본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

왜 여성 음악사인가

Why Women’s Music History?

1

조회

0

다운로드

5

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

초록

Research on feminist musicology or women in music was influenced and triggered by feminist movement and women’s studies of around 1970s, and contributed to the rapid proliferation of feminist knowledge that took place after 1990. Female musicologists who had access to professional education in the United States were not only able to accumulate and analyze various historical documents on women’s musical activities, but also led to the emergence of ‘feminist criticism’, which aims to critique and interpret works regarded as canon of music history (i.e. male composers’ works) from a feminist perspective. In particular, scholars like Susan McClary, Suzanne Cusick, and Ruth Solie continue to study and identify various relationships between women and music, within the context of history, society, race, ideology, and gender. On the other hand, although women played a pivotal role informing Korea’s music culture after the introduction of western music in Korea, the importance of women’s subjective study on music was not recognized and failed to attract attention from the academia for sometime. It was only around 2000 when few women scholars like Min EunKee, Lee YoungMin, Lee KyungHee, and others started to study the topic, and garnered attention of other scholars for a while. However, active discourse on the topic has just begun. Therefore, this study attempts to make women more visible in general music history which is disguised as universal music history, and identify women’s musical experience which naturally was different from that of men. Women have long been defined by “others” more than any other group, and were deprived of knowledge of their own history. Female historian Gerda Lerner emphasized the importance of history research, saying “Future can be predicted by reflecting upon the past. History guides us toward the path to self-recognition, and is the life blood giving meaning to our lives”. In order to position women at the center of musical incidents as an active motive, the other half of music history which disappeared need to be reconstructed. Setting a new context for women should be the starting point in achieving this objective. In order to accept women’s music more subjectively rather than to fill in the void for women musicians by attempting to compensate for their lost history, this study aims to discuss why we need to describe women’s music history and how it should be depicted, by comparing and analyzing various studies on women’s history.

Abstract

Research on feminist musicology or women in music was influenced and triggered by feminist movement and women’s studies of around 1970s, and contributed to the rapid proliferation of feminist knowledge that took place after 1990. Female musicologists who had access to professional education in the United States were not only able to accumulate and analyze various historical documents on women’s musical activities, but also led to the emergence of ‘feminist criticism’, which aims to critique and interpret works regarded as canon of music history (i.e. male composers’ works) from a feminist perspective. In particular, scholars like Susan McClary, Suzanne Cusick, and Ruth Solie continue to study and identify various relationships between women and music, within the context of history, society, race, ideology, and gender. On the other hand, although women played a pivotal role informing Korea’s music culture after the introduction of western music in Korea, the importance of women’s subjective study on music was not recognized and failed to attract attention from the academia for sometime. It was only around 2000 when few women scholars like Min EunKee, Lee YoungMin, Lee KyungHee, and others started to study the topic, and garnered attention of other scholars for a while. However, active discourse on the topic has just begun. Therefore, this study attempts to make women more visible in general music history which is disguised as universal music history, and identify women’s musical experience which naturally was different from that of men. Women have long been defined by “others” more than any other group, and were deprived of knowledge of their own history. Female historian Gerda Lerner emphasized the importance of history research, saying “Future can be predicted by reflecting upon the past. History guides us toward the path to self-recognition, and is the life blood giving meaning to our lives”. In order to position women at the center of musical incidents as an active motive, the other half of music history which disappeared need to be reconstructed. Setting a new context for women should be the starting point in achieving this objective. In order to accept women’s music more subjectively rather than to fill in the void for women musicians by attempting to compensate for their lost history, this study aims to discuss why we need to describe women’s music history and how it should be depicted, by comparing and analyzing various studies on women’s history.

