본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

Relating History Education with National Identities on Modern State-Building: Korean and Chinese History Textbooks in Comparative Perspectives

0

조회

0

다운로드

0

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

주제분류정치외교학

초록

Despite the fact that both South Korea and China have similar past histories of being invaded and colonized by foreign powers, these two countries rarely have common acuities or shared recognition mechanisms. With this puzzling phenomenon, this study compares Korean and Chinese high school history textbooks to reveal their own national identities which are embedded and forged in the textbook discourses. It sets out to locate what Chinese and Korean governments’ national identities have echoed in history textbooks of senior high schools by investigating ‘language use,’ employing ethnomethodology to shed light on the perception gap between the two countries. The perception gap between Korea and China, which has appeared in history textbooks, becomes a potential powerhouse producing various malaises of identity-based struggles stemming from organized delusions on each other.

Abstract

Despite the fact that both South Korea and China have similar past histories of being invaded and colonized by foreign powers, these two countries rarely have common acuities or shared recognition mechanisms. With this puzzling phenomenon, this study compares Korean and Chinese high school history textbooks to reveal their own national identities which are embedded and forged in the textbook discourses. It sets out to locate what Chinese and Korean governments’ national identities have echoed in history textbooks of senior high schools by investigating ‘language use,’ employing ethnomethodology to shed light on the perception gap between the two countries. The perception gap between Korea and China, which has appeared in history textbooks, becomes a potential powerhouse producing various malaises of identity-based struggles stemming from organized delusions on each other.

참고문헌 (57)

