한반도 연안 위성합성 및 수치모델 재분석 해수면온도 자료의 정확도
The Accuracy of Satellite-composite GHRSST and Model-reanalysis Sea Surface Temperature Data at the Seas Adjacent to the Korean Peninsula
2
조회
0
다운로드
5
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
This study evaluates the accuracy of four satellite-composite (OSTIA, AVHRR, G1SST, FNMONC-S) and three model-reanalysis (HYCOM, JCOPE2, FNMOC-M) daily sea surface temperature (SST) data around the Korean Peninsula (KP) using ocean buoy data from 2011−2016. The results reveal that OSTIA has the lowest root mean square error (RMSE; 0.68oC) and FNMOC-S/M has the highest correction coefficients (r = 0.993) compared with observations, while G1SST, JCOPE2, and AVHRR have relatively larger RMSEs and smaller correlations. The large RMSEs were found in the western coastal regions of the KP where water depth is shallow and tides are strong, such as Chilbaldo and Deokjeokdo, while low RMSEs were found in the East Sea and open oceans where water depth is relatively deep such as Donghae, Ulleungdo, and Marado. We found that the main sources of the large RMSEs, sometimes reaching up to 5oC, in SST data around the KP, can be attributed to rapid SST changes during events of strong tidal mixing, upwelling, and typhoon-induced mixing. The errors in the background SST fields which are used in data assimilations and satellite composites and the missing in-situ observations are also potential sources of large SST errors. These results suggest that both satellite and reanalysis SST data, which are believed to be true observation-based data, sometimes, can have significant inherent errors in specific regions around the KP and thus the use of such SST products should proceed with caution particularly when the aforementioned events occur.
Abstract
This study evaluates the accuracy of four satellite-composite (OSTIA, AVHRR, G1SST, FNMONC-S) and three model-reanalysis (HYCOM, JCOPE2, FNMOC-M) daily sea surface temperature (SST) data around the Korean Peninsula (KP) using ocean buoy data from 2011−2016. The results reveal that OSTIA has the lowest root mean square error (RMSE; 0.68oC) and FNMOC-S/M has the highest correction coefficients (r = 0.993) compared with observations, while G1SST, JCOPE2, and AVHRR have relatively larger RMSEs and smaller correlations. The large RMSEs were found in the western coastal regions of the KP where water depth is shallow and tides are strong, such as Chilbaldo and Deokjeokdo, while low RMSEs were found in the East Sea and open oceans where water depth is relatively deep such as Donghae, Ulleungdo, and Marado. We found that the main sources of the large RMSEs, sometimes reaching up to 5oC, in SST data around the KP, can be attributed to rapid SST changes during events of strong tidal mixing, upwelling, and typhoon-induced mixing. The errors in the background SST fields which are used in data assimilations and satellite composites and the missing in-situ observations are also potential sources of large SST errors. These results suggest that both satellite and reanalysis SST data, which are believed to be true observation-based data, sometimes, can have significant inherent errors in specific regions around the KP and thus the use of such SST products should proceed with caution particularly when the aforementioned events occur.
참고문헌 (27)
- Chassignet EP, "The HYCOM (Hybrid Coordinate Ocean Model) data assimilative system", J Mar Syst, 65, pp.60~83 (2007)
- Cummings JA, "Operational oceanography in the 21st century", pp.91~121 (2011), Springer
- Donlon CJ, "Toward improved validation of satellite sea surface skin temperature measurements for climate research", J Climate, 15, pp.353~369 (2002)
- Chelle L. Gentemann, "In situ validation of tropical rainfall measuring mission microwave sea surface temperatures", Journal of Geophysical Research, 109(C4), pp.C04021~ (2004), American Geophysical Union (AGU)[DOI]
- 정영윤, "태풍 에위니아 (0603) 통과 후 상층해양 변동 특성과 영향", 대기, 23(2), pp.205~220 (2013), 한국기상학회[DOI]
- 김성대, "연구사업 해양자료 관리를 위한 표준화와 해양물리자료 표준(안)", Ocean and Polar Research, 37(4), pp.249~263 (2015), 한국해양과학기술원[DOI]
- Kim H-Y, "Characteristics of sea surface temperature errors in the seas around Korea using GCOM-W1", AMSR2, Seoul National University, 2017
- 고은별, "기상청 전지구 해양순환예측시스템(NEMO", NEMOVAR)과 미해군 해양자료동화시스템(HYCOM, 대기, pp.2018, 28(1)[DOI]
- Korea Meteorological Administration, "Guidelines for marine meteorological observations", Korea Meteorological Administration, 100~ (2013)
- Lin I, "New evidence for enhanced ocean primary production triggered by tropical cyclone", Geophys Res Lett, 30(51), pp.1~4 (2003)
- Martin M, "Group for high resolution SST (GHRSST)analysis fields inter-comparisons Part 1. A GHRSST multiproduct ensemble (GMPE)", Deep-Sea Res Part II, 77, pp.21~30 (2012)
- Miyazawa Y, "The JCOPE ocean forecast system", First ARGO Science Workshop (2003)
- Moon I-J, "A study on the cause of the unusual coastal flooding generated by typhoon Winnie along the western coast of Korea", Nat Hazards, 29(3), pp.485~500 (2003)
- Moon I-J, "Impact of upper-ocean thermal structure on the intensity of Korean peninsular landfall typhoons", Prog Oceanogr, 105, pp.61~66 (2012)
- "News flash for abnormal sea conditions: Alert on abnormal cold water near Homigot" (2013)[URL]
- 박경애, "인공위성관측 해수면온도와 현장관측 수온의 비교를 통해 본 해양 피층-표층 수온의 차이", 대한원격탐사학회지, 24(4), pp.273~287 (2008), 대한원격탐사학회
- Reynolds RW, "An improved in situ and satellite SST analysis for climate", J Climate, 15(13), pp.1609~1625 (2002)
- Reynolds RW, "Impacts of in situ and additional satellite data on the accuracy of a sea surface temperature analysis for climate", Int J Climatol, 25, pp.857~864 (2005)
- Reynolds RW, "Daily high-resolution-blended analyses for sea surface temperature", J Climate, 20, pp.5473~5496 (2007)
- Reynolds RW, "Comparisons of daily sea surface temperature analyses for 2007−08", J Climate, 23(13), pp.3545~3562 (2010)
- Lucrezia Ricciardulli, "Uncertainties in sea surface temperature retrievals from space: Comparison of microwave and infrared observations from TRMM", Journal of Geophysical Research, 109(C12), pp.C12013~ (2004), American Geophysical Union (AGU)[DOI]
- Seung YH, "Oceanographic studies related to the tidal front in the mid-Yellow Sea off Korea: physical aspects", J Korean Soc Oceanogr, 25(2), pp.84~95 (1990)
- Shaoling Shang, "Changes of temperature and bio-optical properties in the South China Sea in response to Typhoon Lingling, 2001", Geophysical Research Letters, 35(10), pp.L10602~ (2008), American Geophysical Union (AGU)[DOI]
- Shay LK, "Upper ocean response to Hurricane Gilbert", J Geophys Res, 97, pp.227~247 (1992)
- Stammer D, "Gentemann C(2003)Validation of microwave sea surface temperature measurements for climate purposes", J Climate, 16(1), pp.73~87 (2003)
- Stark JD, "OSTIA: An operational, high resolution, real time, global sea surface temperature analysis system", Oceans 2007- Europe (2007)
- Xie J, "Assessment and inter-comparison of five high-resolution sea surface temperature products in the shelf and coastal seas around China", Cont Shelf Res, 28, pp.1286~1293 (2008)