원 제국의 3차 대월 침입과 그 이후 양국의 관계 ― 『安南行記』 자료의 발굴과 분석을 중심으로 ―
The Yuan(元) Empire's Third Invasion of Đại Việt(大越) and Subsequent Relationship — Based on the discovery and analysis of materials from Annanxingji(安南行記) —
0
조회
0
다운로드
5
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
This article has analyzed for the evolution of the relationship between the Yuan and Đại Việt, focusing on the two documents(表文) of Đại Việt and imperial order(詔書) of Qubilai recorded at Annanxingji, written by Xumingshan(徐明善) who was part of an envoy sent to Đại Việt from the Yuan Empire in November of 1288. While Qubilai's imperial order document has been discussed in the past because of its presence at Annanzhilüe(安南志略), the two documents(表文) of Đại Việt are less well known and have not been examined in detail. However, the contents of the two documents(表文) of Đại Việt have clear historical value as they show the position and diplomatic posture of the Đại Việt side after the end of the Yuan Empire's third invasion of Đại Việt. Although Đại Việt was heavily damaged by the Yuan invasion, it was by no means defeated in the war, and in fact was able to attack the retreating Yuan army and ultimately win. However, if we look at the documents of Đại Việt, we can see that they attempted to reconcile with the Yuan Empire through tribute immediately after the war, and to this end, they fabricated the causes of the deaths of the Yuan commanders they had intentionally killed. The document of Đại Việt also reveals that they attempted to restore diplomatic relations by returning captured prisoners and offering tribute to Qubilai and the empress. However, Qubilai was not entirely receptive to these efforts, insisting that the only way to show submission was through the coming to Yuan court of the Đại Việt monarch. The Đại Việt side insisted that only a tribute could be made, so diplomacy between the two countries continued to run parallel. The records contained in Annanxingji illustrate this diplomatic posture and the tension between the Yuan Empire and Đại Việt in 1288~1289.
Abstract
This article has analyzed for the evolution of the relationship between the Yuan and Đại Việt, focusing on the two documents(表文) of Đại Việt and imperial order(詔書) of Qubilai recorded at Annanxingji, written by Xumingshan(徐明善) who was part of an envoy sent to Đại Việt from the Yuan Empire in November of 1288. While Qubilai's imperial order document has been discussed in the past because of its presence at Annanzhilüe(安南志略), the two documents(表文) of Đại Việt are less well known and have not been examined in detail. However, the contents of the two documents(表文) of Đại Việt have clear historical value as they show the position and diplomatic posture of the Đại Việt side after the end of the Yuan Empire's third invasion of Đại Việt. Although Đại Việt was heavily damaged by the Yuan invasion, it was by no means defeated in the war, and in fact was able to attack the retreating Yuan army and ultimately win. However, if we look at the documents of Đại Việt, we can see that they attempted to reconcile with the Yuan Empire through tribute immediately after the war, and to this end, they fabricated the causes of the deaths of the Yuan commanders they had intentionally killed. The document of Đại Việt also reveals that they attempted to restore diplomatic relations by returning captured prisoners and offering tribute to Qubilai and the empress. However, Qubilai was not entirely receptive to these efforts, insisting that the only way to show submission was through the coming to Yuan court of the Đại Việt monarch. The Đại Việt side insisted that only a tribute could be made, so diplomacy between the two countries continued to run parallel. The records contained in Annanxingji illustrate this diplomatic posture and the tension between the Yuan Empire and Đại Việt in 1288~1289.
참고문헌 (18)
- 陳荊和, "校合本 大越史記全書(上)" (1984), 東京大學東洋文化硏究所附屬東洋學文獻センタ
- 武尙, "安南志略" (1995), 中華書局
- 顧宏義, "金元日記叢編" (2013), 上海書店出版社
- "元史" (1976), 中華書局
- 라시드 앗 딘, "칸의 후예들" (2005), 사계절
- 동북아역사재단, "遼史・金史・元史 外國傳 譯註" (2014)
- 권용철, "至元 30년(1293) 원 제국 사절단과 베트남의 서신 왕래를 통해 본 원-베트남 관계의 양상", 역사학연구, (81), pp.219~244 (2021), 호남사학회
- 송정남, "中世 베트남의 外交 -對蒙抗爭을 소재로-", 국제지역연구, 10(1), pp.205~228 (2006), 국제지역연구센터
- 유인선, "베트남과 그 이웃 중국 : 양국관계의 어제와 오늘" (2012), 창비
- 윤승연, "13세기 몽골의 베트남 침공과 六事 요구", 베트남연구, (16), pp.39~74 (2018), 한국베트남학회[DOI]
- 윤승연, "北으로 간 安南國王 陳益稷", 역사문화연구, (85), pp.273~302 (2023), 역사문화연구소[DOI]
- 조원, "쿠빌라이 시기 安南과의 외교 교섭 ― 元의 정책과 安南의 대응을 중심으로 ―", 동양사학연구, (154), pp.103~134 (2021), 동양사학회[DOI]
- 黨寶海, "昔里吉大王與元越戰爭", 西部蒙古論壇, (4) (2013)
- 施建光, "元明時期安南貢物“代身金人”及其政治寓意考析", 中國邊疆史地研究, 29(1) (2019)
- 李治安, "元代行省制度" (2011), 中華書局
- 山本達郞, "安南史硏究 Ⅰ" (1950), 山川出版社
- 山本達郞, "ベトナム中國關係史 : 曲氏の擡頭から淸佛戰爭まで" (1975), 山川出版社
- 村岡倫, "シリギの亂 - 元初モンゴリアの爭亂", 東洋史苑, 24 (1985)
