논문KCI 등재
결정론과 도덕적 책임의 양립 가능성
Compatibility of Determinism and Moral Responsibility
0
조회
0
다운로드
6
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
주제분류철학
초록
필자는 이 글에서 인간의 행위를 포함해서 모든 사건은 선행하는 원인 조건에 의해 결정된다는 결정론의 기본 주장을 승인하는 한편, 결정론과 도덕적 책임에 간한 논쟁의 핵심 용어인 “원인”과 “자유”의 의미 분석을 통해 “원인에 의한 행위”가 “자유롭지 못한 행위”를 뜻하는 것이 아님을 밝힘으로써, 도덕적 책임이 결정론과 양립할 수 있음을 밝힌다.
Abstract
Some philosophers have maintained that if determinism hold, then we can not place moral responsibility for one's behavior on the agent. Is it true? The answers depend on the meanings of two key words, i.e., "cause" and "freedom." So, in this paper, I will make clear that "behavior by cause" does not means "lack of freedom." and then I will assert that moral responsibili쇼 can be compatible with determinism.
참고문헌 (34)
- Aristotle, "Nicomachean Ethics Ⅲ" (1953), Penguin, Harmondworth
- Aune, B, "Hypotheticals and ‘Can’:Another Look", Analysis, 27 (1967)
- "Free Will, Can, and Ethics: A Reply to Lehrer", Analysis, 30 (1970)
- Austin,J.L, "Ifs and Cans(New Readings in Philosophical Analysis)" (1956), Appleton Century Crofts, N.Y
- Ayer, A.J, "Freedom and Necessity(Philosophical Essays" (1954), Macmillan, London
- "Freedom and Morality and Other Essays" (1984), Clarlendon, Oxford
- Beardsley, E.L, "Determinism and Moral Perspectives", Philosophy and Phenomenological Research (1960)
- Benn, S.I, "Human Action and the Limitation of Causal Explantation(A Modern Introduction to the Philosophy)" (1959), The Free Press
- Campbell, C.A., "Is Free Will Pseudo-Problem?", Mind, 60 (1951)
- Chisholm, R.M, "Freedom and Action(Freedom and Determinism" (1976), Humanities, N.J
- Davidson, D, "Essays on Action and Events" (1980), Clarlendon, Oxford
- Edward, P., "Hard Determinism and Soft Determinism(Introductory Readings in Ethics)" (1958), Prentice Hall
- Edward. P., "A Modern Introduction to Philosophy" (1973), The Free Press
- Frankena, W.K, "Ethics" (1973), Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs
- Frankfurt, H.G, "Freedom of the Will and Concept of a Person", Journal of Philosophy, 68 (1971)
- Grunbaum, A, "Free Will and Law of Human Behavior(New Readings in Philosophical Analysis)" (1972), Appleton Century Crofts, N.Y
- Hobbes, T., "Leviathan" (1962), Collins, London
- Hospers, J., "An Introduction to Philosophical Analysis" (1988), Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs
- "Human Conduct" (1972), Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, Inc
- "Free Will and Psychoanalysis(A Modern Introduction to Philosophy)" (1950), The Free Press
- Hume, D., "A Treatise of Human Nature" (1951), Oxford University Press
- Selby-Begge, "A Treatise of Human Understanding" (1958), Clarendon, Oxford
- Lehrer, K., "Could and Determinism", Analysis, 24 (1963)
- "Cans without Ifs", Analysis, 28 (1968)
- Locke, J., "An Essay concerning Human Understanding" (1975), Clarendon, Oxford
- Moore.G.E., "Ethics" (1912), Oxford University, N.Y
- Nowell-Smith, P., "Free Will and Moral Responsibility", Mind, 57 (1948)
- Schlick, M, "When is a Man Responsible?(A Modern Introduction to the Philosophy)" (1939), The Free Press
- Stevenson, C., "Ethics and Language" (1945), Yale University
- Strawson, P., "Freedom and Resentment(Proceeding of the British Academy)" (1962)
- Taylor, R., "Action and Purpose" (1966), Prentice Hall, N.J
- Taylor, P.W., "Principles of Ethics=윤리학의 기본원리" (1985), 서광사
- Warnock, M., "Ethics Since 1900" (1967), Oxford University, London
- Watson, G., "Free Will=자유의지와 결정론" (1982), 서광사
관련 논문AI추천
자유의지는 도덕적인 책임의 필요조건인가?안건훈한국동서철학회 · 동서철학연구2003 · 제28호설명, 도덕적 책임, 그리고 양립 불가능론이은홍, 이재호중앙철학연구소 · 철학탐구2016 · 제42권 느껴지는 것으로서의 자유김은희한국윤리학회(8A3209) · 윤리학2017 · 제6권 제2호도덕적 책임과 본래성 교육김희봉한국교육철학회 · 교육철학2012 · 제46호자유의지에 대한 조작논증과 근원-양립가능주의의 대응김성수한국논리학회 · 논리연구2018 · 제21권 제3호도덕적 책임에 관한 프랑크퍼트의 이해이상희한국윤리학회 · 倫理硏究2018 · 제1권 제123호