본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

독일과 한국의 보험소비자보호의 쟁점

Issues for Insurance Consumer Protection in Germany and Korea

2

조회

0

다운로드

1

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

주제분류법학

초록

Nowadays the protection of finance consumer, including insurance consumer is hot issue worldwide after world finance crisis in the year of 2007. Some countries have changed the finance supervisory board system. To seek rational dispute settlement system in the field of finance is also common issue internationally. The developed countries are also making hard effort for the reform of finance contract related laws, especially insurance contract law. For example, in germany(2007) and in japan(2008) there was heavy reform in the field of insurance contract law. There is also a sort of competition for the making of better finance related contract law internationally. Other countries, like United Kingdom and australia, are also making effort to get better insurance contract law. The current korean insurance contract law in korean commercial code was effected in 1963. It has many problems. The reform discussion about korean insurance contract law is being done in korean national assembly. To solve the problems we must look at foreign laws. Especially the german insurance contract law (VVG) has influences to korean law because we adopted the continental- european legal system. The german insurance contract law was reformed in 2007 significantly. It was effected on 1. jan. 2008. Japan has also new separate insurance law on 6. june 2008. It is effected on 1.4.2010. The german reform issues are follows: reform of definition of insurance contract, the reflection of technical development, the reform of insurance police, duty to give sufficient informations to other party, reform of the duty of disclosure, reform of the definition of insurance interest, the abandonment of all or nothing principal, the duty to give correct model estimation paper. Especially, the duty of disclosure was very important reform issue in germany. The japanese insurance law has adopted the duty of passive answer in regard of duty of disclosure. By the way, we should regard special character of insurance contract as contract of utmost good faith when we discuss about the reform of insurance contract law. The insurance contract law is very important for the welfare of citizens. The reform of insurance contract law is also in korea hot issue. This study concentrates on showing desirable way to protect the insurance consumer. To solve this problem we should also consider reforming the current finance supervisory board system. The insured should get sufficient information about the insurance contract. The government should offer rational and chief grievance settlement system. The standard contract terms about electronic insurance transaction should also be suitably and properly arranged. We can get our goal for insurance consumer protection when all these measures are fulfilled. The government, scholar, insurance associations and insurance companies should make hard effort to attain their goals.

Abstract

Nowadays the protection of finance consumer, including insurance consumer is hot issue worldwide after world finance crisis in the year of 2007. Some countries have changed the finance supervisory board system. To seek rational dispute settlement system in the field of finance is also common issue internationally. The developed countries are also making hard effort for the reform of finance contract related laws, especially insurance contract law. For example, in germany(2007) and in japan(2008) there was heavy reform in the field of insurance contract law. There is also a sort of competition for the making of better finance related contract law internationally. Other countries, like United Kingdom and australia, are also making effort to get better insurance contract law. The current korean insurance contract law in korean commercial code was effected in 1963. It has many problems. The reform discussion about korean insurance contract law is being done in korean national assembly. To solve the problems we must look at foreign laws. Especially the german insurance contract law (VVG) has influences to korean law because we adopted the continental- european legal system. The german insurance contract law was reformed in 2007 significantly. It was effected on 1. jan. 2008. Japan has also new separate insurance law on 6. june 2008. It is effected on 1.4.2010. The german reform issues are follows: reform of definition of insurance contract, the reflection of technical development, the reform of insurance police, duty to give sufficient informations to other party, reform of the duty of disclosure, reform of the definition of insurance interest, the abandonment of all or nothing principal, the duty to give correct model estimation paper. Especially, the duty of disclosure was very important reform issue in germany. The japanese insurance law has adopted the duty of passive answer in regard of duty of disclosure. By the way, we should regard special character of insurance contract as contract of utmost good faith when we discuss about the reform of insurance contract law. The insurance contract law is very important for the welfare of citizens. The reform of insurance contract law is also in korea hot issue. This study concentrates on showing desirable way to protect the insurance consumer. To solve this problem we should also consider reforming the current finance supervisory board system. The insured should get sufficient information about the insurance contract. The government should offer rational and chief grievance settlement system. The standard contract terms about electronic insurance transaction should also be suitably and properly arranged. We can get our goal for insurance consumer protection when all these measures are fulfilled. The government, scholar, insurance associations and insurance companies should make hard effort to attain their goals.

