본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

Effectiveness and safety of rotary and reciprocating kinematics for retreatment of curved root canals: a systematic review of in vitro studies

1

조회

0

다운로드

1

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

주제분류치의학

초록

Objectives: This systematic review (register-osf.io/wg7ba) compared the efficacy and safety of rotary and reciprocating kinematics in the removal of filling material from curved root canals. Materials and methods: Only in vitro studies evaluating both kinematics during retreatment were included. A systematic search (PubMed/MEDLINE, Scopus, and other databases, until January 2021), data extraction, and risk of bias analysis (Joanna Briggs Institute checklist) were performed. Efficacy in filling removal was the primary outcome. Results: The search resulted in 2,795 studies, of which 15 were included. Efficacy was measured in terms of the remaining filling material and the time required for this. Nine studies evaluated filling material removal, of which 7 found no significant differences between rotary and reciprocating kinematics. Regarding the time for filling removal, 5 studies showed no difference between both kinematics, 2 studies showed faster results with rotary systems, and other 2 showed the opposite. No significant differences were found in apical transportation, centering ability, instrument failure, dentin removed and extruded debris. A low risk of bias was observed. Conclusions: This review suggests that the choice of rotary or reciprocating kinematics does not influence the efficacy of filling removal from curved root canals. Further studies are needed to compare the kinematics safety in curved root canals.

Abstract

Objectives: This systematic review (register-osf.io/wg7ba) compared the efficacy and safety of rotary and reciprocating kinematics in the removal of filling material from curved root canals. Materials and methods: Only in vitro studies evaluating both kinematics during retreatment were included. A systematic search (PubMed/MEDLINE, Scopus, and other databases, until January 2021), data extraction, and risk of bias analysis (Joanna Briggs Institute checklist) were performed. Efficacy in filling removal was the primary outcome. Results: The search resulted in 2,795 studies, of which 15 were included. Efficacy was measured in terms of the remaining filling material and the time required for this. Nine studies evaluated filling material removal, of which 7 found no significant differences between rotary and reciprocating kinematics. Regarding the time for filling removal, 5 studies showed no difference between both kinematics, 2 studies showed faster results with rotary systems, and other 2 showed the opposite. No significant differences were found in apical transportation, centering ability, instrument failure, dentin removed and extruded debris. A low risk of bias was observed. Conclusions: This review suggests that the choice of rotary or reciprocating kinematics does not influence the efficacy of filling removal from curved root canals. Further studies are needed to compare the kinematics safety in curved root canals.

참고문헌 (49)

