펀드투자 자금흐름의 결정요인: 유입자금과 유출자금은 대칭적인가?
Determinants of Fund Investment Flows: Asymmetry between Fund Inflows and Fund Outflows
0
조회
0
다운로드
5
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
본 논문은 펀드투자의 유입자금흐름과 유출자금흐름을 별도로 구분하여 결정요인을 실증 분석하였다. 과거 성과, 펀드연령, 펀드규모, 판매보수 등 주요 요인의 자금흐름에 대한 효과는 유입자금과 유출자금 사이에 큰 차이가 있었다. 과거 성과와의 양(＋)의 관계, 펀드연령과의 음(－)의 관계 등 순유입자금을 기반으로 한 기존 연구에서 확립된 실증 결과는 유출자금에 대해서는 반대로 나타났다. 특히 과거 성과의 유출자금과의 관계는 ‘처분효과(disposition effect)’의 존재를 시사하였다. 한편, ‘계열 펀드’와 ‘비계열 펀드’를 구분할 경우 판매보수의 유입자금과 유출자금에 대한 효과가 두 펀드그룹 사이에 상이하여, 판매사 간의 유인체계 차이가 펀드선택시장에서 중요한 요인인 것으로 나타났다. ‘처분효과’의 존재 등 본 논문에서 미국의 기존 연구와 다른 분석 결과가 얻어진 이유는 표본의 차이에 기인하였을 가능성이 있다.
Abstract
We investigate determinants of fund investment flows using Korean equity investment funds. Unlike previous studies which analyzed net-flows (inflow minus outflow), we analyze fund investment inflows and outflows separately that should properly reflect investors’ fund selection and redemption decision. We find similar effects of past return, fund age on net-flows to existing studies based on US market data. The analysis of determinants of inflows shows that inflows are related to past return, fund age and sales fee as netflows. In contrast, outflows are found to behave quite differently from inflows. Apparently, asymmetry exists between fund investment inflows and outflows at the Korean fund selection market. Specifically, high past returns increase fund investment inflows while increase, rather than decrease, fund outflows. Moreover, ‘convexity’ is detected both in inflows and outflows: higher past returns accelerate outflows as well as inflows. Effects of sales fee also differ between inflows and outflows. In the ‘affiliated’ fund sample, sales fee is negatively related to inflows while positively related to outflows. In the ‘unaffiliated’ fund sample, sales fee is positively related to inflows, but no significant relationship exists with outflows. Empirical findings of this paper imply that the rational investor’s fund selection view cannot provide a consistent explanation of the Korean fund selection market. In particular, the positive and convex relationship between past returns and fund outflows is inconsistent with the rational investor view. The fact that investor’s fund investment appears to display ‘disposition effect’, which has been reported by studies of individual investors’ stock investment behaviour suggests that the behavioral finance view should be a part of explanation for the Korean fund selection market. In addition, the strikingly different patterns between the ‘affiliated’ funds and the ‘unaffiliated’ funds, imply that brokers’ incentive structure is another prevailing factor for fund investment flows.
