ディスカッション場面の質問表現の機能における日韓対照研究
A Japanese-Korean Comparative Study of the Function of Questions in Discussion Situations
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
This study examined the roles that questions play in conversations between amicable native speakers of Korean and Japanese. To monitor their frequency and appearance, the functions of questions in the data were divided into five categories: <information request>, <opinion request>, <confirmation request>, <agreement request>, <information provision>, and <opinion expression>. The analysis revealed that Japanese mores speakers employed a higher frequency of questions compared to Korean mores speakers. The question expressions <confirmation request> and <information request> were frequently used in both languages, but the frequency of <opinion request> varied. Throughout the conversation, the Japanese speaker's <opinion request> kept coming up. However, for Korean speakers, it was only mentioned at the start of the conversation. <Agreement request> was frequently used in Korean speeches. It was discovered that this was the outcome of someone attempting to influence someone else's viewpoint by expressing their own. It is believed that Japanese speakers do not use <agreement request> because they do not want to burden the other party. In Japanese speeches, it is common to engage in <expressing opinions> and <providing information> as a means of gauging the other person's reaction during the discussion. Opinions and information are typically expressed by Korean speakers through statements. This suggests that they prioritized the purpose of communication over maintaining rapport with the other person.
Abstract
This study examined the roles that questions play in conversations between amicable native speakers of Korean and Japanese. To monitor their frequency and appearance, the functions of questions in the data were divided into five categories: <information request>, <opinion request>, <confirmation request>, <agreement request>, <information provision>, and <opinion expression>. The analysis revealed that Japanese mores speakers employed a higher frequency of questions compared to Korean mores speakers. The question expressions <confirmation request> and <information request> were frequently used in both languages, but the frequency of <opinion request> varied. Throughout the conversation, the Japanese speaker's <opinion request> kept coming up. However, for Korean speakers, it was only mentioned at the start of the conversation. <Agreement request> was frequently used in Korean speeches. It was discovered that this was the outcome of someone attempting to influence someone else's viewpoint by expressing their own. It is believed that Japanese speakers do not use <agreement request> because they do not want to burden the other party. In Japanese speeches, it is common to engage in <expressing opinions> and <providing information> as a means of gauging the other person's reaction during the discussion. Opinions and information are typically expressed by Korean speakers through statements. This suggests that they prioritized the purpose of communication over maintaining rapport with the other person.
참고문헌 (11)
- 장윤아, "한일어 일상대화에 있어서의 질문표현의 유형과 기능", 일본어학연구, (74), pp.137~156 (2022), 한국일본어학회[DOI]
- 小田切由香子, "異言語文化間・男女間コミュニケーションにおける性差-会話開始における話題転換上の特徴-", 横浜国立大学留学生センター紀要, 4, pp.42~53 (1997), 横浜国立大学留学生センター
- 斎藤里美, "日本語教育における疑問文・質問文-コミュニケーション上の機能からみた日本語教材の課題-", 日本語学, 8(8), pp.41~56 (1989), 明治書院
- 佐々木由美, "初対面の状況における日本人の"情報要求"の発話-同文化内および異文化間コミュニケーションの場面-", 異文化間教育, 8, pp.110~127 (1998), 異文化間教育学会
- 戸江哲理, "糸口質問連鎖", 社会言語科学, 10(2), pp.135~145 (2008), 社会言語科学会
- 吉田陸, "会話内の質問表現が持つ多義性-応答表現からみる会話構築を中心に-", 筑波応用言語学研究, 16, pp.87~97 (2009), 筑波大学人文社会科学研究科文芸・言語先行応用言語学領域
- Button, Graham., "Topic nomination and topic pursuit", Human Studies, 8, pp.3~55 (1985)
- Freed, F., "The form and function of questions in informal dyadic conversation", Journal of Pragmatics, 21, pp.621~644 (1994)
- Jefferson, G., "Structures of social action: Studies in conversation analysis", pp.167~190 (1984), Cambridge University Press
- Maynard, D. W., "Topical talk, Ritual and social organization of relationships", Social Psychology Quarterly, 47(4), pp.301~316 (1984)
- "トランスクリプションのための記号" (2008)[URL]
