Enactivism을 Enact하기: 번역의 문제를 중심으로
Enacting enactivism: Concerning the translation problem
1
조회
0
다운로드
20
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Enactivism은 체화된 인지의 여러 논의들 중 가장 전복적이고 영향력 있는 접근이다. 하지만 태동한 지 20여년의 세월이 흘렀고, 그 포괄 범위와 성과에서 명실상부 하나의 패러다임으로 자리 잡은 지금까지, 이 이론이 국내 인지과학자들 사이에서는 여전히 낯설고 새로운 접근으로 받아들여지는 것은 안타까운 일이다. 이러한 현실은 부분적으로는 Enactivism이 지니는 본래의 파격이나 심오함 때문이기도 하겠지만, 번역어의 혼란 또한 크게 한 몫을 한 것으로 보인다. 따라서 본 논문은 Enactivism의 철학적, 이론적 관점을 그 역사적 맥락과 개념적 지형을 중심으로 살펴보고, ‘발제(發製)’ ‘구성(構成)’, ‘행위화(行爲化)’ 등의 한국어 번역들이 그 철학적, 이론적 함축을 어떻게 포착하고 해석하고 있는지를 살펴본다. 나아가 이미 출간된 번역어 외에 ‘실행(實行)’과 수행(遂行/修行), 작동(作動)의 다른 번역어들을 검토한다. 이러한 시도는 철학적 난해함이나 번역어의 생소함이 야기한 심리적 장벽을 넘어, Enactivism이 국내 인지과학자들 사이에서 합당하게 주목 받는 계기를 마련하기 위해서이며, 더불어 마음에 대한 서구적 전통과 동양적 전통을 통합적으로 조망하고 실천하고자 했던 바렐라(1946–2001)의 노력이 한국의 철학 전통 안에서 풍성한 결실을 얻기를 바라는 마음에서이다.
Abstract
Enactivism is the most influential and groundbreaking approach among the various theories of embodied cognition. Despite of it's impact and relatively long history, however, Enactivism is still considered as a new and unfamiliar theory in the Korean academic society. Even though this might be partly due to the genuine depth and dramatic approach of Enactivism, it is also due to the disagreement of Korean translation of Enactivism. This paper reviews the philosophical and theoretical implications of Enactivism in the context of history and conceptual terrain, and discusses how the various tranlated Korean words of ‘Enaction’ - ‘발제(發製)’ ‘구성(構成)’, or ‘행위화(行爲化)’- embraced and interpreted the essence of philosophy and concept of ‘Enaction’ and ‘Enactivism’. Furthermore, we offer several alternatives Korean translations of ‘Enaction’: ‘실행(實行)’, 수행(遂行/修行), or 작동(作動). Through this discussion, we hope to provide an opportunity for Korean researchers and philosophers to direct their attention to Enactivism properly and to make a common ground for further development of Enactivism in Korea.
참고문헌 (68)
- 김향선, "하이데거의 기술", 대동철학, 11, pp.63~92 (2000)
- 최호영, "앎의 나무" (2007), 갈무리
- 유권종, "윤리적 노하우" (2009), 도서출판 갈무리
- 바렐라, "인지과학의 철학적 이해" (1997), 옥토
- 바렐라, "몸의 인지과학" (2013), 김영사
- 박충식, "구성적 인공지능", 인지과학, 15(4), pp.61~66 (2004), 한국인지과학회
- 박충식, "윤리적 노하우" (2009), 갈무리
- 박충식, "새로운 도덕 심성 모델: 퇴계학, 구성주의, 인공지능", 한국철학자대회 논문집 (2004)
- 베르그손, "물질과 기억" (2005), 아카넷
- 벤야민, "발터 벤야민의 문예이론" (1983), 민음사
- 김옥희, "번역어의 성립" (2011), 마음산책
- 양일모, "번역문화로 본 일본의 근대,번역어의 성립해설" (2011), 마음산책
- 윤성우, "번역학과 번역철학" (2013), HUEBOOKs
- 이정모, "인지과학: 학문간 융합의 원리와 응용" (2009), 성균관대학교 출판부
- 폴라니, "거대한 전환: 우리 시대의 정치 경제적 기원" (2009), 길
- Bateson, G., "Steps to an ecology of mind" (1972), Ballantine Books
- Ben-Zeeve, A., "Rethinking Knowledge: Reflections across the Disciplines", pp.41~56 (1995), SUNY
- Bishop J. M., "Second-order cybernetics and enactive perception", Kybernetes, 34(9, pp.10) (2005), 1309~1320
- Bruner, J. S., "Toward a theory of instruction" (1966), Belkapp Press
- Bruner, J. S., "The Narrative Construction of Reality", Critical Inquiry, 18(1), pp.1~21 (1991)
- Clark, A., "Doing without representing", Synthese, 101, pp.401~431 (1994)
- Davis, J. I., ""Embodied Cognition as a Practical Paradigm : Introduction to the Topic, The Future of Embodied Cognition"", Topics in Cognitive Science, 4(4), pp.685~691 (2012)
- De Jaegher, H., ""Participatory sense-making : An enactive approach to social cognition"", Phenomenology and the Cognitive Sciences, 6(4), pp.485~507 (2007)
- Di Paolo E., "The Routledge Handbook of Embodied Cognition" (2014), Routledge Press
- Di Paolo, E. A., "Enaction: Towards a New Paradigm for Cognitive Science", pp.33~87 (2010), MIT Press
- Fodor, J. A., "The Language of Thought" (1975), Harvard University Press
- Gibson, J. J., "The Ecological Approach to Visual Perception" (1979), Lawrence Erlbaum Associates
- Glasersfeld, E. von., "Radical Constructivism: A Way of Knowing and Learning" (1995), Falmer Press
- Hayles, N. K., "How we became posthuman: Virtual bodies in cybernetics, literature, and informatics" (1999), The University of Chicago Press
- Hurley, S., "Consciousness in Action" (1998), Harvard University Press
- Hurley, S., "The Shared Circuits Model: How Control, Mirroring and Simulation Can Enable Imitation, Deliberation, and Mindreading", Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 31, pp.1~58 (2008)
