Effects of Information Provision on Responses to Opinion Polls on the Korea-U.S. Free Trade Agreement
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Two deliberative polls on the Korea–United States Free Trade Agreement were conducted in 2006 and 2007. In both experiments, the respondents become more negative toward the agreement after acquiring additional information provided by a panel discussion and a question-and-answer session. In particular, approval for the expected benefits of the agreement dropped significantly, while perception of its costs remained relatively stable. This experiment shows that public support for the agreement may be vulnerable to counterargument. In spite of the current majority support, the government should step up its efforts to convince the public of the benefits of the agreement in a more tangible way.
Abstract
Two deliberative polls on the Korea–United States Free Trade Agreement were conducted in 2006 and 2007. In both experiments, the respondents become more negative toward the agreement after acquiring additional information provided by a panel discussion and a question-and-answer session. In particular, approval for the expected benefits of the agreement dropped significantly, while perception of its costs remained relatively stable. This experiment shows that public support for the agreement may be vulnerable to counterargument. In spite of the current majority support, the government should step up its efforts to convince the public of the benefits of the agreement in a more tangible way.
참고문헌 (21)
- Bae, K. H, "A study of administrative justification through the deliberation process: The Korean case", Paper presented at the 2006 Summer Conference of the Korean Association for Governance (2006)
- "Polls: Deliberative and non-deliberative. Paper presented at the meetings of the American Association for Public Opinion Research"[URL]
- 조성겸, "공론조사의 숙의 유도 방법 : 한국 상황에서의 문제점 검토", 조사연구, 8(2), pp.43~66 (2007), 한국조사연구학회
- Cho, S. K, "Validity of the discussion process in deliberative polls", Paper presented at the 2006 Spring Conference of the Korean Society for Journalism and Communication Studies (2006)
- Conover, P. J, "Studying “every political talk” in deliberative system", Acta Politica, 40 (2005)
- Elliott,J, ". Participatory methods toolkit, a practitioner’s manual: Deliberative polling", Paper presented at the Public Policy Forum (2005)
- Fishkin,J.S, "Deliberative polling: Toward a better-informed democracy", Center for Deliberative Democracy, Stanford University, ~ (2004)
- "The nation in a room: Turning public opinion into policy"[URL]
- Goodin, R. E, "Deliberative impacts: The macro-political uptake of mini-publics", Politics and Society, 34(2) (2006)
- Hansen,K.M, "The deliberative poll", Discussion paper presented at the Elites and Democracy conference (1999)
- Hansen, K. M, "Deliberative democracy and the deliberative poll on the euro", Scandinavian Political Studies, 27(3), pp.261~286 (2004)
- Hovland, C. I, "Personality and persuasibility" (1959), New Haven: Yale University Press
- Hovland, C. I, "Communication and persuasion: Psychological studies of opinion change" (1953), New Haven: Yale University Press
- Kim,S.H, "Deliberative poll through debate and interactive learning", Planning and Policy, Korea Research Institute for Human Settlements, ~ (2006)
- Kim,W.Y, "A study of the deliberative poll as an effective way of gathering public opinion", Ewha Journal of Social Sciences, 11 (2003)
- Luskin, R. C, "Considered opinion:Deliberative polling in Britain.B.J.Political Science 32:455-87", .J. Political Science, 32, pp.455~487 (2002)
- Ministry of Finance and Economy, "Deliberative poll on 8.31: Real estate policy", ~ (2005)
- Nam,I.Y, "Public relations regarding tap water safety in Seoul metropolitan city", Paper presented at Symposium of Korean Society for Journalism and Communication Studies (2005)
- 오현철, "정치적 대표체계의 민주적 재구성 방안 모색: 토의민주주의 관점에서", 시민사회와 NGO, 4(1), pp.145~176 (2006), 제3섹터연구소
- Sturgis,P, "Knowledge and collective preferences: A comparison of two approaches to estimating the opinions of a better informed public", Sociological Methods and Research, 31(4), pp.453~485 (2003)
- Sturgis, P, "A different take on the deliberative poll", Public Opinion Quarterly, 69(1), pp.30~65 (2005)