從工夫論的角度論陽明哲學中良知與氣的關係
The Relationship between Conscience and Qi in Yangming’s Philosophy
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
當前學界對陽明哲學的研究以“良知”爲中心而漸次展開,宋明理學中“理氣”或“性氣”的對立,在陽明心學中被轉換爲“良知”與“氣”的關係。“氣”在陽明哲學中的地位相比宋代理學那裡,有了極大的提高。首先,良知“以其流行謂之氣”命題的提出;其次,對“生之謂性”的重新評價,重申“性即氣,氣即性”,故良知發用不能“外了氣”;再次,“萬物一體”以“同此一氣”或“一氣流通”爲前提。但經過進一步考察我們發現,首先,“致良知”不致力於對治氣稟之雜,而是從本體上做工夫,自然達到“不動氣”的效驗。其次,“萬物一體”的本體論基礎仍然是“良知”,而非一般認爲的“氣”。再次,良知雖不可離氣而言,但終究是良知決定氣,而非氣決定良知。因此,陽明雖然重視“氣”,但他用“良知”吸納“氣”的做法,實際上消解了“氣”的客觀性。
Abstract
At present, the study of Yangming’s philosophy is centered on conscience 良知. But “conscience” in Yangming’s philosophy is not a purely moral concept, but an ontological concept. In the Neo Confucianism of Song and Ming Dynasties, the opposition between qi 气 and li 理 or qi and “human nature” (xing 性) was converted to the relationship between “conscience” and qi in Yangming’s philosophy. The status of qi in Yangming philosophy has been greatly improved compared with the Song Dynasty. But for Yangming, “extending the conscience” (zhiliangzhi 致良知) is not committed to change qi in the human body, but to extend the conscience itself. The ontological foundation of “all things share one body” can only be “conscience” instead of qi. Therefore, conscience can not be separated from qi, but after all, conscience determines qi rather than qi determines conscience. Investigating the relationship between “conscience” and qi is of great significance for us to further grasp Yangming’s philosophy and its inheritance and development of Neo-Confucianism with in the Song Dynasty. Therefore, although Yang ming attaches great importance to qi, his attempt to absorb qi with his conscience actually dispels the objectivity of qi.
참고문헌 (17)
- 陳来, "中國近世思想史研究" (2010), 三聯書店
- 陳榮捷, "〈傳習錄〉詳注集評" (2017), 重慶出版社
- 程顥, "二程集" (2012), 中華書局
- 鄧艾民, "傳習錄註疏" (2012), 上海古籍出版社
- 郭曉东, "識仁與定性——工夫論視域下的程明道哲學研究" (2006), 復旦大學出版社
- 黃宗羲, "明儒學案" (2008), 中華書局
- 黎靖德, "朱子語類" (1986), 中華書局
- 柳存仁, "和風堂文集" (1991), 上海古籍出版社
- 羅欽順, "困知記" (2013), 中華書局
- 牟宗三, "心體與性體" (1987), 正中書局
- 上田弘毅, "氣的思想" (2014), 上海人民出版社
- 王畿, "王畿集,卷一" (2007), 鳳凰出版社
- 王陽明, "王陽明全集" (2014), 上海古籍出版社
- 吳震, "〈傳習錄〉精讀" (2011), 復旦大學出版社
- 楊儒賓, "儒家身體觀" (1996), 中央研究院中國文哲研究所
- 楊儒賓, "異議的意義——近世東亞的反理學思潮" (2012), 臺北大學出版中心
- 朱熹, "四書章句集注" (2010), 中華書局
