본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

由董仲舒 “天人合一” 的思维方式来对汉代政治文化进行哲学考察

A Philosophical Study on Political Culture in the Han Period Seen Through Dong Zhong-Shu's “Heaven and Human Beings in Harmony as One” Thought

0

조회

0

다운로드

0

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

주제분류유교학

초록

汉代董仲舒“天人合一”思想所具有的实际意义只有将当代现实政治与他的思想直接联系起来分析才可以考察,尤其是“合一”的真正意义。为此,本文将分析“天人合一”的思维方式所具有的意义结构,然后进一步考察其思想在当代政治和经济领域中是如何内在化和具体化的。 第一,作为东方“自我修养”目标的“知行合一”知识观的实体实际上发展成为知识与权力相互依附的结构。因此,笔者首先通过董仲舒的思想来研究知识属于政治权力的过程。对传统儒学者来讲,学问是“理论与实践统一”的“知行合一”。这正是积极参与现实的儒学思想之根本。从这个侧面来讲董仲舒作为汉代的知识分子积极在现实政治中实现“知识分子的责任感”。 但问题是,“官僚知识分子”以及“知识分子官僚”在皇帝的支配体制之下,在归属到政治权力的过程之中,很难保持“知识与政治”的“合理的距离”,于是知识分子集团就丧失了其批判精神。董仲舒的“灾异说”是依据古代“天命论”在皇帝的善行和德行中追加了所谓的“灾异”,造成了实权(王权)的紧张感。从这一点上来讲是有其意义的。尽管参与政治的身份受到限制,但是这种紧张感还是通过个人的内在道德规范来实现。这种强调通过天和人(王)的合一来实现天道的做法在加速强化中央集权支配体制的过程中是有局限性的。 第二,“天人合一”的认识过程不仅仅包含了“合一(统一)”的层面,也包含了“相分(对立)”的层面。认识主体与客体的分离是认识的前提,在东方人的思维中自然也是如此。分离以后再进行统一的过程是认识的过程,这不仅仅是观念上的类推。这对在日常劳动过程中为了解放劳动力而制作发明工具的一般人来讲,也是很自然的。

Abstract

This paper is on the meaning of Dong Zhong-Shu's “Heaven and human beings in harmony as one” thought, and its significance in political and economical field. We connected the idea of “heaven and human beings in harmony as one” with unity of knowledge and action, which is aimed at self-cultivation. Through this, analysis on how knowledge and power forms a corrupt relationship was done. Confucian encourages active participation in practical politics. But the problem occurs when “scholars as bureaucrats” or “bureaucrats as scholars” become under the rule of the emperor's governing system. It hinders development of keeping reasonable distance between knowledge and politics, and leads to loss of criticism. We studied the relationship between power and knowledge based on scholars' critical mind mentioned earlier. Characteristics are as follows. First, Dong Zhong-Shu's “the Extraordinary Phenomena” founded on traditional “the mandate of heaven” gives the King a tension of the real power through tensional apparatus, “extraordinary phenomena.”Nevertheless, realization of God's role through heaven and human beings' harmony as one reinforces centralization of authority. The other aspect is that cognitive process of heaven and human beings in harmony as one does not only have “harmony as one” aspect, but also “Sangbun” aspect. This paper explains how Sangbun aspect shape up.

참고문헌 (20)

  1. "大学", ~
  2. "汉书", ~
  3. 金奉建, "董仲舒天人感性思想研究" (1991), 东亚大学
  4. 谢松龄, "天人象—阴阳五行学说是导论" (1989), 山东文艺出版社
  5. 柳东远, "儒家思想的官学化——以董仲舒的天人感应论为中心", 中国学研究, 22, 中国学研究会
  6. 本兹民, "中国古代思想的世界" (2004), 山林社
  7. 徐复观, "两汉思想史 卷2" (1979)
  8. 宋荣培, "东方历史哲学与绝对君主主义批判 in : 中国社会思想史" (1998), 社会评论
  9. 华有根, "董仲舒思想研究" (1992), 上海社会科学出版社
  10. 朴商焕, "对天人合一思想与主客对立关系的认识论研究:兼论东方哲学者的现实政治参与问题", 韩国社会科学论丛, 9 (1999)
  11. 朴商焕, "近代欧洲的中国哲学", 人文科学, 26 (1996), 成均馆大学校人文科学研究所
  12. 顾颉刚著, "中国古代的方士和儒生" (1991), 世界书社
  13. 冯友兰著, "中国哲学史(上,下)" (2003), 喜鹊社
  14. 柳东源, "儒家思想的官学化——以董仲舒的天人感应论为中心", 中国学研究, 22 (2002), 中国学研究会
  15. 王晓明, "人文学的危机——面对人文新道路的中国知识人的省察和探索" (1999), 绿林
  16. De Groot, "Religion in China" (1918), Berlin
  17. "J. Levenson, Confucian China and its Modern Fate, Vol.1-3, Berkely and Los Angeles,1958-65", ~
  18. "Marx", Engels, Deutsche Ideologie, Bd.3
  19. J.Needham, "Science and Civilisation in China, Vol.2" (1956), Cambridge
  20. H.Roetz, "Mensch und Natur im alten China" (1984), Ffm

관련 논문AI추천

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (11건)