참고문헌 (40)

  1. 정찬형, "상법강의(하) (제6판)" (2004), 박영사
  2. 전자거래와 관련한 약관규제법의 정비방안, 전자거래 관련 법제정비방안, "김동훈", 한국법제연구원, ~ (2001)
  3. 김상래, "인터넷뱅킹의 법적 문제와 해결과제", e-commerce (2002), 한국전자거래진흥원
  4. 김성태, "보험법강론" (2001), 법문사
  5. 김은경, "사법공통기준틀(CFR)과 유럽보험계약법의 원칙(PEICL)의 분석 -PEICL에 나타난 보험자의 정보제공의무를 중심으로-", 외법논집, 34(3), pp.19~37 (2010), 법학연구소
  6. 김은경, "보험시장의 효율성을 위한 보험옴부즈맨제도의 연구 - 독일을 중심으로 -", 경영법률, 18(4), pp.205~238 (2008), 한국경영법률학회
  7. 김진환, "약관의 계약편입과 전자약관", 법조, (537) (2001), 법조협회
  8. 박삼철, "투자신탁해설" (2001), 삼우사
  9. 삼성화재, "고객권익보호위원회 심의결정 사례집", ~ (2010)
  10. 서울대학교 금융법센터, "금융시장의 환경변화에 따른 금융관계 법률의 체제정비에 관한 연구" (2002)
  11. 심재승, "영국금융옴부즈만시스템의 운영체계와 기능에 관한 고찰", 한국부패학회보, 13(1), pp.117~136 (2008), 한국부패학회
  12. 양승규, "보험법 제5판" (2004)
  13. 양승규, "보험거래는 금융거래인가", 보험법연구, 4(2) (2010)
  14. 금융소비자보호체계 개선방안, "오영수", 보험연구원, ~ (2011)
  15. 유주선, "2010년 보험업법의 주요 개정내용과 평가", 생명보험 (2011)
  16. 이기수, "보험․해상법 제8판" (2008), 박영사
  17. 이기수, "경제법(제8판)" (2008), 세창출판사
  18. 전자상거래 소비자보호제도의 실효성확보에 관한 연구, "이종인", ~ (2006)
  19. 인터넷 등 온라인을 통한 거래 분야의 약관 사용실태 및 소비자 피해사례 연구, "이종인", ~ (2005)
  20. 이중기, "감독기관 단일화부터 이뤄야", 중앙일보, ~ (2003)
  21. 이충훈, "전자거래에서 약관의 편입과 면책약관에 관한 검토", 법조, (550) (2000), 법조협회
  22. 이필규, "2009년 독일 보험계약법" (2009), 세창출판사
  23. 상법 제4편(보험법) 개정의견, "장경환", ~ (2005)
  24. 장경환, "보험기초이론, 언더라이터 자격시험 교재" (2000), 생명보험협회
  25. 장덕조, "보험소비자보호정책의 평가 및 개선방향", 금융법연구, 7(1), pp.3~32 (2010), 한국금융법학회
  26. 장덕조, "英國保險法의 改正動向과 示唆點", 상사법연구, 28(4), pp.53~101 (2010), 한국상사법학회
  27. 박윤철, "보험계약법" (2006), 학현사
  28. 鄭順燮, "金融市場의 變化와 金融規制制度의 整備(上)", 증권법연구, 3(1), pp.1~30 (2002), 한국증권법학회
  29. 정찬형, "상법강의(하)(제5판)" (2003), 박영사
  30. 최기원, "보험법" (1996), 박영사
  31. 최병규, "약관규제법의 문제점과 개선방안", 경영법률, 13(2) (2003), 한국경영법률학회
  32. 최수령, "변액보험과 보험계약자 보호에 관한 연구", 박사, pp.2011
  33. 최준선, "보험법․해상법" (2005), 삼영사
  34. 최흥섭, "약관규제법에 의한 면책약관의 규제 - 전자상거래를 중심으로 -", 경영법률, 15(2), pp.499~526 (2005), 한국경영법률학회
  35. 한창희, "고지의무의 입법적 연혁과 최근동향", 상사법연구, 28(4), pp.135~185 (2010), 한국상사법학회
  36. Weyers, "Versicherungsvertragsrecht, 3. Aufl" (2003)
  37. Koch, "Versicherungswirtschaft, 5. Aufl" (1998)
  38. Palandt, "BGB, 69. Aufl" (2010)
  39. Präve, "Das neue Versicherungsvertragsgesetz", VersR 2007, pp.1048~ (2007)
  40. Taupitz, "Genetische Diagnostik und Versicherungsrecht", ~ (2000)

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (20건)