集安 地域 高句麗 王陵에 관한 新考察
A New Thought on Goguryeo King's Tombs in Jian Area
0
조회
0
다운로드
11
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Goguryeo Kings are called from their tombs areas in many cases. In relation to this fact, I have researched the rivers’names in Jian area. Gookcheon (國川: national river) and Jungcheon (中川: central river) are regarded as a same river called Tongguha. Yalloo river which was critically accepted as Gookcheon has been found that its name of ‘Yalloo (鴨)’has been maintained as it is. ‘Gook (國)’relevant tomb area name is roughly categorized into Gookwon (國原: national field) but Gookyang (國壤: national land) corresponds to Gookcheon. They have been, therefore, critically renamed the area that covers both left and right area focused on Gooknae fortress. It was called Gookgang (國岡: national hill) that had hill on the east side of Gookwon. The kings’tombs located on such Gookgang are Imgangchong, Taewangreung and Janggunchong. Taewangreung of such 3 kings’tombs located on Gookgang has been commonly accepted as the King Gwanggaeto’s Tomb. However, the name of ‘King Hotae (好太 王)’cannot be the name to point out to the King Gwanggaeto. ‘King Hotae’copper name bell is also doubted on its excavation process and written form. Furthermore, it has been researched that the heritages excavated around Taewangreung could not be buried in Taewangreung. The tomb pointed as Gogookwonwangreung is the 992nd tomb located in Woosanha. It could not be easily accepted as a something belonging to the King Gogookwon in terms of its location condition, buried goods and size. Gogookwangwangreung also cannot be easily corresponded to Taewangreung located on Gookgang because of their clear difference of location condition. Following the King Gwanggaeto’s Tomb Stone, the kings’tombs located on Gookgang are Imgangchong, Taewangreung and Janggunchong. Imgangchong has been critically accepted as the King Dongcheon’s Tomb; Taewangreung as the King Gogookwon’s Tomb; and Janggunchong as the King Gwanggaeto’s Tomb. The King Dongcheon and King Gogookwon were the kings who overcome the biggest national crisis of Goguryeo. The King Gwanggaeto’s Tomb Stone nearby such two kings’tombs is engraved with such brilliant victories splendid enough. Janggunchong seen from the King Gwanggaeto’s Tomb Stone shows its grand look using the King Gwanggaeto’s Tomb Stone written with such remarkable victories as lights. Imgangchong and Taewangreung are connected each other under the view of political location, also under which the King Gwanggaeto’s Tomb Stone was stood at the point on the straight line between Taewangreung and Janggunchong even if they were far away each other. The 330 of family houses allocated as guardians of graves by the King Gwanggaeto were the number to be allocated to the King Dongcheon’s Tomb, King Gogookwon’s Tomb and King Gwanggaeto’s Tomb respectively by 110. Recently, China claimed that all the 28 kings’tombs of Goguryeo were located in China. It has been released that such China’s claim was based on the view: Janggunchong = the King Jangsu’s Tomb. This study points out to the nonsense of Sureungseol (壽陵說: a view that a king’s tomb is made before the king dies) regarding the assumption of Janggunchong = the King Jangsu’s Tomb but also found out the intention of China. Finally, this study has revealed a part of the nonsense of the claim that the kings’tombs of Goguryeo had been located in Jian since the capital moved to Pyeongyang.
