독일과 한국에서의 경찰책임(특히 행위책임)의 승계 -2006년 3월 16일자의 독일연방행정대법원 판결을 중심으로-
Die Rechtsnachfolge in Polizei – und Ordnungspflichten[Verhaltenshaftung] im deutschen und koreanischen Recht – als Mittelpunkt von der Entscheidung BVerwG, Urteil v. 16. 3. 2006 – 7C 3. 05, JZ 2006, 1124ff
0
조회
0
다운로드
2
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
This research seeks how to protect Sexual Assault victims in the criminal justice process after the abolishment of crime to compliant on the crimes of rape in 2012, examining the legal and political grounds of crime to compliant on sexual crimes and the effects of this abolishment and investigating the colorful needs of victims who accused their offenders by conducting an empirical study on the 260 counseling journals recorded at the Korean Sexual Violence Relief Center from 2008 to 2010. This crime to compliant aims to protect victims’ privacy and reputation because of the cultural context in Korea, where exist the social stigma and condemn against sexual assault victims. However, this code has not only protected victims but also shifted the burden by punishment to the offenders on them. Even though victims can be protected by the abolishment of crime to compliant on the crimes of rape in this context, some victims might need the system to focus on the victim’s unwillingness to punish. The empirical study on the counseling journals shows that the victims’ privacy can be violated during the criminal justice process because of social stigma against sexual assault victims and secondary victimization during criminal justice process, and that the victims view criminal settlement as one of the options for resolving the crime through apologies and regret from the offender and restoring from the harm caused by the crime. These results can give directions for protection of sexual assault victims’ privacy in the criminal justice process.
Abstract
This research seeks how to protect Sexual Assault victims in the criminal justice process after the abolishment of crime to compliant on the crimes of rape in 2012, examining the legal and political grounds of crime to compliant on sexual crimes and the effects of this abolishment and investigating the colorful needs of victims who accused their offenders by conducting an empirical study on the 260 counseling journals recorded at the Korean Sexual Violence Relief Center from 2008 to 2010. This crime to compliant aims to protect victims’ privacy and reputation because of the cultural context in Korea, where exist the social stigma and condemn against sexual assault victims. However, this code has not only protected victims but also shifted the burden by punishment to the offenders on them. Even though victims can be protected by the abolishment of crime to compliant on the crimes of rape in this context, some victims might need the system to focus on the victim’s unwillingness to punish. The empirical study on the counseling journals shows that the victims’ privacy can be violated during the criminal justice process because of social stigma against sexual assault victims and secondary victimization during criminal justice process, and that the victims view criminal settlement as one of the options for resolving the crime through apologies and regret from the offender and restoring from the harm caused by the crime. These results can give directions for protection of sexual assault victims’ privacy in the criminal justice process.
참고문헌 (58)
- 김동희, "행정법 Ⅱ" (2010), 박영사
- 김연태, "경찰책임의 승계" (2008), 고려법학
- 김철용, "행정법 Ⅱ" (2010), 박영사
- 박균성, "경찰행정법" (2010), 博英社
