What Makes A Case Study Really Qualitative?: Show Me Your Evidence, Please!
2
조회
0
다운로드
10
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
This paper examines 38 qualitative case studies, published from 2007 to 2009, to critically review whether the core notions of qualitative inquiry have been realized in the articles published within last three years. Based on the integrated criteria of evaluation from several researchers, one can conclude that most of the participating case studies in this study lack negative case analyses, which challenge researcher's hypotheses or beliefs. As a result, the credibility of the researchers’ interpretations is seriously threatened. In addition, the notion of triangulation has still not been represented, although participating researchers claim that they did collect data from a variety of sources in their studies. To reach a credible conclusion, all researchers would agree that negative case analysis and data triangulation are not options but necessary conditions, especially in case studies. To fill the gap between the qualitative researchers’ awareness of these standards and their failure to represent the results in incorporated and systematic ways, the researcher of this study postulates that adopting a computer assisted qualitative data analysis system (CAQDAS) may not only enhance the quality of analysis, but make the writing process less complicated.
Abstract
This paper examines 38 qualitative case studies, published from 2007 to 2009, to critically review whether the core notions of qualitative inquiry have been realized in the articles published within last three years. Based on the integrated criteria of evaluation from several researchers, one can conclude that most of the participating case studies in this study lack negative case analyses, which challenge researcher's hypotheses or beliefs. As a result, the credibility of the researchers’ interpretations is seriously threatened. In addition, the notion of triangulation has still not been represented, although participating researchers claim that they did collect data from a variety of sources in their studies. To reach a credible conclusion, all researchers would agree that negative case analysis and data triangulation are not options but necessary conditions, especially in case studies. To fill the gap between the qualitative researchers’ awareness of these standards and their failure to represent the results in incorporated and systematic ways, the researcher of this study postulates that adopting a computer assisted qualitative data analysis system (CAQDAS) may not only enhance the quality of analysis, but make the writing process less complicated.
참고문헌 (73)
- 안경자, "Teaching as One Has Been Taught: The Impact of Teacher Socialization on the Implementation of English Curricular Reform", 영어교육, 63(3), pp.91~117 (2008), 한국영어교육학회
- 안경자, "Do innovative technologies bring about innovative instructional practices? A case study of a Korean EFL teacher’s class under the curricular reform context", 멀티미디어 언어교육, 12(2), pp.9~42 (2009), 한국멀티미디어언어교육학회
- 안경자, "Learning to Write Academic English: A Sociocultural Perspective on L2 Learners’ Writing Portfolios", 응용언어학, 25(2), pp.1~34 (2009), 한국응용언어학회
- Alisha Witmer, "Practicing Participating in an Academic Discourse: Language Socialization during ESL Teacher-Student Writing Conferences", 영어교육, 64(2), pp.173~197 (2009), 한국영어교육학회
- 차경화, "A Case Study of Assessing Young Children with English Language Proficiency in Korea", 영어교육연구, 21(1), pp.247~271 (2009), 팬코리아영어교육학회
- 최？ 재？ 영, "그림 동화책을 이용한 유치원 영어 수업: 교수 방법과 학습자의 발화 양상", 영어교육연구, 19(3), pp.221~10 (2007), 팬코리아영어교육학회
- 최성희, "A Case Study of Korean EFL Teachers' Small Group Work", Foreign Languages Education, 14(4), pp.1~25 (2007), 한국외국어교육학회
- 한은미, "수업 컨설팅을 통한 초등영어 교사의 내용교수지식 발달에 관한 사례 연구", 초등영어교육, 14(2), pp.73~94 (2008), 한국초등영어교육학회