Abstract
Goguryeo Kings are called from their tombs areas in many cases. In relation to this fact, I have researched the rivers’names in Jian area. Gookcheon (國川: national river) and Jungcheon (中川: central river) are regarded as a same river called Tongguha. Yalloo river which was critically accepted as Gookcheon has been found that its name of ‘Yalloo (鴨)’has been maintained as it is. ‘Gook (國)’relevant tomb area name is roughly categorized into Gookwon (國原: national field) but Gookyang (國壤: national land) corresponds to Gookcheon. They have been, therefore, critically renamed the area that covers both left and right area focused on Gooknae fortress. It was called Gookgang (國岡: national hill) that had hill on the east side of Gookwon. The kings’tombs located on such Gookgang are Imgangchong, Taewangreung and Janggunchong. Taewangreung of such 3 kings’tombs located on Gookgang has been commonly accepted as the King Gwanggaeto’s Tomb. However, the name of ‘King Hotae (好太 王)’cannot be the name to point out to the King Gwanggaeto. ‘King Hotae’copper name bell is also doubted on its excavation process and written form. Furthermore, it has been researched that the heritages excavated around Taewangreung could not be buried in Taewangreung. The tomb pointed as Gogookwonwangreung is the 992nd tomb located in Woosanha. It could not be easily accepted as a something belonging to the King Gogookwon in terms of its location condition, buried goods and size. Gogookwangwangreung also cannot be easily corresponded to Taewangreung located on Gookgang because of their clear difference of location condition. Following the King Gwanggaeto’s Tomb Stone, the kings’tombs located on Gookgang are Imgangchong, Taewangreung and Janggunchong. Imgangchong has been critically accepted as the King Dongcheon’s Tomb; Taewangreung as the King Gogookwon’s Tomb; and Janggunchong as the King Gwanggaeto’s Tomb. The King Dongcheon and King Gogookwon were the kings who overcome the biggest national crisis of Goguryeo. The King Gwanggaeto’s Tomb Stone nearby such two kings’tombs is engraved with such brilliant victories splendid enough. Janggunchong seen from the King Gwanggaeto’s Tomb Stone shows its grand look using the King Gwanggaeto’s Tomb Stone written with such remarkable victories as lights. Imgangchong and Taewangreung are connected each other under the view of political location, also under which the King Gwanggaeto’s Tomb Stone was stood at the point on the straight line between Taewangreung and Janggunchong even if they were far away each other. The 330 of family houses allocated as guardians of graves by the King Gwanggaeto were the number to be allocated to the King Dongcheon’s Tomb, King Gogookwon’s Tomb and King Gwanggaeto’s Tomb respectively by 110. Recently, China claimed that all the 28 kings’tombs of Goguryeo were located in China. It has been released that such China’s claim was based on the view: Janggunchong = the King Jangsu’s Tomb. This study points out to the nonsense of Sureungseol (壽陵說: a view that a king’s tomb is made before the king dies) regarding the assumption of Janggunchong = the King Jangsu’s Tomb but also found out the intention of China. Finally, this study has revealed a part of the nonsense of the claim that the kings’tombs of Goguryeo had been located in Jian since the capital moved to Pyeongyang.
