재교육으로서 비디오를 이용한 피드백이 임상수행평가 성적에 미치는 영향
The Effect of Remedial Precepted Video Review on Clinical Performance Examination Scores
1
조회
0
다운로드
3
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Purpose: Precepted video review (PVR) has been considered one of the methods for the remediation of clinical performance examinations (CPX). This study quantified the effect of brief PVR on CPX scores. Methods: For two years, final-year students (61 students in the 1st year’s cohort and 54 in the 2nd year’s cohort)participated in CPXs. The scores on the initial CPX were announced to the students shortly after that CPX administration. There was no PVR after the initial CPX in the 1st year. All participants of the 2nd year were notified of the opportunity to voluntarily receive brief PVR after the initial CPX. Several months after the initial CPX, the students took the latter CPX in both years. The differences of scores between initial and latter CPX were compared in good performers and poor performers of the initial CPX. Results: Thirteen poor performers and 8 good performers received PVR in the 2nd year. In the 1st year, history taking (Hx), physical examination, and patient physician interaction (PPI) scores of the good performers of the initial CPX were significantly decreased on the latter CPX. In the 2nd year, the Hx and PPI scores of the good performers of the initial CPX, who received PVR, were significantly decreased at the latter CPX. The Hx and PPI scores of the poor performers of the initial CPX were significantly increased at the latter CPX in both years regardless of PVR. Conclusion: The changes in CPX scores according to PVR did not show any consistent trend. Brief PVR appears to be not sufficient for improving CPX scores.
Abstract
Purpose: Precepted video review (PVR) has been considered one of the methods for the remediation of clinical performance examinations (CPX). This study quantified the effect of brief PVR on CPX scores. Methods: For two years, final-year students (61 students in the 1st year’s cohort and 54 in the 2nd year’s cohort)participated in CPXs. The scores on the initial CPX were announced to the students shortly after that CPX administration. There was no PVR after the initial CPX in the 1st year. All participants of the 2nd year were notified of the opportunity to voluntarily receive brief PVR after the initial CPX. Several months after the initial CPX, the students took the latter CPX in both years. The differences of scores between initial and latter CPX were compared in good performers and poor performers of the initial CPX. Results: Thirteen poor performers and 8 good performers received PVR in the 2nd year. In the 1st year, history taking (Hx), physical examination, and patient physician interaction (PPI) scores of the good performers of the initial CPX were significantly decreased on the latter CPX. In the 2nd year, the Hx and PPI scores of the good performers of the initial CPX, who received PVR, were significantly decreased at the latter CPX. The Hx and PPI scores of the poor performers of the initial CPX were significantly increased at the latter CPX in both years regardless of PVR. Conclusion: The changes in CPX scores according to PVR did not show any consistent trend. Brief PVR appears to be not sufficient for improving CPX scores.
참고문헌 (19)
- Beckert, L., "A needs-based study and examination skills course improves students’ performance", Med Educ, 37(5), pp.424~428 (2003)
- Bennett, A. J., "Professionalism deficits among medical students : models of identification and intervention", Acad Psychiatry, 29(5), pp.426~432 (2005)
- Clauser, B. E., "A multivariate generalizability analysis of data from a performance assessment of physicians’ clinical skills", J Educ Meas, 43, pp.173~191 (2006)
- Dowell, J., "What to do about medical students with unsatisfactory consultation skills?", Med Teach, 28(5), pp.443~446 (2006)
- Engelhard, G., "Evaluating rater accuracy in performance assessments", J Educ Meas, 33(1), pp.56~70 (1996)
- Faustinella, F., "Remediation strategies and students’ clinical performance", MedTeach, 26(7), pp.664~665 (2004)
- Harik, P., "An examination of rater drift within a generalizability theory framework", J Educ Meas, 46(1), pp.43~58 (2009)
- Hauer, K. E., "Approaches to medical student remediation after a comprehensive clinical skills examination", Med Educ, 42(1), pp.104~112 (2008)
- Hauer, K. E., "Impact of the United States Medical Licensing Examination Step 2 Clinical Skills exam on medical school clinical skills assessment", Acad Med, 81(10 Suppl), pp.13~16 (2006)
- Kim, J. H., "The effect of precepted video review as remediation for poor performer in clinical performance examination", Simul Healthc, 5(3), pp.187~ (2010)
- 김종훈, "Does sharing information before a clinical skills examination impact student performance?", MEDICAL TEACHER, 32(9), pp.747~753, CARFAX PUBLISHING
- Klamen, D. L., "The efficacy of a targeted remediation process for students who fail standardized patient examinations", Teach Learn Med, 23(1), pp.3~11 (2011)
- Kneebone, R., "Learner-centred feedback using remote assessment of clinical procedures", Med Teach, 30(8), pp.795~801 (2008)
- Lin, C. T., "Personalized remedial intensive training of one medical student in communication and interview skills", Teach Learn Med, 13(4), pp.232~239 (2001)
- Magarian, G. J., "A tutorial for students demonstrating adequate skills but inadequate knowledge after completing a medicine clerkship at the Oregon Health Sciences University", Acad Med, 67(4), pp.277~278 (1992)
- Rosenblatt, M. A., "Evaluation, feedback, and remediation in anesthesiology residency training : a survey of 124 United States programs", J Clin Anesth, 11(6), pp.519~527 (1999)
- Saxena, V., "Remediation techniques for student performance problems after a comprehensive clinical skills assessment", Acad Med, 84(5), pp.669~676 (2009)
- Tavakol, M., "Post-examination analysis of objective tests", Med Teach, 33(6), pp.447~458 (2011)
- White, C. B., "Remediating students’ failed OSCE performances at one school : the effects of self-assessment, reflection, and feedback", Acad Med, 84(5), pp.651~654 (2009)