문법성과 문법 모델링: 영어 목적어 외치 구문의 변이형을 중심으로
Grammaticality and Grammar Modelling: Variations in English Object Extraposition
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
It is a well-known fact that grammar modelling for the English object extraposition construction is never easy due to too many variations in the construction; nevertheless, there are at least 3 grammar models for this construction, such as Kim & Sag (2006, 2007), Kim (2008) and Cho (2010) in Formal Syntax. Though each model accounts for some subset of the construction data, they all seem to face empirical and theoretical problems mainly due to the difficulty of deciding the grammaticality of controversial data. Consequently, they have to hold somewhat different grammar models, which appear to be counter- intuitive. To judge which model is better among the 3 models and to see which is the most optimal model for the construction, we will provide statistical results of 21 native speakers' grammatical judgments for 9 controversial data, and we will discuss the factors that lead to the difficulties of modelling the grammar of the construction. Throughout this paper, we will argue that we must assume a larger set of grammatical sentences than previous analyses and consider various factors such as LP rules, redundancy, and intervention effects to postulate an optimal grammar model for the construction.
Abstract
It is a well-known fact that grammar modelling for the English object extraposition construction is never easy due to too many variations in the construction; nevertheless, there are at least 3 grammar models for this construction, such as Kim & Sag (2006, 2007), Kim (2008) and Cho (2010) in Formal Syntax. Though each model accounts for some subset of the construction data, they all seem to face empirical and theoretical problems mainly due to the difficulty of deciding the grammaticality of controversial data. Consequently, they have to hold somewhat different grammar models, which appear to be counter- intuitive. To judge which model is better among the 3 models and to see which is the most optimal model for the construction, we will provide statistical results of 21 native speakers' grammatical judgments for 9 controversial data, and we will discuss the factors that lead to the difficulties of modelling the grammar of the construction. Throughout this paper, we will argue that we must assume a larger set of grammatical sentences than previous analyses and consider various factors such as LP rules, redundancy, and intervention effects to postulate an optimal grammar model for the construction.
참고문헌 (11)
- Authier, Marc, "V-Governed Expletives, Case Theory, and the Projection Principle", Linguistic Inquiry, 22(4), pp.721~740 (1991)
- Bolinger, Dwight, "Meaning and Form" (1977), Longman
- 조세연, "Toward a Unified Constraint-Based Analysis of English Object Extraposition", 언어와 정보, 14(1), pp.49~65 (2010), 한국언어정보학회
- Chomsky, Noam, "Aspects of the Theory of Syntax" (1965), MIT Press
- Kim, Jong-Bok, "English Object Extraposition: A Constraint-Based Approach", Proceedings of the HPSG05 Conference (2006), CSLI
- Kim, Jong-Bok, "Variations in English Object Extraposition", Proceedings of the 41st Regional Meeting of the Chicago Linguistics Society, pp.1~15 (2007)
- 김종복, "Grammatical Interfaces in English Object Extraposition", 언어연구, 25(3), pp.117~131 (2008), 언어정보연구소
- 김종복, "English syntax: an introduction" (2008), CSLI Publications
- Kuno, Susumo, "Functional Syntax" (1987), The University of Chicago Press
- Pollard, Carl, "Head-driven Phrase Structure Grammar" (1994), CSLI Publications
- 에밀리벤더, "Syntactic Theory: A Formal Introduction. Second edition" (2003), Stanford: CSLI