강간피해자로서 ‘성전환자’의 인정 여부에 관한 검토
A Study on the transsexual as victim of rape
0
조회
0
다운로드
8
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
The article 297 of the Korean Criminal provides that only a woman is possibly raped. In relation to interpretation of 'woman', The Supreme Court(1996) was judging whether man or woman via sex chromosome. But this interpretation gave rise to confusion. In particular case, it is not easy to distinguish man from woman. For example, transsexual(MTF), tansssexual(FTM) etc. On the other hand, One of main issues in these days is the sexual minority's right to equality. Especially transsexual is treated unequally in criminal law. The criteria of judgement between male and female contain biological sex(for instance, a sex chromosome, gonadal sex, internal morphologic sex, external morphologic sex etc), psychological(mental)․social gender etc. Above all, we should recognize that psychological(mental)․social gender is much important the present state of things. Also, we have to pay due regard to such factors as often as judgement between male and female. The Supreme Court(2009) takes a this position. Most of all, for effective protection of transsexual's rights, we have to make an atmosphere where we can recognize transsexual, who exist as minor human type and live together. Therefore, revise action object of rape is reasonable that change as 'person'. In conclusion, the purpose of this writing is to consider the protection of transsexual's right to criminal law.
Abstract
The article 297 of the Korean Criminal provides that only a woman is possibly raped. In relation to interpretation of 'woman', The Supreme Court(1996) was judging whether man or woman via sex chromosome. But this interpretation gave rise to confusion. In particular case, it is not easy to distinguish man from woman. For example, transsexual(MTF), tansssexual(FTM) etc. On the other hand, One of main issues in these days is the sexual minority's right to equality. Especially transsexual is treated unequally in criminal law. The criteria of judgement between male and female contain biological sex(for instance, a sex chromosome, gonadal sex, internal morphologic sex, external morphologic sex etc), psychological(mental)․social gender etc. Above all, we should recognize that psychological(mental)․social gender is much important the present state of things. Also, we have to pay due regard to such factors as often as judgement between male and female. The Supreme Court(2009) takes a this position. Most of all, for effective protection of transsexual's rights, we have to make an atmosphere where we can recognize transsexual, who exist as minor human type and live together. Therefore, revise action object of rape is reasonable that change as 'person'. In conclusion, the purpose of this writing is to consider the protection of transsexual's right to criminal law.
참고문헌 (31)
- 권오걸, "형법각론" (2009), 형설출판사
- 권택근, "성인 반음양 환자에서의 성전환수술의 체험례", 대한성형외과학회지, 19(4) (1992)
- 김석권, "임상을 통해 본 성전환자의 성정체성", 시민과 변호사, (83) (2000), 서울지방변호사회
- 김성돈, "형법각론(제2판)" (2009), 성균관대학교 출판부
- 김성천, "형법각론(제2판)" (2006), 동현출판사
- 김일수, "합동강간치상죄의 불능미수 - 대법원 1996. 6. 11. 선고 96도791판결", 판례연구, (8) (1996), 고려대학교 법학연구소
- 김일수, "새로 쓴 형법각론(제7판)" (2007), 박영사
- 김중권, "“성전환자의 성별정정허가신청사건 등 사무처리지침의 문제점”, 법률신문, 2006. 9. 25", ~ (2006)
- 金台明, "性轉換을 둘러싼 法的 問題點에 대한 檢討", 저스티스, 71, pp.26~51 (2003), 한국법학원
- 노지환, "동성애자의 인권 보호에 관한 논의", 인권법의 이론과 실제, 1(1), pp.147~164 (2009), 법학연구소
- 박상기, "형법각론(제6판)" (2005), 박영사
- 박찬걸, "강간죄의 객체로서 ‘아내’의 인정 여부에 관한 소고", 법학논총, 26(2), pp.79~109 (2009), 법학연구소
- 배종대, "형법각론(제6전정판)" (2006), 홍문사
- 백형구, "형법각론" (1999), 청림출판사
- 손동권, "형법각론(제2개정판)" (2006), 율곡출판사
- 음선필, "성전환증자의 성별변경", 순천향사회과학연구, 8(2) (2002), 순천향대학교 사회과학연구소
- 이영란, "형법학(각론강의)", pp.165~ (2008), 형설출판사
- 이용식, "판례를 통해서 본 성(性)에 대한 법인식의 변화 - 혼인빙자간음죄·강간죄·간통죄를 중심으로 -", 형사법연구, 21(4), pp.295~314 (2009), 한국형사법학회
- 이준일, "트랜스젠더(transgender)의 헌법적 문제", 고려법학, (50), pp.39~75 (2008), 법학연구원
- 임웅, "형법각론" (2002), 법문사
- 정성근, "형법각론(제3판)" (2008), 삼지원
- 정영일, "형법각론(개정판)" (2008), 박영사
- 정현미, "성전환수술자의 강간죄의 객체 여부", 형사판례연구, 6 (1999), 형사판례연구회
- 정혜욱, "강간죄의 행위객체에 관한 연구", 석사, pp.2005
- 진계호, "형법각론(제6판)" (2008), 대왕사
- 최병무, "성전환증 환자에 대한 임상적 연구", 신경정신의학, 32(1) (1993), 대한신경정신의학회
- 한인섭, "성적 소수자의 인권" (2002), 사람생각
- 홍춘의, "성전환자의 성별 결정에 대한 법적 접근. in: 성적 소수자의 인권" (2002), 서울대학교 BK21 법학연구단 공익인권법센터
- Dahlian Kirby, "Transsexualism" (1998), Encyclopedia of Applied Ethics
- Greenberg, "Defining Male and Female: Intersexuality and Collision between Law and Biology, 41. Ariz. L. Riv", ~
- Clinical Psychiatry, 8th ed, "Synopsis of Psychiatry: Behavioral Sciences", pp.1998, Harold I