Remarks on the syntax and semantics of so-called comitative coordination
2
조회
0
다운로드
1
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Natural languages exhibit two conjunction strategies: the coordinate strategy and the comitative strategy (Stassen 2000). Recent work claims that there exists a hybrid construction that appears to employ both strategies, namely comitative coordinate construction. This paper argues against this claim and shows that what the literature assumes to be a hybrid construction is in fact a pure comitative, which is different from a coordinate semantically and syntactically. The paper also offers an alternative structural analysis of this construction, which captures the various differences between comitatives and coordinates. The analysis proposed has consequences on the status of the conjunct constraint, the constraint that bans extracting a whole conjunct.
Abstract
Natural languages exhibit two conjunction strategies: the coordinate strategy and the comitative strategy (Stassen 2000). Recent work claims that there exists a hybrid construction that appears to employ both strategies, namely comitative coordinate construction. This paper argues against this claim and shows that what the literature assumes to be a hybrid construction is in fact a pure comitative, which is different from a coordinate semantically and syntactically. The paper also offers an alternative structural analysis of this construction, which captures the various differences between comitatives and coordinates. The analysis proposed has consequences on the status of the conjunct constraint, the constraint that bans extracting a whole conjunct.
참고문헌 (38)
- Al Khalaf, Eman., "Coordination and linear order", PhD, pp.2015
- 안덕호, "Different in conjunctives, comitatives, and comparatives", 언어연구, 34(3), pp.215~238 (2017), 언어정보연구소[DOI]
- Arkhipov, Alexandre., "Trends in linguistics" (2009), Mouton de Gruyter
- Bayer, Samuel, "The Coordination of unlike categories", Language, 72, pp.579~616 (1996)
- Camacho, José., "The structure of coordination: conjunction and agreement phenomena in Spanish and other languages" (2003), Kluwer Academic Publishers
- Chaves, Rui, "On the grammar of extraction and coordination", Natural Language and Linguistic Theory, 30, pp.465~512 (2012)
- 최혜원, "A Linear Regressional Analysis of With-PPs in English", 언어연구, 29(1), pp.21~44 (2012), 언어정보연구소[DOI]
- Chomsky, Noam., "Syntactic structures" (1957), Mouton
- Dalrymple, Mary, "The semantics of the Russian comitative construction", Natural Language and Linguistic Theory, 16, pp.597~631 (1998)
- Dyla, Stefan, "Quasi-comitative coordination in Polish", Linguistics, 26, pp.383~414 (1988)
- Fillmore, Charles, "Lexical entries for verbs", Foundations of Language, 4, pp.373~393 (1968)
- Fox, Danny., "Economy and semantic interpretation" (2000), MIT Press
- Gazdar, Gerald, "Generalized phrase structure grammar" (1985), Blackwell
- Gleitman, Lila, "Similar, and similar concepts", Cognition, 58, pp.321~376 (1996)
- Goodall, Grant, "Parallel structures in syntax: coordination, causatives and restructuring" (1987), Cambridge University Press
- Grosu, Alexander, "Approaches to island phenomena" (1981), North-Holland
- Huddleston, Rodney, "The Cambridge grammar of the English languag" (2002), Cambridge University Press
- Johannessen, Janne Bondi, "Coordination" (1998), Oxford University Press
- Kayne, Richard, "The antisymmetry of syntax" (1994), MIT Press
- Lakoff, George, "Mathematical linguistics and automatic translation", pp.1~49 (1966), Harvard University
- Larson, Richard, "Double objects revisited : reply to Jackendoff", Linguistic Inquiry, 21, pp.589~632 (1990)
- Levine, Robert, "The extraction riddle: just what are we missing?", Journal of Linguistics, 37, pp.145~174 (2001)
- Levine, Robert, "The unity of unbounded dependency constructions" (2006), Center for the Study of Language and Information
- McNally, Louise, "Comitative coordination : a case study in group formation", Natural Language and Linguistic Theory, 11, pp.347~379 (1993)
- Munn, Alan., "Topics in the syntax and semantics of coordinate structures", PhD, pp.1993
- Postal, Paul., "Three investigations of extraction" (1998), MIT Press
- Progovac, Ljiljana, "Negative polarity: entailment and binding", Linguistics and Philosophy, 16, pp.149~180 (1993)
- Progovac, Ljiljana., "Structure for coordination parts I and II", Glot International, 3(7, 8), pp.3~6 (1998)
- Reid, Wallis, "The communicative function of English verb number", Natural Language and Linguistic Theory, 29, pp.1087~1146 (2011)
- Ross, John., "Constraints on variables in syntax", PhD, pp.1967
- Sag, Ivan, "Coordination and how to distinguish categories", Natural Language and Linguistic Theory, 3, pp.117~171 (1985)
- Stassen, Leon, "AND-languages and WITH-languages", Linguistic Typology, 4, pp.1~54 (2000)
- Stolz, Thomas, "To be with X is to have X : comitatives, instrumentals, locative, and predicative possession", Linguistics, 39(2), pp.321~350 (2001)
- Yamada, Masahiro., "Plurality, reciprocity, and plurality of reciprocity", PhD, pp.2010
- Zhang, Niina., "The syntax of English comitative constructions", Folia Linguistica, 41(1-2), pp.135~169 (2007)
- Zhang, Niina, "Explaining the immobility of conjuncts", Studia Linguistica, 64(2), pp.190~238 (2010)
- Zhang, Niina, "Coordination in syntax" (2010), Cambridge University Press
- Zoerner, Ed., "Coordination: The syntax of &P", Ph D, pp.1995