A Discourse Analysis Approach to the Sluicing Conundrum
2
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
With a critical review of previous analyses on sluicing construction, this study points out problems with structural analyses on sluicing and demonstrates a way to retrieve putative sources for the elided portion in sluicing, minimizing the complexity of deriving sluicing constructions. This paper focuses on so called connectivity effects that constitute a prima facie piece of evidence of movement of the sluice out of a sentential constituent. Much work has been done to resolve the sluicing conundrum between the connectivity effect and absence of syntactic island violation. This paper argues that employing the Cooper style E-type pronoun in the derivation of the second conjunct of sluicing constructions can account for the conundrum without unnecessary complication of grammar. This paper also shows the necessity of considering relevant discourse that affects the acceptability of sluicing which can be represented as a continuum depending on the prominency of the correlate. Degraded acceptability of sluicing with implicit antecedents is from difficulties in parsing the sluice with non-prominent antecendent.
Abstract
With a critical review of previous analyses on sluicing construction, this study points out problems with structural analyses on sluicing and demonstrates a way to retrieve putative sources for the elided portion in sluicing, minimizing the complexity of deriving sluicing constructions. This paper focuses on so called connectivity effects that constitute a prima facie piece of evidence of movement of the sluice out of a sentential constituent. Much work has been done to resolve the sluicing conundrum between the connectivity effect and absence of syntactic island violation. This paper argues that employing the Cooper style E-type pronoun in the derivation of the second conjunct of sluicing constructions can account for the conundrum without unnecessary complication of grammar. This paper also shows the necessity of considering relevant discourse that affects the acceptability of sluicing which can be represented as a continuum depending on the prominency of the correlate. Degraded acceptability of sluicing with implicit antecedents is from difficulties in parsing the sluice with non-prominent antecendent.
참고문헌 (40)
- Albert,C., "Sluicing and Weak Islands", 석사, pp.1993
- Chomsky,N., "A Minimalist Program for Linguistic Theory, in The View from Building 20 –Essays in Linguistics in Honor of Sylvain Bromberger", pp.1~52 (1993), MIT Press
- Chomsky, N., "Principles and Parameters Theory,in Syntax: An International Handbook of Contemporary Research", pp.506~570 (1993), Mouton de Gruyter
- Chung,S.,et al, "Sluicing and Logical Form", Natural Language Semantics, 3, pp.239~282 (1995)
- Chung,S., "Sluicing Revisited. LSA Annual Meeting Symposyum on Ellipsis" (2006), Albuquerque
- van Craenenbroeck,J., "What Lies Beneath: The Hidden Syntax of Sluicing", Talk given at New York University, ~ (2007)
- 1996, , ~
- Culicover, P, "Syntax Made Simple(r)" (2005), Oxford University Press
- Dalrymple,S.,et al, "Ellipsis and Higher-order Unification", Linguistics and Philosophy, 14, pp.399~452 (1991)
- Evans,G., "Pronouns", Linguistic Inquiry, 11, pp.337~362 (1980)
- Fiengo, R., "The Eliminative Puzzles of Ellipsis. In Proceedings of the Stuttgart Ellipsis Workshop, Heidelberg", Arbieitspapiere des Sonderforschungbereichs 340, Bericht Nr. 29., ~ (1992)
- Fodor, J. A., "Functional Structure, Quantifiers and Meaning Postulates", Linguistic Inquiry, 11, pp.759~770 (1980)
- Fortin,C., "Indonesian Sluicing and the P-stranding Generalization. Paper presented at the 14th Annual Meeting of the Austronesian Formal Linguistics Association (AFLA14)", McGill University, ~ (2007)
- Fox,D., "Economy and Semantic Interpretation" (2000), MIT Press
- Fox, D., "Successive Cyclic Movement and Island Repair: The Difference between Sluicing and VP Ellipsis", Linguistic Inquiry, 34, pp.143~164 (2003)
- Ginzburg, J., "Interrogative Investigations: The Form, Meaning, and Use of English Interrogatives" (2000), Center for the Study of Language and Information
- Hardt, D., "Ellipsis and the Structure of Discourse", Journal of Semantics, 21, pp.375~414 (2004)
- Hendricks, P., "Optimality Theoretic Semantics", Linguistics and Philosophy, 24, pp.1~32 (2001)
- Kennedy, C., "Attributive Comparative Deletion", Natural Language and Linguistic Theory, 19, pp.89~146 (2000)
- 김수연, "E-type anaphora will do", 생성문법연구, 16(4), pp.695~716 (2006), 한국생성문법학회
- 김수연, "Islands in sluicing with implicit antecedents", 언어, 33(4), pp.589~609 (2008), 한국언어학회
- 김수연, "Questioning Assumptions for Scope Parallelism in Sluicing", 생성문법연구, 19(4), pp.529~547 (2009), 한국생성문법학회
- Kim, S.-Y., "Sluicing with Implicit Indefinites as Antecedents", 석사, pp.2010
- Koopman, H., "Variables and the Bijection Principle", Linguistic Review, 2, pp.139~160 (1982)
- Natural Explanations for Some Syntactic Universals. Mathematical Linguistics and Automatic Translation, "Kuno,S.", National Science Foundation, 1~85, pp.NSF-28 (1972)
- Kuno, S., "Multiple Wh Questions", Linguistic Inquiry, 3, pp.463~487 (1972)
- Lakoff,G., "A Note on Vagueness and Ambiguity (a squib)", Linguistic Inquiry, 1, pp.357~359 (1972)
- Lasnik,H., "When Can You Save a Structure by Destroying It?", North East Linguistic Society, 31, pp.301~320 (2001)
- Lasnik,H., "On Ellipsis: the PF Approach to Missing Constituents", University of Maryland Working Papers in Linguistics, 15(A) (2007)
- Conroy, C., , College Park, MD, 143~153
- Lobeck,A., "The Phrase Structure of Ellipsis, in Perspectives on phrase structure", pp.81~103 (1991), Academic Press
- May,R., "Logical Form - Its Structure and Derivation" (1985), MIT Press
- Merchant,J., "The Syntax of Silence: Sluicing, Islands, and Identity in Ellipsis" (2001), Oxford University Press.
- Merchant,J., "Swiping in Germanic, in Studies in Comparative Germanic Syntax", pp.289~316 (2002), John Benjamins
- Merchant,J., "Sluicing, in The Blackwell Companion to Syntax", pp.269~289 (2003), Wiley Blackwell
- Merchant,J., "Fragments and Ellipsis", Linguistics and philosophy, 27, pp.661~728 (2004)
- van Riemsdijk,H., "A Case Study in Syntactic Markedness: The Binding Nature of Prepositional Phrases" (1978), Foris
- Romero,M., "Focus and Reconstruction Effects in Wh-phrases" (1998), University of Massachusetts dissertation
- Ross,R., "Guess Who? In Papers from the Fifth Regional Meeting of the Chicago Linguistics Society", 252~286 (1969)
- Wasow,T., "Anaphoric Relations in English" (1972), MIT dissertation