고전적 유라시아주의에 대한 비판적 고찰
A Critical Review of the Early Eurasianism
0
조회
0
다운로드
1
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
In the history of Russia intelligentsia's discussion on Russia's identity is summarized in two questions: where is Russia located in the process of world history and where does Russia go now. A long fervent debate on russian identity between East and West is a fairly typical example of this discussion. In this paper we focus on an early eurasianism, which shows well this intellectual tradition. First of all, we briefly examine the influence of old slavophile thinkers and V. S. Solov'ev on eurasianists. Then, we take a critical approach to the theories of the eurasianist movement: criticism of eurocentrism, emphasis on russian orthodoxy, ideocratia and development place. Above mentioned major issues of Eurasianism are criticised by us for their imperialism, messianic nationalism, totalitarianism, and geographic determinism. Eurasianists wishes to unify multinational country on the basis of 'Russian orthodoxy' and 'ideocratia', but the combination of these two factors strengthens conservatism and autocracy of Eurasianism.
Abstract
In the history of Russia intelligentsia's discussion on Russia's identity is summarized in two questions: where is Russia located in the process of world history and where does Russia go now. A long fervent debate on russian identity between East and West is a fairly typical example of this discussion. In this paper we focus on an early eurasianism, which shows well this intellectual tradition. First of all, we briefly examine the influence of old slavophile thinkers and V. S. Solov'ev on eurasianists. Then, we take a critical approach to the theories of the eurasianist movement: criticism of eurocentrism, emphasis on russian orthodoxy, ideocratia and development place. Above mentioned major issues of Eurasianism are criticised by us for their imperialism, messianic nationalism, totalitarianism, and geographic determinism. Eurasianists wishes to unify multinational country on the basis of 'Russian orthodoxy' and 'ideocratia', but the combination of these two factors strengthens conservatism and autocracy of Eurasianism.
참고문헌 (40)
- 김홍중, "유라시아주의의 제 양상: 지정학에서 지역주의로", 노어노문학, 26(1), pp.283~310 (2014), 한국노어노문학회
- 니콜라이 트루베츠코이, "유럽과 인류" (2012), 지만지
- 백준현, "러시아 이념: 그 사유의 역사" (2004), (주)제이엔씨
- 박영은, "사상운동으로서의 "유라시아주의" 태동과 확장에 대한 인문학적 성찰", e-Eurasia, 2014(51), pp.1~8 (2014)
- 박혜경, "신유라시아주의의 의미와 한계를 둘러싼 다양한 논쟁들", 노어노문학, 26(4), pp.377~402 (2014), 한국노어노문학회
- 송정수, "포스트식민주의적 관점에서 바라본 러시아 문화의 이중적 정체성", 러시아연구, 24(1), pp.117~149 (2014), 러시아연구소
- 신범식, "고전적 유라시아주의의 두 측면에 대한 일고찰", 러시아연구, 8(2), pp.249~295 (1998)
- 오원교, "신(新)유라시아주의 ― 세계화 시대의 러시아적 대안 문화론", 슬라브학보, 20(1), pp.165~193 (2005), 한국슬라브․유라시아학회
- 이기웅, "러시아와 유라시아", 러시아어문학연구논집, (49), pp.313~339 (2015), 한국러시아문학회
- 이지연, "유라시아 담론과 영토의 문제", e-Eurasia, 2014(51), pp.9~13 (2014)
- 임지현, "그대들의 자유 우리들의 자유 : 폴란드 민족해방 운동사" (2000), 아카넷
- 한정숙, "서양에서의 민족과 민족주의", pp.245~297 (1999), 까치
- 김명섭, "코리아, 러시아, 유라시아: 거대변동과 장기지속의 지정학", 한국과 국제정치, 26(1), pp.1~32 (2010), 극동문제연구소
- Бердяев Н. А., "Самопознание. Русская идея" (2009), ЭКСМО
- "Утопический этатизм евразийцев"[URL]
- "Евразийское пространство: Звук, слово, образ. Ответственный редактор Вяч. Вс" (2003), Языки славянской культуры
- "Евразийство (опыт систематического изложения)", pp.107~165 (2002), Арктогея центр
- "Евразийство (формулировка 1927 г.)", pp.166~179 (1927), Арктогея центр
- Жураковсий А., "Россия иВселенская Церковь: В. С. Соловьев и проблема религиозного икультурного единения человечества. Под общей редакцией В. Н. Поруса", pp.221~236 (2004), М.
- Зеньковский В., "История русской философии" (2001), Академический Проект
- "Ответ на статью Бердяева об евразийцах"[URL]
- "Лев Платонович Карсавин. Под ред. С. С. Хоружий" (2012), РОССПЭН
- Макаров В. Г., "“Pax rossica”. История евразийского движения исудьбы евразийцев", Вопросы философии, (2), pp.102~117 (2006)
- "От каких несчастий мы произошли?"[URL]
- Савицкий П. Н, "Географические особенности России, философияполитики" (1927), Евразийское книгоизд
- Соловьев В. С., "Сочинения в двух томах. Т. 2" (1989), Правда
- Соловьев В. С., "Сочинения в двух томах. Т. 2" (1988), Мысль
- Соловьев В. С, "Сочиненияв двух томах. Т. 2" (1988), Мысль
- Соловьев В. С., "Сочинения в двухтомах. Т. 2" (1989), Правда
- Соловьев В. С., "Сочинения в двух томах. Т. 2" (1988), Мысль
- "Полное собрание стихотворенийю"[URL]
- "Европа и Человечество"[URL]
- Трубецкой Н. С., "Наследие Чингисхана: Взгляд на русскуюисторию не с Запада, а с Востока" (2012), Эксмо
- Трубецкой Н. С., "Основы евразийства", pp.194~199 (2002), Арктогея центр
- Чаадаев П. Я., "Полное собраниесочинении и избранные письма в двух томах. Т. 1" (1991), Наука
- G.M. Hamburg, "A History of Russian Philosophy 1830-1930" (1930), Cambridge University Press
- William Leatherbarrow, "A History of Russian Thought" (2010), Cambridge University Press
- Dunlop John B., "The Rise of Russia and the Fall of the Soviet Empire" (1993), Princeton University Press
- Laruelle Marlène, "Russian Eurasianism: An Ideology of Empire. translated by Mischa Gabowitsch" (2008), Wilson Center Press
- Dmitry Shlapentokh, "Russia between East and West: Scholarly Debates on Eurasianism" (2007), Brill