독립적 은행보증의 독립성과 지급금지가처분 － 서울고법 2008.2.28.선고 2007 라 604판결을 중심으로 －
The Independence Rule of Independent Bank Guarantees and Injunction
0
조회
0
다운로드
6
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Independent bank guarantees has a vital role in the international business transactions as a guarantee device. Although the origin of the independent guarantees is not a old one comparing to commercial letter of credit, it is a most common guarantee device in current international trade community. During last three decades, especially around the Iranian Revolution, international community has experienced the harsh and difficult problems regarding independent guarantees. The problems happened in independent guarantee transaction are mostly concerned with the basic characteristics of independent guarantees, i. e., independence rule and abstract rule. Recently, Korean high court decided that beneficiary's claim for premium is amount to the abuse of right. However, the decision has many problems resulting from the distortion of the basic rule and role of independent bank guarantees. The decision ignore the basic characteristics of independent bank guarantees. It should be bear in mind in handling the international instrument like independent bank guarantees to try to promote the international business. It could be achieved to preserve the unique characteristics inherent in international instrument.
Abstract
Independent bank guarantees has a vital role in the international business transactions as a guarantee device. Although the origin of the independent guarantees is not a old one comparing to commercial letter of credit, it is a most common guarantee device in current international trade community. During last three decades, especially around the Iranian Revolution, international community has experienced the harsh and difficult problems regarding independent guarantees. The problems happened in independent guarantee transaction are mostly concerned with the basic characteristics of independent guarantees, i. e., independence rule and abstract rule. Recently, Korean high court decided that beneficiary's claim for premium is amount to the abuse of right. However, the decision has many problems resulting from the distortion of the basic rule and role of independent bank guarantees. The decision ignore the basic characteristics of independent bank guarantees. It should be bear in mind in handling the international instrument like independent bank guarantees to try to promote the international business. It could be achieved to preserve the unique characteristics inherent in international instrument.
참고문헌 (16)
- Arnold, "The Standby Letter of Credit-The Controversy Continues", U. C. C. L. J, 10 (1978)
- Bertrams, "Bank Guarantees in International Trade" (1998), Kluwer International
- Byrne, "The Official Commentary on the International Standby Practices, Introduction (xvi)", ~ (1998)
- Clive M.Schmitthoff, "Export Trade, 9th ed" (1990)
- Dolan, "Letter of Credit Disputes between the Issuer and Its Customer: The Issuer's Rights under the Misnamed "Bifurcated Standard"", Banking L. J, 105 (1988)
- Gable, "Standby Letters of Credit: Nomenclature has confounded analysis", Law & Policy in International Business, 12 (1980)
- Harfield, "Bank Credits and Acceptances, 5th ed" (1974), Ronald Press Company
- Horn, "Bank Guarantees, Standby Letters of Credit and Performance Bonds in International Trade" (1990), Kluwer Law and Taxation Publishers
- Mark P. Zimmett, "Standby Letter of Credit in the Iranian Litigation: Two Hundred Problems in Search of Solution", Law and Policy in International Bus, 16 (1984)
- Michael Rowe, "Guarantees" (1987), Euromoney Pub
- Kozolchyk, "Bank Guarantees and Letters of Credit", U. Pa. J. Int'l Bus. L, 11 (1989)
- Ross P.Buckley, "The 1993 Revision of the Uniform Customs and Practice for Documentary Credits", Geo. Wash. J. Int'l L. & Econ, 28 (1995)
- Roy Goode, "Abstract Payment Undertaking and the Rules of the International Chamber of Commerce", St. Louis L. J, 39 (1995)
- Symons, "Letters of Credit, Good Faith and the Basis for Injunction Relief", Tulane L. Rev, 54 (1980)
- Wheble, "Problem Child"-Standby Letters of Credit and Simple First Demand Guarantees", Ariz. L. Rev, 24 (1982)
- Williams, "On demand and Conditional Performance Bond", J. of Bus. L (1981)