본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

트랜스젠더(transgender)의 헌법적 문제

Constitutional Issues on Transgender

0

조회

0

다운로드

18

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

주제분류법학

초록

Transgender means the symptoms that occur when one identifies his gender as the opposite gender to the biological one or people who have these symptoms. Many problems may happen if transgender people can not change their first names and sex designations in their birth registration and marry and they are discriminated. Transgender people have rights to change of first name and sex designation, to marry and not to be discriminated. These rights are justified on the ground of constitutional law. Generally constitutional laws of most countries in the world provide rights to personality, freedom to marry and equality before the law. In Germany, transgender people can change their name and sex designation on legally strict conditions: compulsive sense of belonging to the other sex, two opinions of the experts in transsexualism etc. Futhermore, they can marry and may not be discriminated. Legal situations of transgender in England are the same as in Germany. Transgender people in most of states of the U.S. can change their sex designation by court order and marry. These legislations reflect a general trend in the world towards the protection and promotion of human rights for transgender. There are no parliamentary legislation about the change of first name and sex designation and the marriage of transgender people in Korea. However, Korea has a general anti-discrimination law (National Human Rights Commission Act), but the gender identity is not numerated as one of the grounds of prohibited discrimination. Therefore, it is urgently necessary to make laws on the protection of human rights and non-discrimination against transgender people. Transgender people are sexual minorities. Many people have a stereotype and prejudice about them. According to the stereotype and prejudice, people don‘t try to recognize the constitutional rights of transgender people to freedom and equality before the law. However, legal protection of transgender people contributes the social pluralism and the promotion of human rights of a whole community.

Abstract

Transgender means the symptoms that occur when one identifies his gender as the opposite gender to the biological one or people who have these symptoms. Many problems may happen if transgender people can not change their first names and sex designations in their birth registration and marry and they are discriminated. Transgender people have rights to change of first name and sex designation, to marry and not to be discriminated. These rights are justified on the ground of constitutional law. Generally constitutional laws of most countries in the world provide rights to personality, freedom to marry and equality before the law. In Germany, transgender people can change their name and sex designation on legally strict conditions: compulsive sense of belonging to the other sex, two opinions of the experts in transsexualism etc. Futhermore, they can marry and may not be discriminated. Legal situations of transgender in England are the same as in Germany. Transgender people in most of states of the U.S. can change their sex designation by court order and marry. These legislations reflect a general trend in the world towards the protection and promotion of human rights for transgender. There are no parliamentary legislation about the change of first name and sex designation and the marriage of transgender people in Korea. However, Korea has a general anti-discrimination law (National Human Rights Commission Act), but the gender identity is not numerated as one of the grounds of prohibited discrimination. Therefore, it is urgently necessary to make laws on the protection of human rights and non-discrimination against transgender people. Transgender people are sexual minorities. Many people have a stereotype and prejudice about them. According to the stereotype and prejudice, people don‘t try to recognize the constitutional rights of transgender people to freedom and equality before the law. However, legal protection of transgender people contributes the social pluralism and the promotion of human rights of a whole community.

참고문헌 (20)

  1. 김중권, "‘성전환자의 성별정정허가신청사건 등 사무처리지침’의 문제점, <법률신문>(법률신문사), 제3493호(2006. 9. 25.), 인터넷 법률신문 웹사이트(www.lawtimes.co.kr), 판례논단", 연구논단에 수록, 2006
  2. 김민규, "성전환(증)자에 대한 법학과 의학의 가교-대법원 2006.004스42 결정을 계기로", 법과사회, (31), pp.307~341 (2006), 법과사회이론학회
  3. 김상수, "트랜스젠더의 성별변경에 관한 연구", 법학논집, 27, pp.67~102 (2006), 청주대학교 법학연구소
  4. 문유석, "성전환 수술을 받은 자의 성별", 인권과 정의, 통권 : 311, pp.85~96 (2002), 대한변호사협회
  5. 민유숙, "성전환자에 대한 호적정정의 가부(可否)", 대법원판례해설, (60), pp.559~618 (2006), 법원도서관
  6. 윤진수, "2006년도 주요 민법 관련 판례 회고", 서울대학교 법학, 48(1), pp.371~449 (2007), 서울대학교 법학연구소
  7. 이덕환, "성전환의 민사법상 문제", 민사법학, (24), pp.429~463 (2003), 한국민사법학회
  8. 이로문, "성전환자와 동성애자의 민법상 지위", 의료법학, 2(2), pp.175~210 (2001), 대한의료법학회
  9. 이철호, "성전환의 헌법적 검토", 아ㆍ태공법연구, (3), pp.91~119 (1994), 아세아ㆍ태평양공법학회
  10. 정현미, "성전환수술자의 강간죄의 객체 여부", 형사판례연구, (6), pp.166~184 (1998), 형사판례연구회
  11. 조희대, "남녀의 성전환은 현행법상 허용되는가", 법조, 통권 : 488, pp.161~199 (1994), 법조협회
  12. 조희대, "성전환수술을 받은 자가 강간죄의 부녀에 해당하는가", 대법원판례해설, (25), pp.618~655 (1996), 법원도서관
  13. 최정학, "성전환의 법적 문제점", 민주법학, (14), pp.211~231 (1998), 민주주의법학연구회
  14. 허영, "성전환자(Transsexuelle)의 법적 지위", 공법연구, 8, pp.97~110 (1980), 한국공법학회
  15. 현소혜, "성전환자의 민사상 법적 지위", 가족법연구, 16(2), pp.307~347 (2002), 한국가족법학회
  16. 홍춘의, "성전환과 호적정정, <법률신문>(법률신문사), 제2492호(1996. 4. 4.), 인터넷 법률신문 웹사이트(www.lawtimes.co.kr), 판례논단", 판례평석에 수록, 1996
  17. "미국 트랜스젠더 법과 정책 연구소(TLPI) 웹사이트: www.transgenderlaw.org", ~
  18. "미국 동성애자 및 트랜스젠더 인권단체(Lambda legal) 웹사이트: www.lambdalegal.org", ~
  19. "미국 동성애자 및 트랜스젠더 인권단체(National Center for Lesbian Rights: NCLR)의웹사이트: www.nclrights.org", ~
  20. "영국 동성애자 및 트랜스젠더 인권단체(The Press for Change) 웹사이트: www.pfc.org.uk", ~

관련 논문AI추천

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (13건)