- 朴尙熙, "Altlasten과 경찰책임", 공법학연구, 3(2), pp.219~239 (2002), 한국비교공법학회
- 정형근, "최신행정법강의(하)" (2009), 박영사
- 손재영, "경찰법" (2014), 박영사
- 김연태, "경찰법연구(제2판)" (2012), 세창출판사
- 李起椿, "獨逸警察法上 狀態責任의 根據 및 制限에 관한 考察", 토지공법연구, 18, pp.18~432 (2003), 한국토지공법학회
- 정하중, "경찰법상의 책임", 공법연구, 25(3) (1997)
- 최영규, "경찰행정법" (2013), 법영사
- 홍정선, "경찰행정법" (2013), 박영사
- Smart, Carol, "Feminism and the Power of Law" (1989), Routledge
- Becker, "Bundesbodenschutzgesetz" (2004)
- Breuer, "Altlasten als Bewährungsprobe der polizeilichen Gefahren und des Umweltschutzes", JuS (1986)
- Dietlein, "Nachfolge im öffentlichen Recht" (1999)
- Drews, "Gefahrenabwehr" (1986)
- Drews, "Allgemeines Polizeirecht" (1961)
- Fikentscher, "Landesrecht Rheinrand Pfalz, Studienbuch" (2009)
- Knemeyer, "Polizei – und Ordnungsrecht" (2007)
- Götz, "Allgemeines Polizei – und Ordnungsrecht" (2008)
- Gornig, "Fälle zum Polizei – und Ordnungsrecht" (2006)
- Guckelberger, "Rechtsnachfolgeprobleme im Baurecht", VerwArch, 90 (1999)
- Gusy, "Polizeirecht" (2009)
- Kluth, "Staats – und Verwaltungsrecht in Sachsen – Anhlat" (2010)
- Kugelmann, "Polizei – und Ordnungsrecht" (2012)
- Lisken, "Handbuch des Polizeirechts" (2012)
- Nolte, "Grundfälle zur Rechtsnachfolge im öffentlichem Recht", JuS (2000)
- Oerderm, "Altlasten in der anwaltlichen Praxis", DVBI (1992)
- Ossenbühl, "Zur Haftung des Gesamtrechtsnachfolgers für Altlasten" (1995)
- , JZ 2006, "2006", ~
- Ossenbühl, "Die Rechtsnachfolge des Erben in die Polizei – und Ordnungspflicht", NJW (1968)
- Ossenbühl, "Verzicht, Verwirkung und Verjährung als Korrektive einer polizeilichen Ewigkeitshaftung", NVwZ (1995)
- Otto Mayer, "Deutsches Verwaltungsrecht Ⅰ" (1961)
- Palme, "Das Urteil des BVerwG zur bodenschutzrechtlichen Haftung des Gesamtrechtsnachfolgers", NVwZ (2006)
- Papier, "Altlasten und polizeiliche Störerhaftung", DVBI (1985)
- Papier, "Die Verantwortlichkeit für Altlasten im öffentlichen Recht", NVwZ (1986)
- Papier, "Zur rückwirkenden Haftung des Rechtsnachfolgers für Altlasten", DVBI (1996)
- Peine, "Die Rechtsnachfolge in öffentlichrechtliche Rechte und Pflichen – OVG Münster", NVwZ-RR (1997)
- Pieroth, "Polizei – und Ordnungsrecht" (2012)
- Rau, "Die Rechtsnachfolge in Polizei – und Ordnungsrechten", JURA (2000)
- Riedl, "Die Rechts – und Pflichtennachfolge im Verwaltungsrecht", Diss ․ jur Erlangen (1998)
- Rixen, "Geheimes Polizei – Gewohnheitsrecht", JZ (2007)
- Rumpf, "Die Rechtsnachfolge im öffentlichen Recht : Dargestellt am Beispiel des Baurechts, des Polozeirechts und des Organisationsrechts", VerwArch, 78 (1987)
- Schenke, "Polizei – und Ordnungsrecht" (2011)
- Schoch, "Besonderes Verwaltungsrecht" (2008)
- Schoch, "Grundfälle zum Polizei – und Ordnungsrecht : 6. Teil Polizei – und Ordnungsrechtlich Verantwortliche", JuS (1994)
- Schlabach, "Simon", NVwZ (1992)
- Schwachheim, "Unternehmenshaftung für Altlasten" (1991)
- Stadie, "Rechtsnachfolge im Verwaltungsrecht", DVBI (1990)
- Seibert, "Altlasten in der verwaltungsgerichtlichen Rechtsprechung", DVBI (1992)
- Sparwasser, "Grenzen der Zustandsstörerhaftung am Beispiel des Altlastenrechts", DVBI (1995)
- Tettingr, "Besonderes Verwaltungsrecht" (2012)
- Volkmann, "Nachfolgefähigkeit und Voraussetzungen einer behördlichen Stillegungsverfügung", JuS (1999)
- von Mutius, "Der “Störer” im Polizei – und Ordnungsrecht", Jura (1983)
- v. Mutius, "Zur Rechtsnachfolge des Erben in die Polizei – und Ordnungsrecht", VerwArch, 71, pp.93~ (1980)
- Wecker, "Altlasten – eine Renaissance der polizeilichen Gefahrenabwehr", NVwZ (1987)
- Würtenberger, "Polizeirecht in Baden – Württemberg" (2005)