한유 시에 대한 한중 지식인의 평가 비교 연구 -李瀷의《星湖僿說》과 趙翼의《甌北詩話》를 중심으로
A Comparative Study on the evaluation of the Han Yu's poems by both Korean and Chinese scholar -Fousing on Li Yi`s 《XinghuSishuo》and Zao Yi`s 《OubeiShihua》
2
조회
0
다운로드
6
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Han Yu was one of the main leaders of the Classical Prose Movement at his time, Middle Tang. His achievement in Classical Prose Creation has a vital influence to the literary history and was highly appreciated. One the other hand, the evaluation on his style of poem-composing has a controversial. It's because he compose poetry introducing prose elements into the poetry. This paper will make comparative study on how the scholar in Korea and China evaluated the Han Yu's poetry. For this study I choose two books: ≪XinghuSishuo≫ by Li Yi in Joseon Dynasty and ≪OubeiShihua≫ by Zao Yi in Qing Dynasty. ≪XinghuSishuo≫ by Li Yi is a book about what Li Yi realizes by reading, experiencing, listening and seeing in the form of memorandum. It is kind of essay about short subject what Li Yi thinks. <Poetry and prose part> in ≪XinghuSishuo≫, composed of 3 parts and 378 chapters. has two-thirds of poetry and writings, which has various contents from the general opinion about the poetry to the explanation about the fragmentary poetic diction and version. ≪OubeiShihua≫ composed of 12 volumes, is the main book about criticism of poems. From vol. 1 to 10, it specializes about 10 poets. Especially in Vol 3 it focuses on the Han Yu's poetry and describes the Zao Yi's view about Han Yu's poetic world. Li Yi asserts that Han Yu's created his own unique style of poem-composing, which can not be found in any other poets. Zao Yi found contemporary spirit in Han Yu's poetry and understand the characteristic of Yi wen wei shi (以文爲詩). It shows that Li Yi and Zao Yi has evaluated Han Yu's poetry by both their own way and objective way.
Abstract
Han Yu was one of the main leaders of the Classical Prose Movement at his time, Middle Tang. His achievement in Classical Prose Creation has a vital influence to the literary history and was highly appreciated. One the other hand, the evaluation on his style of poem-composing has a controversial. It's because he compose poetry introducing prose elements into the poetry. This paper will make comparative study on how the scholar in Korea and China evaluated the Han Yu's poetry. For this study I choose two books: ≪XinghuSishuo≫ by Li Yi in Joseon Dynasty and ≪OubeiShihua≫ by Zao Yi in Qing Dynasty. ≪XinghuSishuo≫ by Li Yi is a book about what Li Yi realizes by reading, experiencing, listening and seeing in the form of memorandum. It is kind of essay about short subject what Li Yi thinks. <Poetry and prose part> in ≪XinghuSishuo≫, composed of 3 parts and 378 chapters. has two-thirds of poetry and writings, which has various contents from the general opinion about the poetry to the explanation about the fragmentary poetic diction and version. ≪OubeiShihua≫ composed of 12 volumes, is the main book about criticism of poems. From vol. 1 to 10, it specializes about 10 poets. Especially in Vol 3 it focuses on the Han Yu's poetry and describes the Zao Yi's view about Han Yu's poetic world. Li Yi asserts that Han Yu's created his own unique style of poem-composing, which can not be found in any other poets. Zao Yi found contemporary spirit in Han Yu's poetry and understand the characteristic of Yi wen wei shi (以文爲詩). It shows that Li Yi and Zao Yi has evaluated Han Yu's poetry by both their own way and objective way.
참고문헌 (31)
- 趙鍾業, "修正增補韓國詩話叢編" (1997), 태학사
- 李瀷, "星湖僿說" (1929), 文光書林
- 趙翼, "甌北詩話" (1981), 人民文學出版社
- 趙翼, "甌北詩話" (2009), 서울대학교출판부
- 鄺健行, "韓國詩話中論中國詩資料選粹" (2000), 중화서국
- 錢仲聯, "韓昌黎詩繫年集釋", 學海出版社
- "韓愈資料彙編", 學海出版社
- 劉德重, "詩話槪說" (1990), 中華書局
- 李卓藩, "韓愈詩初探", 文史哲出版社
- 止水, "韓愈詩選" (1980), 三聯書局
- 陳迩東, "韓愈詩選" (2000), 人民文學出版社
- 李瀷, "국역성호사설" (1982), 민족문화추진회
- 李瀷, "성호사설精選" (1998), 현대실학사
- 李瀷, "성호사설" (1999), 한길사
- 金學主, "中國文學史論" (2001), 서울대학교출판부
- 李炳漢, "中國詩와 詩人, 唐代篇" (1998), 사람과 책
- 高八美, "韓愈詩硏究", 박사, pp.民國75
- 金學主, "論韓愈的詩 in 町田三郞敎授退官記念 中國思想史論叢" (1995)
- 陳寅恪, "論韓愈 in 歷史硏究" (1954)
- 錢基博, "韓集籒讀錄第六 in 論韓愈" (1935)
- 程千帆,, "韓愈以文爲詩說 in 古詩考索" (1979), 南京大學古典文獻硏究所
- 羅聯添, "論韓愈古文幾個問題 in 唐代文學硏究" (1992)
- 畢桂發, "趙翼論詩的宏觀視野的創新精神" (1998), 河南大學學報
- 張明曙, "論趙翼的詩歌創新主張" (1991), 上海師範大學學報
- 김지영, "中國 古典詩歌의 散文的 要素 收容 樣相 中唐에서 北宋까지의 以文爲詩를 중심으로", 박사, pp.2007
- 김지영, "韓愈 詩의 散文的 특징에 대한 고찰", 중국문학, 49, pp.17~36 (2006), 한국중국어문학회
- 김지영, "≪甌北詩話≫에 나타난 趙翼의 詩論 연구", 중국문학, 54, pp.71~92 (2008), 한국중국어문학회
- 張戒, "歲寒堂詩話"
- 陳師道, "後山詩話"
- 魏慶之, "詩人玉屑"
- 陳善, "捫蝨新語"
