上海自贸区仲裁临时措施制度的思考
Review on Interim Measure of International Commercial Arbitration in SFTZ
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
在全球化的推动下,各国各地区之间贸易和投资稳步增长,随之而来的各种纠纷也在所难免,基于中立性、低成本、一裁终局以及保密性强等等优势,国际商事仲裁成为解决国际贸易投资纠纷的主要手段。当然相比于其他纠纷解决方式,仲裁有其自身的缺陷,一方面仲裁缺乏支持仲裁程序以及结果的强制权力,这使得仲裁裁决的实现常常依赖于第三人的配合;另一方面,也就是本文将要专门探讨的问题即临时措施,无可置疑在仲裁过程中临时措施起着非常重要的作用,比如保存证据、查封金融账户以及及时处理易腐烂货物物品都需要临时措施,可以说临时措施对于保障仲裁有效进行有不可替代的作用。我国相继出台《中国(上海)自由贸易试验区仲裁规则》以及《关于适用〈中国(上海)自由贸易试验区仲裁规则〉的仲裁案件司法审查和执行若干意见》对于临时措施进行了较为详细的规定,但是仍然存在一些不合理之处,如何借鉴国际经验,通过临时措施制度解决商事仲裁所面临的诸多困境,已成为非常重要的研究课题。
Abstract
With the low cost, the finality and high security, International commercial arbitration has become the main means to solve international trade and investment disputes. However, due to the weak coercion of arbitration, thinking about how to guarantee the conduct of arbitration has become an important issue which affect the validity of arbitration, thus, the interim measures become the irreplaceable key of international commercial arbitration. <The Arbitration Rules of The China (Shanghai) Free Trade Area> set rules about interim measures, which is in line with international practice. In the promotion of institutional innovation and boosting the development of the free trade area is of great significance, but thinking the arbitration rules of the free trade area slightly, due to the lack of regulations and fuzziness, we may face many difficulties in the future, such as ineffective enforcement of decision making, double security and the “nullity” of the emergency tribunal. Therefore, it is necessary to conscientiously learn international experience in the future, combining with the work practices of the FTA, creating a rules based international arbitration system. The article first introduced the meaning, character, type and function of the system of interim measures in international commercial arbitration, and then introduced the system from both the issue and enforces of the interim measures. Also, comparing the rules of interim measures in SFTZ and other areas. Finally, the article discussed the practice of the interim measures in SFTZ, that is, from the introduction of the system to the construction of the relevant extension system, such as the extension of the interim measures, the introduction of the emergency arbitration tribunal system and the permission. In addition, it can not be neglected that many difficulties and challenges will be faced in the construction of FTA arbitration rules, such as implementation of the tribunal’s power of decision, the vagueness of the security and the connection between the emergency tribunal and other institutions.
참고문헌 (15)
- 杜新丽, "国际商事仲裁理论与实践专题研究", pp.146~ (2009), 中国政法大学出版社
- 乔欣, "比较商事仲裁", pp.339~ (2004), 法律出版社
- 赵秀文, "国际商事仲裁法", pp.213~ (2004), 中国人民大学出版社
- 赵相林, "国际民商事争议解决的理论与实践", pp.308~ (2009), 中国政法大学出版社
- 黄云, "论我国国际商事仲裁临时措施的发布", 法制与经济, pp.29~32 (2015)
- 周丽霞, "论国际商事仲裁临时措施的域外执行", 河北法学, pp.122~126 (2011)
- 解常晴, "国际仲裁中的临时保全制度及其发展前景", 仲裁与法律, (3), pp.5~27 (2002)
- "北京仲裁", 2013, 119~
- 商事纠纷的解决——可就解决商事纠纷的 某些问题制定的统一规则:调解、临时保护措施、仲裁协议的书面形式的 秘书长报告, "联合国国际贸易法委员会仲裁工作组", 108~, pp.A, CN.9[DOI]
- , 2012
- , 2011
- , 2006
- , 1996
