Ellis의 비합리적 신념의 개념적 타당화 분석 및 대안적 측정도구 틀의 탐색
Conceptual Validation Analysis of Ellis's Irrational Beliefs and Exploration of an Alternative Measurement Tool Framework
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
본 연구는 Ellis의 비합리적 신념 요인들에 대한 개념적 타당화, 기존 측정도구들의 한계 분석, 그리고 이에 기초한 새로운 측정도구의 개발을 위한 틀을 제시하고자 하였다. 먼저 개념적 분석 결과, Ellis의 11개 비합리적 신념은 논리적 합당성, 경험적 검증, 융통성, 실용성 및 적응적 정서 등 합리성 준거를 위반하는 것으로 나타났다. 다시 말해 각 신념은, 스스로 성립될 수 없는 명제를 수용하고, 경험적으로 발생하지 않을 사실을 믿으며, 일방성과 경직성을 바탕으로 하며, 실생활에서 부정적 결과를 초래하고, 부적응적 정서와 행동을 유발하는 것으로 분석되었다. 또한, 국내 3개 Ellis 비합리적 신념 측정도구의 내용분석 결과, 각 문항에 대한 양 극단 반응의 변별이 불가함, 해당 요인의 개념적 초점화에 실패함. 일반적 대상과 상황 대신 개인적 특성에 대한 믿음을 반영함, 사고 대신 정서와 행동 상태를 측정함, 개념적 표현적 중복을 보임 등의 한계를 가지는 것으로 확인되었다. 끝으로, 이러한 문제점들을 극복하기 위한 측정도구의 틀을 제시하였다. 이 도구는 Ellis 11개 비합리적 사고내용의 각 핵심을 나타내는 제 3자의 상황을 이야기로 제시하고, 이에 대해 응답자가 주인공의 생각과 일치하는 정도를 표시하도록 설계되었다. 이러한 자기반영적인 측정 틀은 기존 자기보고식 측정도구들이 가지는 자기방어적 대응을 최소화함으로써, 비합리적 신념의 보다 정확한 측정 가능성을 가질 것으로 논의되었다.
Abstract
This study aimed to conduct a conceptual validation of Ellis's irrational beliefs, analyze the limitations of existing measurement tools, and propose a framework for a new measurement tool. First, an examination of the irrationality of 11 Ellis’ irrational beliefs revealed that each belief violates "logical validity" by accepting propositions that cannot stand alone, "empirical verification“ in that many incompatible facts actually occur, "flexibility" by keeping unidirectionality and rigidity, "practicality" by producing negative outcomes and "adaptive emotion" by triggering maladaptive emotions and behaviors. Additionally, a content analysis of three domestic irrational beliefs scales revealed several limitations: They fail to differentiate extreme responses for each item, do not conceptually focus on the relevant factor, reflect beliefs related to personal traits and situations rather than general objects, measure emotional and behavioral states instead of thoughts, and exhibit conceptual expressional overlapping. Finally, a framework for a new measurement tool was proposed to address these issues. This tool presents third-person scenarios including the core content of each Ellis's irrational belief and asks respondents to rate the similarity between their and the protagonist’s thoughts. This self-reflective measurement framework is expected to reduce defensive responses commonly associated with self-report scales of irrational beliefs.
참고문헌 (47)
- 박경애, "인지행동치료" (1997), 학지사
- 박경애, "인지정서행동치료" (2022), 학지사
- 朴在滉, "비행청소년과 정상청소년의 합리적신념의 차이 : Ellis의 합리적 정의이론을 중심으로", 석사, pp.1981
- 서수균, "한국판 일반적 태도 및 신념 척도 개발 및 타당화 연구", 한국심리학회지, 21(1), pp.113~130 (2009)
- 이형득, "상담의 이론적 접근" (1992), 형설출판사
- 이희영, "유아기 자녀를 둔 어머니의 비합리적 신념과 양육 스트레스와의 관계", 수산해양교육연구, 23(3), pp.400~409 (2011), 한국수산해양교육학회
- 최정훈, "사회적 불안에서의 비합리적 신념과 상황요인", 한국심리학회지, 6(1), pp.21~47 (1994)
- Arnkoff, D. B., "Cognitive assessment in social anxiety and social phobia", Clinical Psychology Review, 9, pp.61~74 (1989)
- Beck, A. T., "Cognitive therapy and emotional disorder" (1979), International Universities Press
- Bernard, M. E., "Validation of General Attitude and Belief Scale", Journal of Rational Emotive and Cognitive Behavior Therapy, 16, pp.183~196 (1998)
- Burgess, P. M., "Belief systems and emotional disturbance: Evaluation of the rational emotive model", doctor, pp.1986
- Burgess, P. M., "Toward resolution of conceptual issues in the assessment of belief systems in rational-emotive therapy", Journal of Cognitive Psychotherapy, 4(2), pp.171~184 (1990)
- Chauliac, M., "It is all in the surv-eye: Can eye tracking data shed light on the internal consistency in self-report questionnaires on cognitive processing strategies?", Frontline Learning Research, 8(3), pp.1~20 (2020)
- David, D., "A synopsis of rational emotive behavior therapy (REBT): Fundamental and applied research", Journal of Rational Emotive & Cognitive Behavior Therapy, 23, pp.175~221 (2005)
- David, D., "The handbook of rational and emotional psychotherapy" (2018), Springer International
- David, D., "The development of rational emotive behavior therapy : A historical perspective", Journal of Cognitive Psychotherapy, 26(4), pp.360~374 (2012)
- DiGiuseppe, R. D., "Depression in the family" (1986), Haworth Press
