反古思潮的“反古邏輯”批判： 附論經濟決定論的“崇古邏輯”
A Critique of Anti-ancient Logic of the Anti-ancient Trend: Also the Pro-ancient Logic of the Economy Determinism
1
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
In late 19<sup>th</sup> and early 20<sup>th</sup> century, China had been loser in a series of conflicts with western countries. When reflecting this history, some people attributed the defeat to cultural factors, thus started the anti-ancient trend. Anti-ancient arguments take distinction between economy, politics and culture and the cause-effect relationship between the three as the assumptive premise, and the decline of the nation as the factual premise, hence infer that culture is liable to the nation`s weakness. However, as both of the premises are false, the whole logic is wrong. Besides, the pro-ancient logic, seemly opposite to anti-ancient logic, is in fact the same with the latter.
Abstract
In late 19<sup>th</sup> and early 20<sup>th</sup> century, China had been loser in a series of conflicts with western countries. When reflecting this history, some people attributed the defeat to cultural factors, thus started the anti-ancient trend. Anti-ancient arguments take distinction between economy, politics and culture and the cause-effect relationship between the three as the assumptive premise, and the decline of the nation as the factual premise, hence infer that culture is liable to the nation`s weakness. However, as both of the premises are false, the whole logic is wrong. Besides, the pro-ancient logic, seemly opposite to anti-ancient logic, is in fact the same with the latter.