참고문헌 (30)

  1. 민은기, "페미니즘 음악학의 성과와 전망", 서양음악학, 5통권 : 5호, pp.33~81 (2002), 한국서양음악학회
  2. 민은기, "페미니즘 음악비평: 바그너의 <니벨룽겐의 반지>에 나타난 여성주체의 정체성", 음악이론연구, 7 (2002), 서울대학교 서양음악연구소
  3. 박정숙, "힐데가르트 폰 빙겐(Hilegard von Bingen)의 <심포니아(Symphonia armonie celestium revelationum)> 연구", 석사, pp.2007
  4. 백영경, "여성의 눈으로 역사 읽기", 여성과 사회, 10 (1999), 한국여성연구소
  5. 설혜심, "서양 여성사의 역사", 학림, 통권 : 28호 (2007), 연세대학교 사학연구회
  6. 이경희, "페미니즘 음악비평: 소나타 형식에 나타난 페미니즘 비평", 음악이론연구, 7 (2002), 서울대학교 서양음악연구소
  7. 이영민, "서양음악사 속의 여성들: 중세", 서양음악학, 5통권 : 5호, pp.11~23 (2002), 한국서양음악학회
  8. 이창신, "미국 여성과 여성사: 성, 젠더, 그리고 차이의 역사학", 미국사 연구, 10 (1999), 한국미국사학회
  9. 정현백, "새로운 여성사, 새로운 역사학", 역사학보, 통권 : 150호 (1996), 역사학회
  10. 조순경, "한국 여성학 지식의 사회적 형성", 경제와 사회, 통권 : 45호 (2000), 한국산업사회학회
  11. 채현경, "새 음악학: 해체, 페미니즘, 그리고 통합" (2007), 파주: 궁리
  12. 한국여성연구소, "새 여성학 강의" (2005), 서울: 동녘
  13. Bowers, Jane, "Women Making Music: The Western Art Tradition, 1150-1950" (1987), Urbana and Chicago: University of Illinois Press
  14. Briscoe, James R, "New Historical Anthology of Music by Women" (2004), Bloomington and Indianapolis: Indiana University Press
  15. Cook, Nicolas, "Music: A Very Short Introduction(음악이란 무엇인가)" (2004), 서울: 동문선
  16. Donovan, Josephine, "Feminist Theory(페미니즘 이론)" (1994), 서울: 문예출판사
  17. Evans, Sara M, "Born for Liberty: A History of Women in America(자유를 위한 탄생, 미국 여성의 역사)" (1998), 서울: 이화여자대학교 출판부
  18. Friedan, Betty, "The Feminine Mystique(여성의 신비)" (2005), 서울: 이매진
  19. Herbert, Trevor, "“Social History and Music History,” in The Cultural Study of Music" (2003), New York: Routledge
  20. Hrdy, Sarah Blaffer, "The woman that Never Evolved(여성은 진화하지 않았다)" (2006), 서울: 서해문집
  21. Lerner, Gerda, "The Creation of Feminist Consciousness(역사 속의 페미니스트)" (1999), 서울: 평민사
  22. Lerner, Gerda, "The Creation of patriarchy(가부장제의 창조)" (2004), 서울: 당대
  23. Lerner, Gerda, "Why History Matters(왜 여성사인가)" (2006), 서울: 푸른역사
  24. Miles, Rosalind, "Who Cooked the Last Supper(최후의 만찬은 누가 차렸을까)" (2002), 서울: 동녘
  25. Morris, Pam, "Literature and Feminism(문학과 페미니즘)" (1999), 서울: 문예출판사
  26. Nochlin, Linda, "Women, Art, and Power(페미니즘 미술사)" (1997), 서울: 예경
  27. Pendle, Karin, "Women and Music: A History" (2001), Bloomington and Indianapolis: Indiana University Press
  28. Scott, Joan W, "Gender and Politics of History" (1988), New York: Columbia University Press
  29. Tick, Judith, "“Women in music,” The New Grove dictionary of music and musicians" (2001), London: Macmillan
  30. Tuttle, Lisa, "Encyclopedia of Feminism(페미니즘 사전)" (1999), 서울: 동문선

관련 논문AI추천

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (9건)