- DiGiuseppe, R., "The development of a measure of rational", irrational thinking, 1988, ~
- DiGiuseppe, R., "Rational emotive behavior therapy: It works for me—It can work for you" (2007), Springer Science & Business Media
- Ellis, A., "Reason and emotion in psychotherapy" (1962), Lyle Stuart and Citadel Books
- Ellis, A., "Biological basis of human irrationality : A reply to McBurnett and LaPointe", Individual Psychology, 35(1), pp.111~116 (1979)
- Ellis, A., "Comprehensive handbook of cognitive therapy", pp.5~19 (1989), Plenum
- Ellis, A., "The practice of rational emotive therapy" (2007), Springer
- Ellis, A., "Rational Emotive Behavior Therapy: A Therapist’s Guide" (2005), Impact
- Gawronski, B., "Foundations of social psychological measurement", pp.1~27 (2019), Taylor & Francis
- Gawronski, B., "Handbook of attitudes", pp.283~314 (2014), Psychology Press
- Haaga. D. A. F., "An appraisal of rational-emotive therapy", Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psycholog, 61, pp.215~220 (1993)
- Jones, R. G., "The factored measures of Ellis' irrational belief system, with personality and maladjustment correlates" (1969), Univ. Microfilms, Inc
- Jordana, A., "Ready for failure? Irrational beliefs, perfectionism and mental health in male soccer academy players", Journal of Rational-Emotive & Cognitive-Behavior Therapy, 40(1), pp.51~70 (2022)
- Kassinove, H., "Developmental trends in rational thinking: Implications for rational-emotive, school mental health programs", Journal of Community Psychology, 5(3), pp.266~274 (1977)
- Kuhn, T., "The structure of scientific revolutions" (1962), Chicago University Press
- Linder, H., "A brief assessment of irrational thinking : The Shortened General Attitude and Belief Scale", Cognitive Therapy and Research, 23, pp.651~663 (1999)
- Lynch, A., "Reevaluating irrational beliefs : How much stability is there in the belief systems across populations", Behavior Modification, 35(5), pp.459~474 (2011)
- López, F., "Exploring the stability of irrational beliefs in clinical and non-clinical samples : A meta-analysis", Journal of Rational-Emotive & Therapy, 34(1), pp.1~17 (2016)
- MacLaren, C., "Rational emotive behavior therapy: A practitioner's guide" (2013), Routledge
- Malouff, J. M., "Development and validation of a measure of irrational belief", Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 54(6), pp.860~863 (1986)
- Prola, M., "The social desirability of irrational beliefs", Perceptual and Motor Skills, 61(1), pp.336~338 (1985)
- Sava, F., "Implicit and explicit self-esteem and irrational beliefs", Cognition, Brain, Behavior, 15(1), pp.29~48 (2011)
- Smith, T. W., "Irrational beliefs in the cause and treatment of emotional distress : A critical review of the rational emotive model", Clinical Psychology Review, 2, pp.505~522 (1982)
- Smith, T. W., "Assessment of irrational beliefs : The question of discriminant validity", Journal of Clinical Psychology, 39(6), pp.976~981 (1983)
- Shorkey, C. T., "Development of the Rational Behavior Inventory : Initial validity and reliability", Educational and Psychological Measurement, 37, pp.527~534 (1977)
- Snir, S., "Expanding art therapy process research through self-report questionnaires", Art Therapy, 31(3), pp.113~119 (2014)
- Stewart, I., "Do you really know what you believe? Developing the Implicit Relational Assessment Procedure (IRAP) as a direct measure of implicit beliefs", International Journal of Psychology and Psychological Therapy, 9(3), pp.439~459 (2009)
- Terjesen, M. D., "A psychometric review of measures of irrational beliefs : Implications for psychotherapy", Journal of Rational-Emotive and Cognitive-Behavior Therapy, 27, pp.83~96 (2009)
- Turner, M. J., "The development and initial validation of the irrational performance beliefs inventory (iPBI)", European Journal of Psychological Assessment, 34, pp.174~180 (2018)
- Woods, P. J., "A study of 'belief' and 'non-belief' items from the Jones Irrational Beliefs Test with implications for the theory of RET", Journal of Rational-Emotive and Cognitive-Behavior Therapy, 10, pp.41~52 (1992)
- Zurawski, R. M., "Assessing irrational beliefs and emotional distress : Evidence and implications of limited discriminant validity", Journal of Counseling Psychology, 34(2), pp.224~227 (1987)