수사적 상황과 역할에 따른 대통령 수사학 장르 분석 - 박정희 전 대통령과 박근혜 대통령의 방미연설을 중심으로 -
Comparative Analysis on Presidential Rhetoric as Genre Reflected in Rhetorical Situation and Role Criticism
0
조회
0
다운로드
17
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Rhetorical genre represents a class of messages having important structural and content similarities that creates special expectations among listeners. Presidential rhetoric delivers textual features to the similar effect of creating trust and bonding people. Based on the arguments of Bitzer and Hart, this study attempts to compare and contrast two presidential addresses that were delivered in two different time and spacial settings. For this purpose, former President Park Jung Hee's 1963 National Press Club address in Washington and President Park Geun Hye's 2013 address in U.S. Congress in Washington were chosen. As analytic tools, Hart's credibility strategy index and I-reference style were used, along with Bitzer's elements in rhetorical situation. The results indicated that two Presidents showed similar patterns in their use of credibility strategy and use of I-reference positioning them in a certain role in their speeches. While two speeches, each of which 48 years apart, revealed different rhetorical situations in terms of their exigences, audiences, and contraints, respective presidents retained similar generic features in their addresses. From the results, it could be discussed that the presidential rhetoric as a generic form has a unique construct of communicating messages that pronounce their unique social role and solidate trust system in society.
Abstract
Rhetorical genre represents a class of messages having important structural and content similarities that creates special expectations among listeners. Presidential rhetoric delivers textual features to the similar effect of creating trust and bonding people. Based on the arguments of Bitzer and Hart, this study attempts to compare and contrast two presidential addresses that were delivered in two different time and spacial settings. For this purpose, former President Park Jung Hee's 1963 National Press Club address in Washington and President Park Geun Hye's 2013 address in U.S. Congress in Washington were chosen. As analytic tools, Hart's credibility strategy index and I-reference style were used, along with Bitzer's elements in rhetorical situation. The results indicated that two Presidents showed similar patterns in their use of credibility strategy and use of I-reference positioning them in a certain role in their speeches. While two speeches, each of which 48 years apart, revealed different rhetorical situations in terms of their exigences, audiences, and contraints, respective presidents retained similar generic features in their addresses. From the results, it could be discussed that the presidential rhetoric as a generic form has a unique construct of communicating messages that pronounce their unique social role and solidate trust system in society.
참고문헌 (16)
- 곽중철, "미국 대통령의 위기 수사(Rhetoric)에 관한 연구: 북한 핵 위기 관련 Clinton과 Bush 행정부 담론의 비교", 박사, 신문방송학, pp.2003
- 강태완, "역대 대통령의 연설문에 나타난 수사적 특징과역할 규정", 사회과학연구, 30(2) (2004)
- 박성희, "대통령 취임 연설의 제의적(Epideictic) 특성 수사 분석 : 버락 오바마 미국 대통령 취임연설문을 중심으로", 스피치와 커뮤니케이션, (11), pp.195~222 (2009), 한국소통학회
- 이윤지, "미국 대통령 취임 연설문의 수사에 관한 연구 : 토마스 제퍼슨에서 버락 오바마까지 대통령 10명의 취임 연설문을 중심으로, Diction 5.0 적용", 석사, 언론홍보영상학, pp.2011
- 강원도민일보, "박정희 의장과 박근혜 대통령 그리고 방미", 강원도민일보 2013년 5월 8일, ~ (2013)
- 국민일보, "박정희는 52년전 돈 빌리러 갔던 미국…박근혜는 경제 동반자 되어 찾는다", 국민일보 2013년 5월 3일, ~ (2013)
- 서울경제, "박근혜 대통령 방미기간 상하원 합동연설", 서울경제 2013년 4월 24일, ~ (2013)
- 중앙일보, "박정희 대통령 방미의 기억", 중앙일보 2013년 4월 30일, ~ (2013)
- 한국일보, "박 의장과 박 대통령의 방미 일정", 한국일보 2013년 6월 2일, ~ (2013)
- 채널 A 뉴스, "박정희-박근혜 ‘부녀 대통령’의 다른 방미", 채널 A 뉴스 2013년 5월 3일, ~ (2013)
- 채널 A 뉴스, "박정희 父女와 미국의 52년 인연", 채널 A 뉴스 2013년 5월 9일, ~ (2013)
- 헤럴드경제, "박정희 - 박근혜 ’미국 인연’ 화제. 53년만에 블레어 하우스에 똑같이", 헤럴드경제 2013년 5월 6일, ~ (2013)
- Bitzer, L. F, "The rhetorical situation", Philosophy & Rhetoric, 25, pp.1~14 (1992)
- Campbell, K. K, "Presidents Creating the Presidency Chicago and London" (2008), University of Chicago Press
- Dorsey L. G, "The presidency and rhetorical leadership" (2002), Texas A&M University Press
- Hart, R. P, "Modern rhetorical criticism" (1997), Allyn and Bacon
