미국·일본의 해외 법정비 지원 활동에 대한 분석을 통해 본한국의 법정비 지원 활동의 나아가야 할 방향
An analysis of legal technical assistance of the USA and Japan and the implications for our assistance activities
0
조회
0
다운로드
1
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Today, there is growing interest for legal technical assistances, which are beingperformed by the developed countries to support legal system reform of theunderdeveloped or developing countries. Recently, Korea recognizes also the need forlegal technical assistance for developing countries and will be therefore actively involvedin it. For us, there is continuing interest in the ‘hardware’ for performing legal technicalassistance, but the research for the field of ‘software’, which can be the contents of‘hardware’, is not yet enough. Above all, many things are unclear, for example, ① underwhich ideas the legal technical assistance must be performed, ② which goals must beachieved with it, ③ in which way each project can be selected and efficiently performed,④ which countries and what should be supported, ⑤ with which attitude we shouldwork in performing legal technical assistance and what should not be overlooked etc. In this paper, I tried to get implications for the raised issues through the analysis oflegal technical assistance performed by the United States and Japan. Legal technical assistance is a very tough business, which needs a lot of effort andtakes long time. To achieve great success in this area, the basic idea of it should beclearly recognized, the comprehensive and long-term plan should be designed, and eachproject should be step-by-step performed. Otherwise, the resulting waste of manpowerand money, conflicts and overlap between each project and project might occur. Thus,it is thought to be inevitable the installation of the control tower, which supports andcoordinates each organization and each project. In addition, to our success of legal technical assistance, the overall effort is required,for example, national effort, academic support, cooperation of NGOs and evenparticipation of companies.
Abstract
Today, there is growing interest for legal technical assistances, which are beingperformed by the developed countries to support legal system reform of theunderdeveloped or developing countries. Recently, Korea recognizes also the need forlegal technical assistance for developing countries and will be therefore actively involvedin it. For us, there is continuing interest in the ‘hardware’ for performing legal technicalassistance, but the research for the field of ‘software’, which can be the contents of‘hardware’, is not yet enough. Above all, many things are unclear, for example, ① underwhich ideas the legal technical assistance must be performed, ② which goals must beachieved with it, ③ in which way each project can be selected and efficiently performed,④ which countries and what should be supported, ⑤ with which attitude we shouldwork in performing legal technical assistance and what should not be overlooked etc. In this paper, I tried to get implications for the raised issues through the analysis oflegal technical assistance performed by the United States and Japan. Legal technical assistance is a very tough business, which needs a lot of effort andtakes long time. To achieve great success in this area, the basic idea of it should beclearly recognized, the comprehensive and long-term plan should be designed, and eachproject should be step-by-step performed. Otherwise, the resulting waste of manpowerand money, conflicts and overlap between each project and project might occur. Thus,it is thought to be inevitable the installation of the control tower, which supports andcoordinates each organization and each project. In addition, to our success of legal technical assistance, the overall effort is required,for example, national effort, academic support, cooperation of NGOs and evenparticipation of companies.
참고문헌 (31)
- 체제전환국 법정비지원사업의 현황과 과제(2004년 법무부 연구용역 보고서), "권오승", 아시아법연구소, ~ (2004)
- 박광동, "법제수출사업의 이념과 과제" (2008), 한국법제연구원
- 박근서, "법제수출 : 법률 컨텐츠, 법률정보시스템, 법률교육 수출을 통해 개방원조(ODA) 중점사업으로 육성해야", 법제 (2011), 법제처
- 법무부, "베트남 개혁개방법제 개관", 법무자료 제263집, ~ (2005)
- 심동섭, "세계화와 법의 교류" (2006), 해든
- 윤대규, "주요국가의 개도국에 대한 법제정비 지원 사업", 통일문제연구, 20(1), pp.97~144 (2008), 평화문제연구소
- 이성환, "우리나라 법제협력사업의 이념적ㆍ실천적 과제", 법제 (2012), 법제처
- 법제수출을 위한 기본전략과 과제(2012년 법제처 용역 보고서), "이성환", ~ (2012)
- 이준현, "일본의 캄보디아 민법 제정 지원과 제정된 민법의 내용", 법조, 60(5), pp.161~213 (2011), 법조협회
- 이준현, "체제전환국 법정비 지원 활동과 일본 - 베트남에 대한 지원을 중심으로 -", 비교사법, 16(1), pp.195~226 (2009), 한국비교사법학회
- 전병서, "일본의 아시아 체제 전환국(베트남, 캄보디아 등)에 대한 법정비지원에 관한 연구", 인권과 정의, (364), pp.117~131 (2006), 대한변호사협회
- ABA Rule of Law Initiative, "Promoting Justice, Economic Opportunity and Human Dignity", ~ (2013)
- David M. Trubek, "Scholars in Self-Estrangement: Some Reflections on the Crisis in Law and Development Studies in the United States", Wisconsin Law Review, (4) (1974)
- 吉澤敏行, "法律家の國際協力-日弁連 の國際司法支援活動の實踐と展望" (2012), 現代人文社
- 獨立行政法人 國際協力機構, "課題別指針 法整備支援", 平成 23년(2011) 3월, ~ (2011)
- 上柳敏郞, "法律家の國際協力-日弁連 の國際司法支援活動の實踐と展望" (2012), 現代人文社
- 松尾弘, "良い統治と法の支配―開発法学の挑戦" (2009), 日本評論社
- 榊原信次, "ベトナム法整備支援體驗記" (2006), 信山社
- 日本辯護士連合會, "法律家の國際協力-日弁連の國際司法支援活動の實踐と展望" (2012), 現代人文 社
- 鮎京正訓, "アジア法ガイドブック" (2009), 名古屋大学出版会
- 佐藤直史, "法律家の國際協力-日弁連の國際司法支援活動の實踐と展望" (2012), 現代人文社
- 香川孝三, "法整備支援論:制度構築の國際協力入門" (2007), ミネルヴァ書房