- 한학선, "Influence of Parent-Child Interaction through Reading of Books on SLA:Socio-Cultural Approach", 영어교육연구, 20(1), pp.133~155 (2008), 팬코리아영어교육학회
- 장은영, "A Window on Identity: Diary Study for Understanding English Language Learners’ Identity Construction", 영어교육, 64(3), pp.53~78 (2009), 한국영어교육학회
- 전지현, "Strategic Behavior: A Case Study of a Korean Student's Reading Difficulty in US Classrooms", 응용언어학, 25(2), pp.65~95 (2009), 한국응용언어학회
- 지현희, "고등학생 영어 글쓰기 과정에 관한 사례 연구: 모국어의 역할을 중심으로", 영어교육연구, 19(4), pp.301~12 (2007), 팬코리아영어교육학회
- 주형미, "Cross-language Transfer of Reading Strategies and Knowledge among Korean-English Bilingual Students", 영어교육, 63(3), pp.259~285 (2008), 한국영어교육학회
- 염수경, "e-Learning 국제교류협력 프로젝트를 통한 초등학생들의 영어학습 사례연구: Flying Time Capsule Project", 영어교육연구, 21(3), pp.263~284 (2009), 팬코리아영어교육학회
- Kang, Su-Ja, "Korean ESL Students’ Ambivalence: Desire to Have and Desire to Avoid Communication with American Friends", 영어교육, 62(3), pp.101~124 (2007), 한국영어교육학회
- Kang, Y. S, "Implications for language teacher education", English Language Teaching, (37), pp.30~48 (2008)
- 김봉규, "A case study on scaffolding interaction in L2 reading activities", 초등영어교육, 15(2), pp.129~150 (2009), 한국초등영어교육학회
- 김병철, "Using Movies to Teach English Phrasal Verbs: A Case Study of the Movie Grease", 영상영어교육(STEM Journal), 10(1), pp.3~25 (2009), 영상영어교육학회
- 김은정, "외국어 영재교육 교사연수를 통하여 살펴본 교사의 영재교육에 관한 인식", Foreign Languages Education, 14(4), pp.255~278 (2007), 한국외국어교육학회
- 김은주, "Status Quo of CLT-based English Curricular Reform: A Teacher’s Voice from the Classroom", 영어교육, 63(2), pp.43~69 (2008), 한국영어교육학회
- 김혜영, "온라인 결합 초등영어커리큘럼: 애플사례연구", 멀티미디어 언어교육, 10(1), pp.177~200 (2007), 한국멀티미디어언어교육학회
- 김정민, "영어 교재 분석 평가의 사례", 영어어문교육, 13(4), pp.233~252 (2007), 한국영어어문교육학회
- 김경자, "Writing Strategies and Writing Proficiency in the EFL Classroom", Foreign Languages Education, 15(1), pp.69~89 (2008), 한국외국어교육학회
- Myonghee Kim, "A Case Study of an Online Graduate Course for Worldwide Language Teachers", 멀티미디어 언어교육, 10(2), pp.98~124 (2007), 한국멀티미디어언어교육학회
- 김양희, "A Case Study of Home Literacy Development and Practices in a Korean Family in the US", Foreign Languages Education, 14(3), pp.149~178 (2007), 한국외국어교육학회
- 김윤규, "Taking Turns in Class Discussions in English: Exploring Korean Graduate Students’ Experiences", Foreign Languages Education, 14(4), pp.49~72 (2007), 한국외국어교육학회
- 이은실, "Emotional Issues in Language Learning: A Case Study of Korean Female Students in Short Term Study Abroad", 영어어문교육, 14(2), pp.131~148 (2008), 한국영어어문교육학회
- 이 정 원, "A Case Study on Written Language Use and Interactions in Dialogue Journals", 영어교육, 62(2), pp.79~100 (2007), 한국영어교육학회
- 이정원, "영자신문을 활용한 고등학생의 영어 독해능력 향상에 관한 사례 연구", 영어어문교육, 13(1), pp.159~180 (2007), 한국영어어문교육학회
- 이선자, "영어 읽기 장애현상을 보이는 아동의 효과적 지도에 관한 사례연구", 초등영어교육, 15(1), pp.185~213 (2009), 한국초등영어교육학회
- Nam, Jung Mi, "A Case Study of Two Korean Students' Classroom Interactions in a Graduate Course in America", 영어어문교육, 13(3), pp.57~75 (2007), 한국영어어문교육학회
- Tae-Il Pae, "Potential determinants of successful L2 academic writing: A case study with two novice L2 writers.", 영어교육연구, 19(3), pp.47~3 (2007), 팬코리아영어교육학회
- Paek, Jiwon, "Learners’ attitudes and listening proficiency in verbal interaction.", 영어교육연구, 19(1), pp.29~2 (2007), 팬코리아영어교육학회
- 박명주, "Language Use of English-speaking Children in the Immersion Classrooms", 영어교육연구, 20(1), pp.85~105 (2008), 팬코리아영어교육학회
- 박선호, "초등학교 몰입식 영어교육 사례 연구", 초등영어교육, 15(2), pp.5~39 (2009), 한국초등영어교육학회
- 신유선, "The Effects of Graphic Organizers in L2 Writing Instruction: A Case Study of an L2 Writing Instructor", 영어교육연구, 21(1), pp.137~155 (2009), 팬코리아영어교육학회
- Steven L. Thorne, "New Media Language Use and “Bridging Activities”: Implications for Plurilingual Life in a (Partially) Digital World", 멀티미디어 언어교육, 11(1), pp.35~60 (2008), 한국멀티미디어언어교육학회
