다자간환경협정과 WTO협정의 융합 - 통합적 해석방법을 중심으로 -
Conciliation between MEAs and WTO Agreements
0
조회
0
다운로드
5
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Abstract
A matter is that the regulation of international environmental concerns, however categorized, generally entails the applications of international law as a whole. The sometimes difficult question is how to do so in an integrated and coherent manner. Given the great variety of potentially relevant environmental and other treaties and rules and principles of general international law, how do we determine their precise interaction? I considered this question in the context of comparison with WTO agreements. We could reach the interesting conclusion on this issue. In the event of a true conflict between WTO law and certain multilateral environmental agreement (MEA), the latter will prevail by virtue of Article 41 of the Vienna Convention. The necessary assumption, of course, is that the MEA provisions in question are 'integral' agreements for the common benefit of all states, form which of principally bilateral relations, form which derogation inter se will usually be permissible. Conflict and fragmentation are necessary consequences of the interaction of international environmental law with other branches of international law. In practice, international courts and tribunals have found various ways of applying international law as an integrated whole. Rule of interpretation, priority of treaties, or a balancing of competing interests have generally provided an ample range of techniques for promoting coherence in the application of international law.
참고문헌 (20)
- 성재호, "국제경제법 개정판", pp.346~ (2006), 박영사
- 이은섭, "WTO체제하의 무역과 환경의 연계", 무역학회지, 30(3), pp.75~99 (2005), 한국무역학회
- "WTO Trade and Environment committee Agrees on Work Programme, Trade & Env't News Bull.", Information and Media Relations Division of the GATT, 3~ (1995)
- Ashif H. Qureshi, "The World Trade Organization", 9~ (1996)
- A. E. Boyle, "Relationship between International Environmental Law and Other Branches of International Law in The Oxford Handbook of International Environmental Law", pp.127~ (2007), Oxford University Press
- J. Pauwelyn, "Conflict of Norms in Public International Law", pp.369~ (2003), Cambridge University Press
- P. Reuter, "Introduction to the Law of Treaties", pp.132~ (1995), Kegan Paul International
- I. Sinclair, "The Vienna Convention on Treaties, 2nd edition", pp.96~ (1984), Manchester University Press
- A. Watt, "Law of Treaties in The International Law Commission 1949-1998, Volume 2", pp.678~ (1999), Oxford University Press
- Mike Meier, "GATT, WTO, and the Environment: To What Extent Do GATT", WTO Rules Permit Member Nations to Protect th Environment When Doing So Adversely Affects Trade, 1997, pp.8, 247~
- Bruce Neuling, "The Shrimp-Turtle case: Implications for Article XX of GATT and the Trade and Environment Debate", Loy. L.A. Int'l & Comp. L. Rev., 22, pp.1~ (1999)
- John H. Jackson, "World Trade Rules and Environmental Polices: congruence of Conflict?", Wash & Lee L. Rev., 49, pp.1240~ (1992)
- 최승환, "국제경제법 제3판", pp.688~ (2006), 법영사
- E. Pertsman, "International and European Trade and Environmental Law after th Uruguay Round", pp.155~161 (1995), Klwer Law international
- 장 신, "地球溫暖化防止에 관한 교토의정서의 國際法的 考察", 국제법학회논총, 45(2), pp.189~210 (2000), 대한국제법학회
- 이재형, "교토메커니즘의 국제통상법적 분석", 안암법학, 통(25), pp.577~599 (2007), 안암법학회
- European Communities-Measures Affecting Asbestos and Asbestos Containing Products, adopted by DSB 5 April 2001, WTO Appellate Body Roport, , ~, pp.WT (2001), DS135[DOI]
- I. Brownlie, "Principles of Public International Law, 6th edition", pp.276~ (2003), Oxford University Press
- Final Report of th Expert croup Workshop in International Environmental Law Aiming at Sustainable Development, , ~, pp.UNEP (1996), IEL[DOI]
- V. Lowe, "Sustainable Development and Unsustainable Argument in International Law and Sustainable Development", pp.31~ (1999), Oxford University Press