  1. Torabinejad M, "Outcomes of nonsurgical retreatment and endodontic surgery: a systematic review", J Endod, 35, pp.930~937 (2009)
  2. Ng YL, "Outcome of primary root canal treatment: systematic review of the literature -- Part 2. Influence of clinical factors", Int Endod J, 41, pp.6~31 (2008)
  3. Del Fabbro M, "Endodontic procedures for retreatment of periapical lesions", Cochrane Database Syst Rev, 10, pp.CD005511~ (2016)
  4. Estrela C, "Common operative procedural errors and clinical factors associated with root canal treatment", Braz Dent J, 28, pp.179~190 (2017)
  5. Gaêta-Araujo H, "Association between the root canal configuration, endodontic treatment technical errors, and periapical hypodensities in molar teeth: a cone-beam computed tomographic study", J Endod, 45, pp.1465~1471 (2019)
  6. de Pablo OV, "Root anatomy and canal configuration of the permanent mandibular first molar: a systematic review", J Endod, 36, pp.1919~1931 (2010)
  7. Kang M, "Outcome of nonsurgical retreatment and endodontic microsurgery: a meta-analysis", Clin Oral Investig, 19, pp.569~582 (2015)
  8. Riis A, "Tooth Survival after surgical or nonsurgical endodontic retreatment: long-term follow-up of a randomized clinical trial", J Endod, 44, pp.1480~1486 (2018)
  9. Chércoles-Ruiz A, "Endodontics, endodontic retreatment, and apical surgery versus tooth extraction and implant placement: a systematic review", J Endod, 43, pp.679~686 (2017)
  10. Da Rosa RA, "Micro-CT evaluation of root filling removal after three stages of retreatment procedure", Braz Dent J, 26, pp.612~618 (2015)
  11. Silva EJ, "Effectiveness of rotatory and reciprocating movements in root canal filling material removal", Braz Oral Res, 29, pp.1~6 (2015)
  12. Alves FR, "Removal of root canal fillings in curved canals using either reciprocating single- or rotary multi-instrument systems and a supplementary step with the XP-Endo finisher", J Endod, 42, pp.1114~1119 (2016)
  13. Ozyurek T, "Efficacy of ProTaper Next and ProTaper Universal retreatment systems in removing gutta-percha in curved root canals during root canal retreatment", J Istanb Univ Fac Dent, 51, pp.7~13 (2017)
  14. Zelada G, "The effect of rotational speed and the curvature of root canals on the breakage of rotary endodontic instruments", J Endod, 28, pp.540~542 (2002)
  15. Alfouzan K, "Fracture of nickel titanium rotary instrument during root canal treatment and retreatment:a 5-year retrospective study", Int Endod J, 51, pp.157~163 (2018)
  16. Nevares G, "Efficacy of ProTaper NEXT compared with Reciproc in removing obturation material from severely curved root canals: a micro-computed tomography study", J Endod, 42, pp.803~808 (2016)
  17. Delai D, "Apically extruded debris in filling removal of curved canals using 3 NiTi systems and hand files", Braz Dent J, 29, pp.54~59 (2018)
  18. Delai D, "Efficacy of a thermally treated single file compared with rotary systems in endodontic retreatment of curved canals: a micro-CT study", Clin Oral Investig, 23, pp.1837~1844 (2019)
  19. Madarati AA, "The efficacy of retreatment and new reciprocating systems in removing a gutta-percha-based filling material", J Taibah Univ Med Sci, 13, pp.452~458 (2018)
  20. Rehman K, "Comparison of orange oil and chloroform as gutta- percha solvents in endodontic retreatment", J Contemp Dent Pract, 14, pp.478~482 (2013)
  21. Agrawal P, "Evaluation of efficacy of different instrumentation for removal of gutta-percha and sealers in endodontic retreatment: an in vitro study", J Contemp Dent Pract, 20, pp.1269~1273 (2019)
  22. Fruchi LC, "Efficacy of reciprocating instruments for removing filling material in curved canals obturated with a single-cone technique: a micro-computed tomographic analysis", J Endod, 40, pp.1000~1004 (2014)
  23. Borges MM, "Efficacy of reciprocating systems for removing root filling material plus complementary cleaning methods in flattened canals: Microtomography and scanning electron microscopy study", Microsc Res Tech, 82, pp.1057~1064 (2019)
  24. Bago I, "Evaluation of filling material remnants after basic preparation, apical enlargement and final irrigation in retreatment of severely curved root canals in extracted teeth", Int Endod J, 53, pp.962~973 (2020)
  25. Ahn SY, "Kinematic effects of nickel-titanium instruments with reciprocating or continuous rotation motion: a systematic review of in vitro studies", J Endod, 42, pp.1009~1017 (2016)
  26. Zuolo AS, "Efficacy of reciprocating and rotary techniques for removing filling material during root canal retreatment", Int Endod J, 46, pp.947~953 (2013)
  27. Rödig T, "Efficacy of the ProTaper retreatment system in removing Thermafil, GuttaCore or vertically compacted gutta-percha from curved root canals assessed by micro-CT", Int Endod J, 51, pp.808~815 (2018)
  28. Kaloustian MK, "Evaluation of two shaping systems and two ultrasonic irrigation devices in removing root canal filling material from mesial roots of mandibular molars: a micro CT study", Dent J (Basel), 7, pp.2~ (2019)
  29. Marfisi K, "Efficacy of Reciproc® and Profile® instruments in the removal of gutta-percha from straight and curved root canals ex vivo", J Oral Maxillofac Res, 6, pp.e1~ (2015)
  30. Moher D, "Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement", Int J Surg, 8, pp.336~341 (2010)
  31. Dos Reis-Prado AH, "Comparison between immediate and delayed post space preparations: a systematic review and meta-analysis", Clin Oral Investig, 25, pp.417~440 (2021)
  32. Aminoshariae A, "Master apical file size - smaller or larger: a systematic review of microbial reduction", Int Endod J, 48, pp.1007~1022 (2015)
  33. Yaylali IE, "Ultrasonically activated irrigation to remove calcium hydroxide from apical third of human root canal system: a systematic review of in vitro studies", J Endod, 41, pp.1589~1599 (2015)
  34. Capar ID, "Effectiveness of ProTaper Universal retreatment instruments used with rotary or reciprocating adaptive motion in the removal of root canal filling material", Int Endod J, 48, pp.79~83 (2015)
  35. Rodrigues CT, "Comparison of two methods of irrigant agitation in the removal of residual filling material in retreatment", Braz Oral Res, 31, pp.e113~ (2017)
  36. Rodrigues CT, "Efficacy of CM-wire, M-wire, and nickel-titanium instruments for removing filling material from curved root canals: a micro-computed tomography study", J Endod, 42, pp.1651~1655 (2016)
  37. Rödig T, "Efficacy of reciprocating and rotary NiTi instruments for retreatment of curved root canals assessed by micro-CT", Int Endod J, 47, pp.942~948 (2014)
  38. Çanakçi BC, "Evaluation of apically extruded debris from curved root canal filling removal using 5 nickel-titanium systems", J Endod, 42, pp.1101~1104 (2016)
  39. Kaşıkçı Bilgi I, "Efficiency and apical extrusion of debris: a comparative ex vivo study of four retreatment techniques in severely curved root canals", Int Endod J, 50, pp.910~918 (2017)
  40. Jorgensen B, "The efficacy of the WaveOne reciprocating file system versus the ProTaper retreatment system in endodontic retreatment of two different obturating techniques", J Endod, 43, pp.1011~1013 (2017)
  41. Nevares G, "Evaluation of apically extruded debris during root canal retreatment using ProTaper Next and Reciproc in severely curved canals", Iran Endod J, 12, pp.323~328 (2017)
  42. Arruda ED, "Apical transportation and centering ability after root canal filling removal using reciprocating and continuous rotary systems: a CBCT study", Eur J Dent, 13, pp.613~618 (2019)
  43. Üreyen Kaya B, "Atomic force microscopy and energy dispersive X-ray spectrophotometry analysis of reciprocating and continuous rotary nickel-titanium instruments following root canal retreatment", Microsc Res Tech, 82, pp.1157~1164 (2019)
  44. Zevallos-Quiroz CA, "Efficacy of controlled memory and shape memory nickel titanium instruments in removing filling material from severely curved root canals: an ex vivo study", Iran Endod J, 14, pp.115~121 (2019)
  45. Landis JR, "The measurement of observer agreement for categorical data", Biometrics, 33, pp.159~174 (1977)
  46. Monguilhott Crozeta B, "A micro-computed tomography assessment of the efficacy of rotary and reciprocating techniques for filling material removal in root canal retreatment", Clin Oral Investig, 20, pp.2235~2240 (2016)
  47. Crozeta BM, "Micro-computed tomography study of filling material removal from oval-shaped canals by using rotary, reciprocating, and adaptive motion systems", J Endod, 42, pp.793~797 (2016)
  48. Patnana AK, "The incidence of nickel-titanium endodontic hand file fractures: a 7-year retrospective study in a tertiary care hospital", J Conserv Dent, 23, pp.21~25 (2020)
  49. Caviedes-Bucheli J, "The influence of two reciprocating single-file and two rotary-file systems on the apical extrusion of debris and its biological relationship with symptomatic apical periodontitis. A systematic review and meta-analysis", Int Endod J, 49, pp.255~270 (2016)