참고문헌 (52)
- 서길수, "중화인민공화국 학자의 고구려 왕릉 비정에 대한 비판적 고찰", 고구려발해연구, 29, pp.305~337 (2007), 고구려발해학회
- 김종복, "집안의 고구려 도성, In 集安 高句麗 유적의 어제와 오늘", 성균관대학교박물관, 185~ (2006)
- 魏存成, "高句麗遺蹟", pp.164~ (2002)
- 余昊奎, "集安地域고구려 超大型積石墓의 전개과정과 그 被葬者문제", 韓國古代史硏究, 41, pp.89~ (2006)
- 고광의, "고구려 왕릉, In 고구려 문명 기행", pp.137~149 (2005), 고구려연구재단
- 李道學, "廣開土王陵碑文의 國烟과 看烟의 性格에 대한 再檢討", 韓國古代史硏究, 28 (2002)
- "고구려 광개토왕릉비문 연구", 297~ (2006)
- 李道學, "永樂 6年 廣開土王의 南征과 國原城, In 孫寶基博士停年紀念韓國史學論叢", pp.103~104 (1988), 1988
- 박진욱, "조선고고학전서 세편", pp.74~ (1991)
- 魏存成, "高句麗遺蹟", pp.164~ (2002)
- 손수호, "고구려고분연구", 49~ (2001)
- 박진욱, "조선고고학전서 중세편", pp.74~, 1991
- 김종복, "집안의고구려도성, In 集安高句麗유적의어제와오", pp.185~ (2006), 성균관대학교박물관
- 吉林省文物考古硏究所集安市博物館編, "集安高句麗王陵--1990∼2003年集安高句麗王陵調 査報告", 117~ (2004)
- 吉林省文物考古硏究所 集安市博物館, "w集安高句麗王陵--1990∼2003年 集安高句麗王陵調 査報告", 112~115 (2004)
- 여호규, "集安地域 고구려 超大型積石墓의 전개과정과 被葬者 문제", 한국고대사연구, (41), pp.85~134 (2006), 한국고대사학회
- 李熙濬, "太王陵의 墓主는 누구인가?", 한국고고학보, (59), pp.74~117 (2006), 한국고고학회
- 李道學, "永樂 6年 廣開土王의 南征과 國原城", 고구려 광개토왕릉비문 연구, pp.379~383 (2006)
- 박진욱, "조선고고학전서 중세편", pp.7~ (1991)
- 여호규, "集安地域 고구려 超大型積石墓의 전개과정과 被葬者 문제", 한국고대사연구, (41), pp.85~134 (2006), 한국고대사학회
- 吉林省文物考古硏究所 集安市博物館, "集安高句麗王陵--1990∼2003年 集安高句麗王陵調 査報告", 4~ (2004)
- 吉林省文物考古硏究所 集安市博物館, "集安高句麗王陵--1990∼2003年 集安高句麗王陵調 査報告", 5~ (2004)
- 강현숙, "중국 길림성 집안 지역 고구려 왕릉의 구조에 대하여", 한국고대사연구, (41), pp.5~46 (2006), 한국고대사학회
- 吉林省文物考古硏究所 集安市博物館, "集安高句麗王陵--1990∼2003年 集安高句麗王陵調 査報告", 216~ (2004)
- 조법종, "고구려 수묘제와 광개토왕대 사회 변화, In 고조선 고구려사 연구", pp.433~ (2006), 고조선 고구려사 연구
- 박시형, "광개토왕릉비", 139~ (1966)
- 朴眞奭, "太王陵 墓主新考, In 高句麗 文化의 歷史的 價値--韓 中共同學術會議", 34~ (2004)
- 民衆書林, "漢韓大字典", 522~ (1997)
- 이도학, "太王陵과 將軍塚의 被葬者 問題 再論", 고구려발해연구, 19, pp.119~147 (2005), 고구려발해학회
- 한국고대사회연구소, "譯註韓國古代金石文 1", 510~ (1992)
- 朴眞奭, "太王陵 墓主新考, In 高句麗 文化의 歷史的 價値--韓 中共同學術會議", 34~ (2004)
- 高寬敏, "三國史記の原典的硏究", 117~ (1996)
- 히스토리카 한국사편찬위원회, "히스토리카 한국사", pp.146~ (2007), 이끌리오
- 李道學, "太王陵과 將軍塚의 被葬者 問題 再論", 고구려연구회 2004년 추계학술대회 桓仁 集安 지역 고구려유적 발굴성과의 검토, pp.109~112 (2004)
- 최종택, "集安 高句麗 王陵 出土遺物의 諸 問題", 한국고대사연구, (41), pp.135~168 (2006), 한국고대사학회
- 吉林省文物考古硏究所, "集安高句麗王陵--1990∼2003年集安高句麗王陵 調査報告", ~ (2004)
- 李道學, "고도순례", 고구려의 두 번째 수도 국내성, 2008, pp.13~
- 崔鍾澤, "集安‘高句麗 王陵’出土遺物의 諸問題", 韓國古代史硏究, 41, pp.139~ (2006)
- 李熙濬, "太王陵의 墓主는 누구인가", 韓國考古學報, 59, pp.94~ (2006)
- 李道學, "高句麗의 國難과 故國原王像", 高句麗硏究, 23, pp.26~ (2006)
- 申采浩, "朝鮮上古史, In 丹齋申采浩全集 上卷", pp.197~198 (1987)
- 李道學, "高句麗의 國難과 故國原王像", 高句麗硏究, 23, pp.17~18 (2006)
- 李道學, "太王陵과 將軍塚의 被葬者 問題 再論", 고구려연구회 2004년 추계학술대회 桓仁·集 安지역 고구려유적 발굴성과의 검토, pp.112~ (2004)
- 余昊奎, "集安地域고구려 超大型積石墓의 전개과정과 그 被葬者문제", 韓國古代史硏究, 41, pp.126~127 (2006)
- 李道學, "'광개토대왕릉비'를 세운 목적은 무엇일까, In 다시 보는 고구려사", pp.216~ (2004)
- 張福有, "高句麗王陵通考要報", 東北史地, 4, pp.2~13 (2007)
- 吉林省文物考古硏究所, "集安高句麗王陵--1990∼2003年集安高句麗王陵 調査報告", 362~ (2004)
- 李道學, "역사가 기억해주는 이름", pp.63~64 (2007)
- 李道學, "고구려 광개토왕릉비문 연구", pp.339~340 (2006)
- 魏存成, "高句麗遺蹟", pp.167~ (2002)
- 李道學, "46차 고구려연구회 학술발표회 토론문", 46차 고구려연구회 정기학술발표, pp.39~ (2007)
- 張福有, "高句麗王陵通考", 東北史地, 4, pp.13~ (2007)
