수, "표현의 자유와 정보통신 내용규제제도", 법학연구, 12(1) (2002), 연세대학교 법학연구소
- 이화실, "인터넷 역기능의 예방 및 피해구제를 위한 제도의 마련: 정보통신망 이용촉진 및 정보보호 등에 관한 법률", 국회보, (484) (2007), 국회사무처
- 전응휘, "인터넷 실명제: 표현의 자유 위협, 사생활침해 우려", 국회보, (465) (2005), 국회사무처
- 전창호, "인터넷 실명제: 얼굴 숨긴 사이버 폭력-방치할 수 없다", 국회보, (439) (2003), 국회사무처
- 조소영, "인터넷 선거운동(E-Campaigning)에 대한 헌법적 고찰", 헌법학연구, 11(2) (2005), 한국헌법학회
- 한상희, "음란물 규제법제와 통신실명제", 정보법학, (3) (1999), 한국정보법학회
- 한상희, "사이버공간에서의 익명성과 책임", CLIS Monthly, (5) (2003), 정보통신정책연구원
- 한상희, "게시판실명제와 책임 in 한국공법이론의 새로운 전개, 목촌김도창박사팔순기념논문집" (2005)
- 허경미, "인터넷 게시판 실명제 관련법의 정비방향에 관한 연구", 형사정책연구, 17(2) (2006), 한국형사정책연구원
- 홍완식, "인터넷실명제 관련 법률안의 입법원칙에 따른 검토", 토지공법연구, 31 (2006), 한국토지공법학회
- 황성기, "인터넷이용자 제작 콘텐츠(UCC)와 관련한 법적 문제점", 방송문화연구, 19(1) (2007), KBS 한국방송
- 황용석, "인터넷게시판 실명제에 대한 비판적 연구 : 익명적 표현의 권리를 중심으로", 언론과 사회, 15(2) (2007), 성곡문화재단 언론과사회사
- Rob Kling, "Anonymous Communication Policies for the Internet: Results and Recommendations of the AAAS Conference in Cyberethics: Social & Moral Issues in the Computer Age" (2000), Prometheus Books
- "EU Data Protection Working Party, Privacy on the Internet-An integrated EU Approach to On-line Data Protection"[URL]
- "Declaration on freedom of communication on the Internet"[URL]