참고문헌 (31)
- 고광수, "주식형 펀드 투자자의 디스포지션 효과", 한국증권학회지, 39(4), pp.517~543 (2010), 한국증권학회
- 금융감독원, "기존 펀드의 판매보수 인하 시행", ~, pp.보도자료 (2010)
- 박영규, "펀드투자자와 펀드매니저의 투자 행태에 관한 연구", 재무연구, 18(1), pp.31~67 (2005), 한국재무학회
- 조성빈, "판매보수의 펀드투자자금과 투자성과에 대한 영향", 금융연구, 26(1), pp.75~105 (2012), 한국금융학회
- Barber, Brad M., "All That Glitters: the Effect of Attention on the Buying Behaviour of Individual and Institutional Investors", Review of Financial Studies, 21, pp.785~818 (2008)
- Barber, Brad M., "Out of Sight, Out of Mind : The Effects of Expenses on Mutual Fund Flows", Journal of Business, 78, pp.2095~2119 (2005)
- Bergstresser, Daniel., "Assessing the Costs and Benefits of Brokers in the Mutual Fund Industry", Review of Financial Studies, 22, pp.4129~4156 (2009)
- Berk, Jonathan B., "Mutual Fund Flows and Performance in Rational Markets", Journal of Political Economy, 112, pp.1269~1295 (2004)
- Robust Inference with Multi-way Clustering, "Cameron, A. Collin.", ~, pp.NBER Technical Working Paper, No. 327 (2006)
- Carhart, Mark M, "On The Persistence of Mutual Fund Performance", Journal of Finance, 52, pp.57~82 (1997)
- Chevalier, Judith and Glenn Ellison, "Risk Taking by Mutual Funds as a Response to Incentives", Journal of Political Economy, 105, pp.1167~1200 (1997)
- Christoffersen, Susan E. K., "What Do Consumers’ Fund Flows Maximize? Evidence from Their Brokers’ Incentives", Journal of Finance, pp.201~235 (2013)
- Chui, Andy, "Individualism and Momentum around the World", Journal of Finance, 65, pp.361~392 (2010)
- Del Guercio, Diane G., "The Determinants of the Flow of Funds of Managed Portfolios: Mutual Funds vs. Pension Funds", Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis, 37, pp.523~557 (2002)
- Fama, Eugene F., "Risk, Return, and Equilibrium: Empirical Tests", Journal of Political Economy, 81, pp.607~636 (1973)
- Goetzmann, William N., "Cognitive Dissonance and Mutual Fund Investors", Journal of Financial Research, 20, pp.145~158 (1997)
- Grinblatt, Mark., "What Makes Investors Trade?", Journal of Finance, 56, pp.589~616 (2001)
- Gruber, Martin J., "Another Puzzle: The Growth in Actively Managed Mutual Funds", Journal of Finance, 51, pp.783~810 (1996)
- Huang, Jennifer C., "Participation Costs and the Sensitivity of Fund Flows to Past Performance", Journal of Finance, 62, pp.1273~1311 (2007)
- Ippolito, Roger A., "Consumer Reaction to Measures of Poor Quality: Evidence from the Mutual Fund Industry", Journal of Law and Economics, 35, pp.45~70 (1992)
- Ivkovic, Zoran, "Individual Investor Mutual Fund Flows", Journal of Financial Economics, 92, pp.223~237 (2009)
- Keswani, Aneel, "Investor Reaction to Mutual Fund Performance:Evidence from UK Distribution Channels", Journal of Financial Research, 35, pp.425~450 (2012)
- 김세완, "Nonlinear Dynamic Relations Between Equity Return and Equity Fund Flow:Korean Market Empirical Evidence", Asia-Pacific Journal of Financial Studies, 39(2), pp.139~170 (2010), 한국증권학회
- Lynch, Anthony W., "How Investors Interpret Past Fund Returns", Journal of Finance, 53, pp.2033~2058 (2003)
- Nanda, Z. Vikram, "Family Values and the Star Phenomenon: Strategies of Mutual Fund Families", Review of Financial Studies, 17, pp.667~698 (2004)
- Newey, Whitney K., "A Simple, Positive Semi-definite Heteroskedasticity and Autocorrelation Consistent Covariance Matrix", Econometrica, 55, pp.703~708 (1987)
- Odean, Terrance, "Are Investors Reluctant to Realize their Losses?", Journal of Finance, 775(1), pp.1775~1798 (1998)
- Petersen, Mitchell, "Estimating Standard Errors in Finance Panel Data Sets:Comparing Approaches", Review of Financial Studies, 22, pp.435~480 (2009)
- Shefrin, Hersh, "The Disposition to Sell Winners Too Early and Ride Losers Too Long: Theory and Evidence", Journal of Finance, 40, pp.777~790 (1985)
- Sirri, Erik R., "Costly Search and Mutual Fund Flows", Journal of Finance, 53, pp.1589~1622 (1998)
- Thompson, Samuel B., "Simple Formulas for Standard Errors That Cluster by Both Firm and Time", Journal of Financial Economics, 99, pp.1~10 (2011)