관련 논문AI추천

Influence of reciprocating and rotary instrumentation on microbial reduction: a systematic review and meta-analysis of in vitro studiesKarahan Sevilay, Küçükkaya Eren Selen, Uzunoğlu-Özyürek Emel대한치과보존학회 · Restorative Dentistry and Endodontics2021 · 제46권 제2호Impact of root canal curvature and instrument type on the amount of extruded debris during retreatmentÇalışkan Mehmet Kemal, Kandemir Demirci Gözde, Kaşıkçı Bilgi İlknur, Miçooğulları Kurt Seniha, Serefoglu Burcu대한치과보존학회 · Restorative Dentistry and Endodontics2021 · 제46권 제1호Efficacy of reciprocating and rotary retreatment nickel-titanium file systems for removing filling materials with a complementary cleaning method in oval canals김현철, Imane Benkiran, Lamyae Bedida, Said Dhaimy대한치과보존학회 · Restorative Dentistry and Endodontics2021 · 제46권 제1호Effectiveness of endodontic retreatment using WaveOne Primary files in reciprocating and rotary motionsCavenago Bruno Cavalini, Costa Patricia Marton, Duarte Marco Antônio Húngaro, Leal Renata Maíra de Souza, Yamanari Guilherme Hiroshi대한치과보존학회 · Restorative Dentistry and Endodontics2023 · 제48권 제2호Efficacy of reciprocating instruments and final irrigant activation protocols on retreatment of mesiobuccal roots of maxillary molars: a micro-CT analysisAlcalde Murilo Priori, da Rosa Ricardo Abreu, Duarte Marco Antonio Hungaro, Furlan Renan Diego, Só Marcus Vinicius Reis, Tietz Lilian, Vivan Rodrigo Ricci, Weissheimer Theodoro대한치과보존학회 · Restorative Dentistry and Endodontics2022 · 제47권 제1호Shaping ability and apical debris extrusion after root canal preparation with rotary or reciprocating instruments: a micro-CT studyBarbosa Ana Flávia Almeida, da Silva Emmanuel João Nogueira Leal, de Lima Carolina Oliveira, de Moura Sara Gomes, Lacerda Mariane Floriano Lopes Santos, Misael Waleska Florentino, Sassone Luciana Moura대한치과보존학회 · Restorative Dentistry and Endodontics2021 · 제46권 제2호

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (9건)