- 윤은자, "Literature-based Instruction: A Case Study of an Elementary ESL Classroom in the US", 영어교육연구, 20(3), pp.119~141 (2008), 팬코리아영어교육학회
- Allwright, D, "Focus on the language classroom: An introduction to classroom research for language teachers" (1991), Cambridge University Press
- Bloomberg, L. D, "Completing your qualitative dissertation: A roadmap from beginning to end" (2008), Sage
- Bogdan, R. C, "Qualitative research for education: An introduction to theories and methods" (2007), Pearson Education
- Creswell, J. W, "Research design: Qualitative, quantitative, and mixed methods approaches" (2003), Sage
- Denzin, N. K, "Handbook of qualitative research" (2000), Sage
- Duff, P, "Case study research in applied linguistics" (2008), Lawrence Erlbaum Associates
- Ellingson, L. L, "Engaging crystallization in qualitative research: An introduction" (2009), Sage
- Farrell, T. S. C, "Exploring EFL classrooms at a Korean university", English Teaching, 49, pp.285~309 (1994)
- Flick, U, "Managing quality in qualitative research" (2008), Sage
- Geertz, C, "Thick description: Toward an interpretive theory of culture. In Turning points in qualitative research: Tying knots in a handkerchief", pp.143~168 (2003), AltaMira Press
- Holliday, A, "Doing and writing qualitative research" (2002), Sage
- 유현정, "학술지 논문을 통한 영어교육학 연구동향 분석", Foreign Languages Education, 13(3), pp.339~368 (2006), 한국외국어교육학회
- Kim, J. W, "Research trends in TEFL studies in Korea and future research directions: Focusing on research methodology, orientation, and topic", English Teaching, 61(special), pp.247~260 (2006)
- Krashen, S, "The input hypothesis: Issues and implications" (1985), Longman
- Lincoln, Y. S, "Naturalistic inquiry" (1985), Sage
- Locke, L. F, "Proposals that work : A guide for planning dissertations and grant proposals (3rd ed.)" (1993), Sage
- Long, M, "Native speaker", non-native speaker conversation in the second language classroom, 1982, ~
- Maxwell, J. A, "Qualitative research design" (1996), Sage
- Merriam, S. B, "Qualitative research and case study applications in education" (1998), Jossey-Bass
- Mitchell, J. C, "Case and situational analysis", Sociological Review, 31(2), pp.187~211 (1983)
- Nunan, D, "Research methods in language learning" (1994), Cambridge University
- Park, C, "Understanding qualitative research: Learning by doing" (2006), Hyungsul
- Park, Chongwon, "From Qualitative to Quantitative Continuum: Exploring the Possibility with the Aid of the CAQDAS (Nvivo 2)", 영어교육, 59(4), pp.71~96 (2004), 한국영어교육학회
- Park, C, "Peer pressure and learning to speak English", English Teaching, 55(4), pp.231~268 (2000)
- Richards, K, "Qualitative inquiry in TESOL" (2003), Macmillan
- "The new features of NVivo 9 In http:", pp.QSR, www.qsrinternational.com
- Saldana, J, "The coding manual for qualitative researchers" (2009), Sage
- Sandelowski, M, "Writing a good read: Strategies for representing qualitative data", Research in Nursing & Health, 21(4), pp.375~382 (1998)
- Savin-Baden, M, "New approaches to qualitative research: Wisdom and uncertainty" (2010), Routledge
- Seale, C, "The quality of qualitative research" (1999), Sage
- Seidman, I, "Interviewing as qualitative research: A guide for researchers in education and the social sciences" (2006), Teachers College
- Seror, J, "Computers and qualitative data analysis: Paper, pens, and high-lighters vs. screen, mouse, and keyboard", TESOL Quarterly, 39, pp.321~328 (2005)
- Swain, M, "Communicative competence: Some roles of comprehensible input and comprehensible output in its development. In Input in second language acquisition", pp.235~253 (1985), Newbury House
- van Lier, L, "The classroom and language learner" (1988), Longman
- Wolcott, H. F, "Transforming qualitative data: Description, analysis, and interpretation" (1994), Sage