실어증 환자에서 선다형 이름 맞추기 검사의 유용성
The Usefulness of Multiple-Choice Name Matching Test in Aphasic Patients
0
조회
0
다운로드
1
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
The aim of this study is to investigate the usefulness of the multiple-choice name matching test (MC-NMT) in adults with aphasia by comparing the Korean version of the Boston Naming Test (K-BNT) and subsets of the Korean version of the Western Aphasia Battery (K-WAB). Thirty-nine patients who suffer from aphasia participated in the study. All patients were examined by the K-BNT, MC-NMT and K-WAB. The MC-NMT consisted of the 30 original BNT object stimuli which were presented with four response choices (written words) with similar frequency, including one correct and three incorrect responses. Cards containing the drawings were presented to the patient one at time. An item was passed if the patient chose the correct response within 10 seconds. We subdivided two groups into a total group and a low K-BNT group (at and below 15 points). We evaluated the correlation between the K-BNT, MC-NMT score and production, naming, repetition,comprehension, reading and writing scores in subsets of the K-WAB. There was a highly positive correlation between the K-BNT score and naming score of the K-WAB in total patients. However, the MC-NMT was highly correlated with reading scores in the K-WAB. In low score K-BNT patients, the K-BNT strongly correlated with production, naming and repetition scores of the K-WAB. These findings mean that K-BNT reflects motor language function. However, the MC-NMT was strong correlated comprehension, reading and writing of the K-WAB. This finding reflects sensory language function. We suggest that the combination of K-BNT and newly developed MC-NMT will be useful to evaluate speech functions in aphasic patients.
Abstract
The aim of this study is to investigate the usefulness of the multiple-choice name matching test (MC-NMT) in adults with aphasia by comparing the Korean version of the Boston Naming Test (K-BNT) and subsets of the Korean version of the Western Aphasia Battery (K-WAB). Thirty-nine patients who suffer from aphasia participated in the study. All patients were examined by the K-BNT, MC-NMT and K-WAB. The MC-NMT consisted of the 30 original BNT object stimuli which were presented with four response choices (written words) with similar frequency, including one correct and three incorrect responses. Cards containing the drawings were presented to the patient one at time. An item was passed if the patient chose the correct response within 10 seconds. We subdivided two groups into a total group and a low K-BNT group (at and below 15 points). We evaluated the correlation between the K-BNT, MC-NMT score and production, naming, repetition,comprehension, reading and writing scores in subsets of the K-WAB. There was a highly positive correlation between the K-BNT score and naming score of the K-WAB in total patients. However, the MC-NMT was highly correlated with reading scores in the K-WAB. In low score K-BNT patients, the K-BNT strongly correlated with production, naming and repetition scores of the K-WAB. These findings mean that K-BNT reflects motor language function. However, the MC-NMT was strong correlated comprehension, reading and writing of the K-WAB. This finding reflects sensory language function. We suggest that the combination of K-BNT and newly developed MC-NMT will be useful to evaluate speech functions in aphasic patients.
참고문헌 (18)
- 국립국어연구원, "현대국어사용빈도조사2", 국립국어연구원, ~ (2005)
- Edwards, D. F., "Screening patientswith stroke for rehabilitation needs: validation of thepost-stroke rehabilitation guidelines", Neurorehabil NeuralRepair, 20, pp.42~48 (2006)
- Enderby, P., "Frenchay aphasia screening test:validity and comparability", Disabil Rehabil, 18, pp.238~240 (1996)
- Kertesz, A., "Western aphasia battery" (1982), Grune &Stratton
- Kertesz, A., "Neuropsychological evaluation of language", JClin Neurophysiol, 11, pp.205~215 (1994)
- Kertesz, A., "Recovery patterns and prognosisin aphasia", Brain, 100, pp.1~18 (1977)
- 김향희, "한국판 보스톤 이름대기 검사(K-BNT)" (1997), 학지사
- 김향희, "파라다이스 한국판 웨스턴 실어증 검사(PARADISE·K-WAB)" (2001), 파라다이스 복지재단
- 김향희, "실어증 선별검사 도구개발을 위한 예비연구", 음성과학, 13(2), pp.7~18 (2006), 한국음성과학회
- Mack, W. J., "Boston naming test : shortened versions for use inAlzheimer’s disease", J Gerontology, 47, pp.154~158 (1992)
- 오정희, "재활의학에서의 실어증 관리", 대한재활의학회, 9(2), pp.49~56 (1985)
- 박혜숙, "한국어판 실어증 감별진단검사법 시안(I)의 임상적용에 대한예비연구", 대한신경과학회, 10, pp.350~357 (1992)
- Porch, B., "Porch index of communication ability:administration, scoring, and interpretation" (1967), Consulting Psychologists Press
- 편성범, "한국판 프렌차이 실어증선별검사의 개발을 위한 정상성인의 표준화 연구", Annals of Rehabilitation Medicine, 33(4), pp.436~440 (2009), 대한재활의학회
- Schull, H. M., "Minnesota test for differential diagnosis ofaphasia" (1965), Universityy of Minnesota press
- Syder, D, "SheffieldScreening Test for Acquired Language Disorders" (1993), NFER-NELSON
- Spreen, O, "Assessment of Aphasia", pp.50~57 (2003), Oxford university press
- Welch, L. W., "Educational and gender normative data for the Boston namingtest in a group of older adults", Brain Lang, 53, pp.260~266 (1996)