Attracting Neighbors: Soft Power Competition in East Asia
0
조회
0
다운로드
3
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
This article explores the dynamics of competition by means of soft power among two key regional states, China and Japan. It demonstrates that, in their embrace of regionalism, each has concentrated soft power on East Asian neighbors by competitively proposing regional visions that would best position it in the regional leadership stakes. China took the initiative, Japan responded quickly, and China is now striking back. This does not necessarily mean that the liberal claim that East Asia is “ripe for cooperation” is misplaced. Nor does it suggest that the realist claim of “ripe for rivalry” better represents the reality. Rather, this article argues that regional powers compete in order to attract neighbors. Since this contest involves embracing others, it is not necessarily a zero-sum game. This article evaluates the success, or lack thereof, of the two countries’ efforts in order to learn what they imply for Korea.
Abstract
This article explores the dynamics of competition by means of soft power among two key regional states, China and Japan. It demonstrates that, in their embrace of regionalism, each has concentrated soft power on East Asian neighbors by competitively proposing regional visions that would best position it in the regional leadership stakes. China took the initiative, Japan responded quickly, and China is now striking back. This does not necessarily mean that the liberal claim that East Asia is “ripe for cooperation” is misplaced. Nor does it suggest that the realist claim of “ripe for rivalry” better represents the reality. Rather, this article argues that regional powers compete in order to attract neighbors. Since this contest involves embracing others, it is not necessarily a zero-sum game. This article evaluates the success, or lack thereof, of the two countries’ efforts in order to learn what they imply for Korea.
참고문헌 (76)
- Acharya, A., "November 8. China’s charm offensive in Southeast Asia", International Herald Tribune, ~ (2003)
- "May 3. Asian strategy as I see it: Japan as the “thought leader” of Asia. Speech by Minister for Foreign Affairs Taro Aso at the Foreign Correspondents’ Club of Japan" (2006)[URL]
- "May 26. A networked Asia: Conceptualizing a future. Speech by Minister for Foreign Affairs Taro Aso on the occasion of the 12th Nikkei International Conference on the Future of Asia" (2006)[URL]
- "November 30. Arc of freedom and prosperity: Japan’s expanding diplomatic horizons. Speech by Minister for Foreign Affairs Taro Aso on the occasion of the Japan Institute of International Affairs Seminar" (2006)[URL]
- Bowles, P., "Asia’s post-crisis regionalism", Review of International Political Economy, 9(2) (2002)
- Calder, K., "Asia’s deadly triangle: How arms, energy and growth threaten to destabilize Asia-Pacific" (1997), Nicholas Brealey
- Chan, B., "2006, January 3. East Asia summit: The result analysis", Mirae Nondan, ~ (2006)
- Cheng, J. Y., "The ASEAN-China free trade area: Genesis and implications", Australian Journal of International Affairs, 2, pp.257~277 (2004)
- Cho, Y., "China’s soft power: Discussions, resources, prospects", Asian Survey
- Cumings, B., "The origin and development of the Northeast Asian political economy", International Organization, 38(1), pp.1~40 (1984)
- Dent, C., "Networking the region: The emergence and impact of Asia-Pacific bilateral trade agreement projects", The Pacific Review, 16(1) (2003)
- Dent, C., "East Asian regionalism" (2008), Routledge
- Dittmer, L., "The emerging Northeast Asian regional order, in The international relations of Northeast Asia" (2004), Rowman and Littlefield
- Dobson, W., "Deeper integration in East Asia", World Economy, 24(8) (2001)
- Dudden, A., "2006, April 22. US congressional resolution calls on Japan to accept wartime crime to comfort women", Japan Focus, ~ (2006)
- Friedberg, A., "Ripe for rivalry: Prospects for peace in a multipolar Asia", International Security, 18(3) (1993)
- Garrison, J. A., "China’s prudent cultivation of “soft” power and implications for U.S. policy in East Asia", Asian Affairs: An American Review, 32(1), pp.25~30 (2005)
- Green, M., "Japan’s reluctant realism" (2001), Palgrave
- Hatch, W., "Asia in Japan’s embrace" (1996), Cambridge University Press
- Higgott, R., "The Asian economic crisis: A study in the politics of resentment", New Political Economy, 3(3) (1998)
- Johnson, C., "MITI and the Japanese miracle: The growth of industrial policy, 1925-1975" (1975), Stanford University Press
- Kang, D., "Getting Asia wrong", International Organization, 27 (2003)
- Katzenstein, P. J., "Asian regionalism" (1999), Cornell University Press
- Kang, D., "A world of regions" (2006), Cornell University Press
- Katzenstein, P. J., "Network power: Japan and Asia" (1997), Cornell University Press
- Katzenstein, P. J., "Beyond Japan: The dynamics of East Asian regionalism" (2006), Cornell University Press
- Kawakatsu, H., "Bunkaryoku: Nihon no sokojikara, In Cultural power: Japan’s latent power" (2006), Wedge
- Kazuko, M., "Higashi ajia kyodotai no kochiku (4): tosetsu netowaku kaiseki" (2006), Iwanami
