본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

터키의 EU 가입 협상에 따른 이슬람 종교-문화적 갈등과 절충에 관한 연구

A Study on the Conflict and Harmony of Islamic Religious-Cultural Factors in the Process of Turkey's Negotiation for His EU Integration

0

조회

0

다운로드

7

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

초록

In October, 2005 Turkey has started a wide range of negotiation with EU for her full membership in Luxembourg, where Turkey's candidacy was rejected in 1997. We expect however a long way to fulfill Turkey's goals to be integrated to Europe. Because all critical decisions on Turkey have been taken after every kind of difficult process since the Helsinki Summit in 1999, when Turkey's EU candidacy was accepted. In spite of negative approaches initiated certain countries as France and Belgium against Turkey's efforts to be EU member, Turkey has implemented political reforms with incredible speed within five years. Things that were not expected by the Europeans to be achieved in 20 years, were accomplished in only five years. Now many experts agree that Turkey has much more possibility to be a full member of EU after 2012. Accordingly the government of Turkey(AKP) exerts her bet efforts to fulfill 35 standard articles which EU suggested for Turkey as the basic guidelines and conditions for full membership negotiation. Of course, such four sensitive political-historical issues as ①Armenian genocide in 1905, ②rights of minority Kurdish communities in Turkey, ③peace agreement of with Greece for Cyprus status, ④tolerance to Greek Patriarchal renovation in Istanbul, are main subjects for negotiation processes with EU. But the matter of cultural differences between Turkey and EU is also a pivotal factor for the future of Turkey with EU. How a 99%Muslim country can be integrated to Christian EU community? How to harmonize some Islamic religious obligations or rituals which might violate the value of EU or its standards? The 5 times daily prayers,one month long fasting, cruelty to animal and insanitary matters on sacrifice festival during the Eid-al Adha, honor killings, women circumcision, hijab prohibition in the public sectors and many others are some of critical issues to be discussed. As for EU too, the debate about Turkey's EU membership clearly demonstrates that Europe is once again at one of critical deciding moments. At this point the EU should decide: Is it going to stay as "an institution of ols Europe" or is it going to progress to a better,more advanced stage with Turkey?(Laciner 2005:13). In this regard, this articles is designed to study on the conflict and harmony of Islamic Religious-Cultural factors in the process of Turkey's negotiation for his EU Integration mainly based on anthropological intensive interviews. Surprisingly, Turkey has successfully solved the religious and cultural differences in many fields through comprehensive reinterpretation of Islamic tradition and obligations. Furthermore Turkey showed great possibilities to other Muslim countries like Morocco an Tunisia in Mediterranean to be member of EU in the future.

Abstract

In October, 2005 Turkey has started a wide range of negotiation with EU for her full membership in Luxembourg, where Turkey's candidacy was rejected in 1997. We expect however a long way to fulfill Turkey's goals to be integrated to Europe. Because all critical decisions on Turkey have been taken after every kind of difficult process since the Helsinki Summit in 1999, when Turkey's EU candidacy was accepted. In spite of negative approaches initiated certain countries as France and Belgium against Turkey's efforts to be EU member, Turkey has implemented political reforms with incredible speed within five years. Things that were not expected by the Europeans to be achieved in 20 years, were accomplished in only five years. Now many experts agree that Turkey has much more possibility to be a full member of EU after 2012. Accordingly the government of Turkey(AKP) exerts her bet efforts to fulfill 35 standard articles which EU suggested for Turkey as the basic guidelines and conditions for full membership negotiation. Of course, such four sensitive political-historical issues as ①Armenian genocide in 1905, ②rights of minority Kurdish communities in Turkey, ③peace agreement of with Greece for Cyprus status, ④tolerance to Greek Patriarchal renovation in Istanbul, are main subjects for negotiation processes with EU. But the matter of cultural differences between Turkey and EU is also a pivotal factor for the future of Turkey with EU. How a 99%Muslim country can be integrated to Christian EU community? How to harmonize some Islamic religious obligations or rituals which might violate the value of EU or its standards? The 5 times daily prayers,one month long fasting, cruelty to animal and insanitary matters on sacrifice festival during the Eid-al Adha, honor killings, women circumcision, hijab prohibition in the public sectors and many others are some of critical issues to be discussed. As for EU too, the debate about Turkey's EU membership clearly demonstrates that Europe is once again at one of critical deciding moments. At this point the EU should decide: Is it going to stay as "an institution of ols Europe" or is it going to progress to a better,more advanced stage with Turkey?(Laciner 2005:13). In this regard, this articles is designed to study on the conflict and harmony of Islamic Religious-Cultural factors in the process of Turkey's negotiation for his EU Integration mainly based on anthropological intensive interviews. Surprisingly, Turkey has successfully solved the religious and cultural differences in many fields through comprehensive reinterpretation of Islamic tradition and obligations. Furthermore Turkey showed great possibilities to other Muslim countries like Morocco an Tunisia in Mediterranean to be member of EU in the future.