  1. Adler, Patricia A., "Everyday Life Sociology", Annual Review of Sociology, 13, pp.217~235 (1987)
  2. Ahonen, Sirkka, "Politics of Identity through History Curriculum: Narratives of the Past for Social Exclusion – or Inclusion?", Journal of Curriculum Studies, 33(2), pp.179~194 (2001)
  3. Anderson, Benedict, "Imagined Communities: Reflections on the Origin and Spread of Nationalism" (1991), Verso
  4. Balibar, Etienne, "Becoming National: A Reader", pp.132~149 (1991), Oxford University Press
  5. Billing, Michael, "Banal Nationalism" (1995), Sage
  6. Buzan, Barry, "The ‘Standard of Civilisation’ as an English School Concept", Millennium: Journal of International Studies, 42(3), pp.576~594 (2014)
  7. Dong, Xiangrong, "Viewing Koreans’ Views on China from History Textbooks", International Forum, 14(6), pp.45~50 (2012)
  8. Duara, Prasenjit, "Becoming National: A Reader", pp.151~177 (1995), Oxford University Press
  9. Fox, Jon E., "Everyday Nationhood", Ethnicities, 8(4), pp.536~563 (2008)
  10. Goh, Evelyn, "Contesting International Society in East Asia", pp.167~187 (2014), Cambridge University Press
  11. Hjerm, Mikael, "National Identities, National Pride and Xenophobia: A Comparison of Four Western Countries", Acta Sociologica, 41(4), pp.335~347 (1998)
  12. Hobsbawm, Eric. J, "Nations and Nationalism Since 1780" (1992), Cambridge University Press
  13. Hroch, Miroslav, "Becoming National: A Reader", pp.60~77 (1993), Oxford University Press
  14. Huntington, Samuel P, "Who Are We?: The Challenges to America’s National Identity" (2004), Simon & Schuster
  15. Ichijo, Atsuko, "Debate on Understanding National Identity by David McCrone and Frank Bechhofer", Nations and Nationalism, 23(3), pp.441~462 (2017)
  16. Im, Sang-Sŏn, "Comparison of History Textbooks in China, Taiwan, and Hong Kong" (2008), Northeast Asian History Foundation
  17. Jessen, Mathias Hein, "Governmentality and Statification: Towards a Foucauldian Theory of the State", Theory, Culture & Society, 37(1), pp.53~72 (2019)
  18. 강택구, "역사교육과 국가 이미지의 상관관계에 대한 연구 -대한민국 중등학교 역사교육이 중국 국가 이미지에 어떤 영향을 끼치는가에 대한 설문조사 분석을 중심으로-", 경주사학, (32), pp.145~173 (2010), 경주사학회
  19. Kim, Ji-Hun, "Descriptions of Korea in the Experimental History Textbooks Followed by the History Curriculum Standards in China", Korean Modern and Contemporary History, 36, pp.208~239 (2006)
  20. Kim, Jong-Bak, "The Unified Multiethnic Nation Theory in Chinese History Textbooks" (2011), Northeast Asian History Foundation
  21. Kim, Jong-Hyŏn, "The Political Space of Memory: History Education and Nationalism in East Asia through Museums" (2014), Northeast Asian History Foundation
  22. Kim, Yu-Kyŏng, "Collective Memory and History Education Textbooks in Nation-States", pp.396~411 (2002), Changbi Publishers
  23. Ku, Nan-Hui, "Recognition of the Nation Problems, and the Treatment Regarding Koguryo and Palhae in China", Social Studies Education, 13(2), pp.87~112 (2006)
  24. 권소연, "한ㆍ중 양국의 역사인식과 중ㆍ고교 역사학습론 비교", 역사교육연구, (3), pp.209~256 (2006), 한국역사교육학회
  25. Lemke, Thomas, "Foucault, Governmentality, and Critique" (2012), Routlege
  26. Li, Yingshun, "Research Status and Development Trend of History Education in China and South Korea", Yanbian University Bulletin, 50(4), pp.115~120 (2017)
  27. Lubbers, Marcel, "What Kind of Nationalism Sets the Radical Right and its Electorate Apart From the Rest? Pride in the Nation’s History as Part of Nationalist Nostalgia", Nations and Nationalism, 25(2), pp.449~466 (2019)
  28. McCrone, David, "Understanding National Identity" (2015), Cambridge University Press
  29. McNeill, William H, "Keeping Together in Time: Dance and Drill in Human History" (1995), Harvard University Press
  30. Miller, David, "On Nationality" (1995), Oxford University Press
  31. Miller, David, "Citizenship and National Identity" (2000), Polity Press
  32. High School Curriculum Commentary on Sociology, "History", Ministry of Education, Science and Technology, 2009, Ministry of Education, Notification No. 2015-78
  33. Compulsory Education History Curriculum Standard, "Ministry of Education of the People’s Republic of China", Beijing Normal University Press, ~ (2011)
  34. Morgan, Katalin, "Designing a Tool for History Textbook Analysis", Forum: Qualitative Social Research, 14(1) (2013)
  35. Korean History Textbook, "National Institute of Korean History", National Institute of Korean History, ~ (2010)
  36. Niu, Jun, "Introduction to History of Foreign Relations of the People’s Republic of China (1949-2000)" (2014), Peking University Press
  37. 오병수, "국내 학계의 중국 역사교과서 연구 경향과 과제", 동북아역사논총, (53), pp.147~170 (2016), 동북아역사재단[DOI]
  38. 박재영, "역사교과서‧이미지‧스테레오타입 - 한‧중 역사교과서에 나타난 상호 이미지의 비교분석을 중심으로 -", 경주사학, (30), pp.134~174 (2009), 경주사학회
  39. Pak, Jŏng-Hyŏn, "China’s Historical Perception of the Sino-Japanese War and the Direction of History Education", Chinese Modern History Studies, 20, pp.53~76 (2003)
  40. Ordinary High School Curriculum Standard (Experiment) History Textbook Mandatory 1, "People’s Education Press Institute of Curriculum Materials", People’s Education Press, ~ (2007)
  41. Ordinary High School Curriculum Standard (Experiment) History Textbook Mandatory 2, "People’s Education Press Institute of Curriculum Materials", People’s Education Press, ~ (2007)
  42. Ordinary High School Curriculum Standard (Experiment) History Textbook Mandatory 3, "People’s Education Press Institute of Curriculum Materials", People’s Education Press, ~ (2007)
  43. Qi, Zhanyong, "The Evolutionary Logic and Future Choices of China’s Ordinary High School Education Policy in the 40 Years of Reform and Opening", Elementary Education, 15(6), pp.32~38 (2018)
  44. Richards, Benjamin, "National Identity and Social Cohesion: Theory and Evidence for British Social Policy", Ph.D, pp.2013
  45. Samra-Fredericks, Dalvir, "The Handbook of Business Discourse", pp.92~104 (2009), Edinburgh University Press
  46. Smith, Anthony D, "Becoming National: A Reader", pp.106~130 (1989), Oxford University Press
  47. Smith, Anthony D, "National Identity" (1991), Penguin Books
  48. Smith, Tom W., "National Pride in Comparative Perspective: 1995", 96 and 2003, International Journal of Public Opinion Research, pp.2006, 18(1)[DOI]
  49. Toulmin, Stephen Edelston, "The Uses of Argument" (2003), Cambridge University Press
  50. Vickers, Edward, "History Education and National Identity in East Asia" (2005), Routledge
  51. Wang, Xi, "A Review of Research on the Curriculum Reform of History Education for Secondary Schools in Ten Years", Review on Modern Education and Scientific Secondary Education, 59, pp.129~131 (2014)
  52. Yan, Xuetong, "From Hiding the Capacity and Keeping a Low Profile to Striving for Achievements", Chinese Politics and International Politics, 4, pp.1~35 (2014)
  53. Ye, Min, "The Belt Road and Beyond: State-Mobilized Globalization in China, 1998-2018" (2020), Cambridge University Press
  54. 유용태, "역사교과서 속의 민주주의: 한중일 3국 비교", 역사교육, (132), pp.39~69 (2014), 역사교육연구회
  55. 윤세병, "중국 역사교과서의 서사 구조와 이데올로기", 역사교육연구, (18), pp.47~87 (2013), 한국역사교육학회[DOI]
  56. Zhang, Yongjin, "The ‘English School’ in China: A Travelogue of Ideas and their Diffusion", European Journal of International Relations, 9(1), pp.87~114 (2003)
  57. Zhu, Zhiqun, "Interpreting China’s ‘Wolf-Warrior Diplomacy’: What Explains the Sharper Tone to China’s Overseas Conduct Recently?", The Diplomat, ~ (2020)

관련 논문AI추천

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (3건)