실천적 유물론에 대한 변증법적 단상: 물질과 정신의 이원론을 넘어
A Dialectical Reflection on the Practical Materialism: Beyond the Dualism of Idealism and Materialism
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
New Materialism has been quite successful in bringing back the ontology of matter and materiality in order to overcome the binary oppositions between spirit and matter. However, it is very ironic that New Materialism has recourse to the mystic monism of materiality to go beyond the traditional dualism. Against the monism, this essay suggests practical materialism as a critical way of genuinely overcoming the dualism of idealism and materialism. First, the Hegelian dialectic will be discussed in terms of the essence-and-appearance opposition. Then, Karl Marx’s criticism of Ludwig Feuerbach’s “contemplative materialism” is to be dealt. According to Marx, the practical materialism, which relies on the Hegelian dialectics of “rising from the abstract to the concrete,” should overcome the dogmatic dualism of idealism and materialism by way of practical activity including dialectically both the concrete social reality and the abstract conceptual practice. In this sense, the practical materialism should be regarded as a more viable option for surpassing the limit of dualism rather than New Materialism.
Abstract
New Materialism has been quite successful in bringing back the ontology of matter and materiality in order to overcome the binary oppositions between spirit and matter. However, it is very ironic that New Materialism has recourse to the mystic monism of materiality to go beyond the traditional dualism. Against the monism, this essay suggests practical materialism as a critical way of genuinely overcoming the dualism of idealism and materialism. First, the Hegelian dialectic will be discussed in terms of the essence-and-appearance opposition. Then, Karl Marx’s criticism of Ludwig Feuerbach’s “contemplative materialism” is to be dealt. According to Marx, the practical materialism, which relies on the Hegelian dialectics of “rising from the abstract to the concrete,” should overcome the dogmatic dualism of idealism and materialism by way of practical activity including dialectically both the concrete social reality and the abstract conceptual practice. In this sense, the practical materialism should be regarded as a more viable option for surpassing the limit of dualism rather than New Materialism.
참고문헌 (30)
- 김상민, "물질의 귀환: 인류세 담론의 철학적 기초로서의 신유물론", 문화과학, 97(3), pp.55~80 (2019)
- 김현, "신체화 된 이성과 사유하는 몸 - 헤겔(G. W. F. Hegel) 사변철학에 대한 포이어바흐(L. Feuerbach)의 비판과 그의 ‘감성적 유물론’을 중심으로-", 헤겔연구, (44), pp.171~213 (2018), 한국헤겔학회[DOI]
- 김환석, "사회과학의 새로운 패러다임, 신유물론", 지식의 지평, 25, pp.81~89 (2018)
- 이안희, "포이에르바하와 마르크스의 유물론에 관한 비교 고찰", 사회과학연구, 6, pp.201~222 (1994)
- Althusser, Louis, "For Marx" (1969), Pantheon Books
- Bennet, Jane, "New Materialisms: Ontology, Agency, and Politics", pp.47~69 (2010), Duke UP
- Burbidge, John W., "The Cambridge Companion to Hegel", pp.86~101 (1993), Cambridge UP
- Callinicous, Alex, "Marxism and Philosophy" (1985), Oxford UP
- Cheah, Pheng, "New Materialisms:Ontology, Agency, and Politics", pp.70~91 (2010), Duke UP
- Coole, Diana, "New Materialisms: Ontology, Agency, and Politics" (2010), Duke UP
- Engels, Friedrich, "Karl Marx and Frederick Engels: Selected Works. Vol. 3", pp.335~376 (1970), Progress Publisher
- Forster, Michael, "The Cambridge Companion to Hegel", pp.130~170 (1993), Cambridge UP
- Hamilton, Clive, "Defiant Earth: The Fate of Humans in the Anthropocene" (2017), Polity Press
- Hegel, G. W., "Phenomenology of Spirit" (1977), Clarendon P
- Hegel, G. W., "Elements of the Philosophy of Right" (1991), Cambridge UP
- Hegel, G. W., "Hegel’s Logic" (1975), Oxford UP
- Hegel, G. W., "Hegel’s Philosophy of Mind" (1971), Oxford UP
- Hyppolite, Jean, "Studies on Marx and Hegel" (1969), Basic Books
- Lukács, Georg, "History and Class Consciousness: Studies in Marxist Dialectics" (1968), MIT P
- MacGregor, David, "Hegel and Marx after the Fall of Communism" (1998), U of Wales P
- MacGregor, David, "The Communist Ideal in Hegel and Marx" (1984), George Allen
- Marx, Karl, "Capital: A Critique of Political Economy. Vol. 1" (1967), International Publishers
- Marx, Karl, "Grundrisse: Foundations of the Critique of Political Economy" (1973), Random House
- Marx, Karl, "The Marx-Engels Reader" (1978), Norton
- Marx, Karl, "Selected Correspondence" (1975), Progress Publishers
- Mattick Jr., Paul, "Marx’s Method in Capital: A Reexamination", pp.115~134 (1993), Humanities P
- Murray, Patrick, "Marx’s Method in Capital: A Reexamination", pp.37~65 (1993), Humanities P
- Ollman, Bertell, "Dialectical Investigations" (1993), Routledge
- Smith, Tony, "Marx’s Method in Capital: A Reexamination", pp.15~36 (1993), Humanities P
- Wert, Kathryn Van, "New Materialisms : Ontology, Agency, and Politics by Diana Coole and Samantha Frost", Modern Language Studies, 43(2), pp.66~71 (2014)