참고문헌 (37)

  1. "Zaman Gazetesi 편집국장 Abdullah Aymaz와 면담-2007년 1월 30일, 2월 12일 두 차례(이스탄불, 신문사 접견실)", ~
  2. "누르주 그룹의 제2인자 Ismail Buyukcelebi, 2005년 1월 30일(이스탄불, ISHAD 사무실)", ~
  3. "S-TV 보도본부장 Adem Kalac, 2007년 2월 1일(이스탄불, 방송국 집무실)", ~
  4. "IIFSO 사무총장 Omar Faruq Yaser, 2007년 2월 7일 (앙카라 IIFSO 본부)", ~
  5. "복지당 청년당원 교육 책임자 Muhittin Yildirim, 2007년 8월 20~30일(앙카라 복지당 본부)", ~
  6. "TURKIYE 신문사 편집장 Huseyin Tanrikulu, 2007년 2월 5일 전화 인터뷰", ~
  7. "이슬람 문화연구소 연구원 Abdullah Topaloglu, 2005년 1월 29일(이스탄불, 연구소 사무실)", ~
  8. "OIC 사무총장 Ekmelledin Ihsanoglu, 2009년 11월 11일, 아제르바이잔 바쿠, 하야트 호텔)", ~
  9. "이스탄불대학교 역사학과 교수 Dr.Mehmet Saray, 2006년 2월 3일(이스탄불 대학 연구실)", ~
  10. Alsayyad, Nezar, "Musluman Avrupa ya da Avro-Islam" (2004), Everest Yayinlar
  11. Antoun, Richard T., "Anthropology" The Study of the Middle East" (1976), John Willy & Sons
  12. Bernard Lewis, "중동의 역사" (1998), 까치
  13. Cardini, Franco, "Europe and Islam" (1999), Blackwell
  14. Nasr, Seyyed Hossein, "The Heart of Islam" (2002), HarperCollins
  15. Efegil, Ertan, "Turkiye-AB Iliskiler" (2007), Orion
  16. El Fadl, Khaled Abou, "The Place of Tolerance in Islam" (2002), Beacon Press
  17. Hairi, Shaykh Fadhlallah, "이슬람의 이해" (1999), 김영사
  18. Laciner, Sedat, "European Union with Turkey" (2005), Ankara
  19. Lindholm, Charles, "Islamic Middle Eas" (1996), Blackwell
  20. Lunde, Paul, "Islam" (2002), DK Publishing Inc.
  21. Nisan, Mordechai, "Minorities in the Middle East" (1991), McFarland & Company
  22. Ortayli, Ilber, (2007), Kultur Yayinlar
  23. Parfrey, Adam, "Extreme Islam" (2001), Feral House
  24. Ramadan Tariq, "To be a European Muslim" (2004), Islamic Foundation
  25. Vali, Nasr, "Lesson from the Muslim World" (2003), Daedalus
  26. Yildiz, H.Dursun, "Buyuk Islam Tarihi" (1986), Cag Yayinlari
  27. 김정위, "중동사" (1997), 대한교과서
  28. 한국이슬람학회, "끝나지 않은 전쟁" (2002), 청아
  29. 이원삼, "이슬람:이슬람문명의 올바른 이해하기" (2001), 청아
  30. 이희수, "중동소수민족의 현황과 과제", 한국중동학회 논총, 18 (1997), 한국중동학회
  31. 이희수, "이슬람 부흥운동:21세기로의 새로운 공포인가?", 전통과 현대, (창간) (1997)
  32. 이희수, "이슬람 문화" (2003), 살림출판사
  33. "Daily News, 2004년 12월 28일자, Is the cultural gap between Turkey and Europe too wide?", ~
  34. "Zaman Daily 2007~2010 1월까지의 신문기사", ~
  35. "Hurriyet 2006년 5월 16일자", ~
  36. "전자신문 2008년 11월 20일자", ~

관련 논문AI추천

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (11건)