- "NHK", 2005
- Kenichi, I., "Higashi-ajia to nihon no shinro. NHK shuppan: 2", ~ (2005)
- Kensaburo, O., "Aimai na nihon to watashi" (1995), Kodansha
- Keohane, R., "Power and Interdependence in the Age of Information", Foreign Affairs, 77(5) (1998)
- Kurlantzick, J., "Charm offensive: How China’s soft power is transforming the world" (2007), Yale University Press
- Lampton, D. M., "China’s rise in Asia need not be at America’s expense, in Power shift: China and Asia’s new dynamics", pp.317~319 (2005), University of California Press
- Leheny, D., "A narrow place to cross swords: Soft power and the politics of Japanese popular culture in East Asia, in Network power: Japan and Asia" (2006), Cornell University Press
- Lincoln, E., "East Asian economic regionalism" (2003), The Brookings Institution
- Ito, K., "Higashi-ajia kyodotai to nihon no shinro" (2005), Nihon keizai shimbunsha
- Masahiro, K., "Higashi-ajia kyodotai", Nihon keizai shimbunsha 2005 (2005)
- McGray, D., "Japan’s Gross National Cool", Foreign Policy, 130, pp.44~54 (2002)
- Munakata, N., "Has politics caught up with markets?: In search of East Asian economic regionalism, in Beyond Japan" (2005), Cornell University Press
- Najita, T., "Japan’s revolt against the West. Cambridge History of Japan" (1988), Cambridge University Press
- Nye, J., "Soft power", Foreign Policy, 80 (1990)
- Nye, J., "Bound to lead: The changing nature of American power" (1991), Basic Books
- Nye, J., "Soft power and American foreign policy", Political Science Quarterly, 119(2) (2004)
- Nye, J., "Soft power: The means to success in world politics" (2004), Public Affairs
- Nye, J., "The decline of American soft power", Foreign Affairs (2004)
- Nye, J., "Power and interdependence in the age of information", Foreign Affairs (1998)
- Ogura, K., "Sharing Japan’s cultural products as “international assents”", Chuo Koron (2004)
- Otmazgin, N. K., "Contesting soft power: Japanese popular culture in East and South East Asia", International Relations of the Asia-Pacific (2007)
- Pape, R., "Soft balancing against the United States", International Security, 30(1), pp.7~45 (2005)
- Paul, T. V., "Introduction: The enduring axioms of the balance of power theory and their contemporary relevance, in Balance of power: theory and practice in the twenty-first century", pp.1~24 (2004), Stanford University Press
- Pempel, T. J., "Remapping East Asia: The construction of a region" (2005), Cornell University Press
- Pyle, K., "Japan rising: The resurgence of Japanese power and purpose", Public Affairs (2007)
- Ramo, J. C., "Beijing consensus" (2004), The Foreign Policy Centre
- Rozman, G., "South Korea and Sino-Japanese rivalry: A middle power’s options within the East Asian core triangle", The Pacific Review, 20(2), pp.209~ (2007)
- Schweller, R., "Managing the rise of great powers, in Engaging China: The management of an emerging power" (1999), Routledge
- Shambaugh, D., "China engages Asia: Reshaping the regional order", International Security, 64 (2004)
- Shambaugh, D., "Return to the Middle Kingdom? China and Asia in the early twentyfirst century, in China’s rise in Asia: Promises and perils" (2005), Rowman & Littlefield
- Shiraishi, S., "Japan’s soft power: Doraemon goes overseas, in Network power: Japan and Asia" (1997), Cornell University Press
- Shiraishi, S., "The third wave. In Beyond Japan: The dynamics of East Asian regionalism", pp.237~272 (2006), Cornell University Press
- Sohn, Y., (2005), Dong-AIlbo
- Taniguchi, M., "Higashi-ajia kyodotai" (2005), Iwanami shoten
- Terada, T., "Japan-Australia partnership in the era of East Asian community: Can they advance together", Pacific Economic Papers, 352, pp.15~16 (2005)
- Terada, T., "Forming an East Asian community: A site for Japan-China power struggles", Japanese Studies, 26(1), pp.1~13 (2006)
- US, Japan establish military alliance, "2004, June 25. People’s Daily", ~ (2004)
- US-Japan Security Consultative Committee, "2002, December. Joint statement of the US-Japan Security Consultative Committee", ~ (2002)
- US-Japan Security Consultative Committee, "2005, February. Joint statement of the US-Japan Security Consultative Committee", ~ (2005)
- US-Japan Security Consultative Committee, "2006, March. Joint statement of the US-Japan Security Consultative Committee", ~ (2006)
- Wang, J., "China’s multilateral diplomacy in the new millennium, in China rising: Power and motivation in Chinese foreign policy", pp.159~200 (2005), Rowman & Littlefield
- Weber, D., "Two funerals and a wedding", The Pacific Review, 14(3) (2001)
- Wong J., "China-ASEAN free trade agreement: Shaping future economic relations", Asian Survey, 3, pp.507~526 (2003)
- Yamada, T., "Toward a principled integration of East Asia: Concept of an East Asian community", Gaiko Forum (2005)
- Yoshimatsu, H., "The political economy of regionalism in East Asia" (2008), Palgrave
- Yukio, M., "Heisei Baburu no kenkyu", Toyo keizai shinposha, 2 (2002)
- Yunling, Z., "China’s regional strategy, in Power shift: China and Asia’s new dynamics", pp.48~68 (2005), University of California Press
- Zheng, B., "China’s peaceful rise to the great Power status", Foreign Affairs (2005)