- Hutchins, E., "Cognition in the Wild" (1995), MIT Press
- Johnson, M., "The Body in the Mind: The Bodily Basis of Meaning, Imagination, and Reason" (1987), University of Chicago Press
- Juarero, A., "Dynamics in Action" (1999), MIT Press
- Lakoff, G., "Metaphors We Live By" (1980), University of Chicago Press
- Lakoff, G., "Philosophy in the Flesh: the Embodied Mind and its Challenge to Western Thought" (1999), Basic Books
- Liberman, A. M., "Perception of the speech code", Psychological review, 74(6), pp.431~461 (1967)
- Liberman, A. M., "The discrimination of speech sounds within and across phoneme boundaries", Journal of experimental psychology, 54(5), pp.358~368 (1957)
- Luhman, N., "Social systems" (1995), Stanford University Press
- Lutz A., "Neurophenomenology: Integrating Subjective Experience and Brain Dynamics in the Neuroscience of Consciousness", Journal of Consciousness Studies, 10, pp.31~52 (2003)
- Maturana H., "Autopoiesis and cognition: The realization of the living" (1980)
- Maturana, H., "The Tree of Knowledge: The biological roots of human understanding" (1992), Shamabala
- McMullin, B., "Rediscovering computational autopoiesis" (1997), Santa Fe Institute
- Merleau-Ponty, M., "Phenomenology of perception" (1962), Rouledge & Kegan Paul
- Merleau-Ponty, M., "The Structure of Behavior" (1963), Dusequesne University Press
- Noe, A., "Action in Perception" (2004), MIT Press
- O'Regan, K., "A Sensorimotor Account of Vision and Visual Consciousness", Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 24, pp.939~1031 (2001)
- Petitot, J., "Naturalizing Phenomenology: Contemporary Issues in Phenomenology and Cognitive Science" (1999), Stanford University Press
- Piaget, J., "Origins of intelligence in the child" (1936), Routledge & Kegan Paul
- Proulx, J., "Some Differences between Maturana and Varela's Theory of Cognition and Constructivism", Complicity: An International Journal of Complexity and Education, 5(1), pp.11~26 (2008)
- Reid, D. A., ""Enaction: An Incomplete Paradigm for Consciousness Science", Review of "Enaction: Toward a New Paradigm for Cognitive Science" Edited by John Stewart, Olivier Gapenne and Ezequiel A. Di Paolo", Constructivist Foundations, 7(1), pp.81~83 (2011)
- Rohde, M., "Enaction, Embodiment, Evolutionary Robotics: Simulation Models for a Post-Cognitivist Science of Mind" (2010), Atlantis Press
- Rorty, R., "Philosophy and the Mirror of Nature" (1979), Princeton University Press
- Shannon, E. C., "A Mathematical Theory of Communication", Bell System Technical Journal, 27, pp.379~423 (1948)
- Shapiro, L., "Embodied Cognition" (2011), Routledge
- Thompson E., "Making Sense of Sense-Making: Reflections on Enactive and Extended Mind Theories", Topoi, 28, pp.23~30 (2009)
- Thompson E., "Radical Embodiment: Neural Dynamics and Consciousness", Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 5(10), pp.418~425 (2001)
- Turvey, M. T., "Affordances and prospective control: An outline of the ontology", Ecological Psychology, 4(3), pp.173~187 (1992)
- Uexkull, J. von, "Instinctive behavior: The development of modern concept", pp.5~80 (1934), International Universities Press
- Varela F., "Principles of Biological Autonomy", pp.1979, Elsevier
- Varela, F., "Gaia: A way of knowing", pp.48~64 (1987), Lindisfarne Press
- Varela, F., "The Naturalization of Phenomenology as the Transcendence of Nature: searching for generative mutual constraints", Alter: Revue de Phenomenologie, 5, pp.355~385 (1997)
- Varela, F., "Ethical Know-How" (1999), Stanford University Press
- Varela, F., "Truth is what works: Francisco J. Varela on cognitive science, buddhism, the inseparability of subject and object, and the exaggerations of constructivism-a conversation", Journal of Aesthetic Education, 40(1), pp.35~53 (2006)
- Varela, F., "The View from Within: First-Person Methodologies" (1999), Imprint Academic
- Varela, F. J., "The Early Days of Autopoiesis: Heinz and Chile", Systems Research, 13(3), pp.407~416 (1996)
- Varela, F., "The embodied mind: Cognitive science and human experience" (1991), MIT Press
- Wittgenstein, L., "Philosophical investigations" (1958), Basil Blackwell