朱子의 윤리학에서 차등적 배려의 정당성
The Justification of Discriminative Treatment in Zhu xi's Ethics
1
조회
0
다운로드
6
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
This article attempts to criticize the opinion of "treat all sentient beings equivalently" asserted by A. Naess & P. Singer, and to certify the justification of discriminative treatment suggested by Zhu xi. This paper, first, criticizes A. Naess & P. Singer's point of view, and argues that all sentient beings are different based on the theory of Li-Yi-Fen-Shu(理一分殊). Second, this article attempts to recover the status of human beings that is extinguished in dialogue of deep ecology through Zhu xi's Explanation on Can-Zan-Hua-Yu(參贊化育), and to illuminate significance of Cheng(誠) as basic behavior of Can-Zan-Hua-Yu .Last, this article attempts to find the practical methods of ecology from re-construing Zhu xi's cultivation theory of Ge-Wu(格物)
Abstract
This article attempts to criticize the opinion of "treat all sentient beings equivalently" asserted by A. Naess & P. Singer, and to certify the justification of discriminative treatment suggested by Zhu xi. This paper, first, criticizes A. Naess & P. Singer's point of view, and argues that all sentient beings are different based on the theory of Li-Yi-Fen-Shu(理一分殊). Second, this article attempts to recover the status of human beings that is extinguished in dialogue of deep ecology through Zhu xi's Explanation on Can-Zan-Hua-Yu(參贊化育), and to illuminate significance of Cheng(誠) as basic behavior of Can-Zan-Hua-Yu .Last, this article attempts to find the practical methods of ecology from re-construing Zhu xi's cultivation theory of Ge-Wu(格物)
참고문헌 (21)
- 程顥, "二程文集" (1997), 中華書局
- 楊時, "龜山集" (2000), 中華書局
- 朱熹, "朱熹集" (1998), 四川敎育出版社
- 朱熹, "朱子語類" (1987), 中華書局
- 김명식, "환경, 생명, 심의민주주의" (2002), 범양사
- 한면희, "미래세대와 생태윤리" (2007), 철학과현실사
- 김남준, "식물윤리학의 원리- 식물윤리학의 근거 정립을 위한 시론적 연구", 환경철학, 12(12), pp.1~35 (2011), 한국환경철학회
- 김명식, "동물윤리와 환경윤리: 동물해방론과 생태중심주의 비교", 환경철학, (15), pp.1~30 (2013), 한국환경철학회
- 김세정, "서구의 환경철학과 왕양명의 한몸 철학", 양명학, 4 (2000), 한국양명학회
- 안옥선, "생태적 삶의 태도로서 ‘동일시’와 ‘동체자비’", 불교와 문화, 1 (2007), 동아시아불교문화학회
- 이승환, "주자의 공동체적 생태윤리" (2006)
- Arne Naess, "Ecology, Community and Lifestyle" (1989), Cambridge Univ Press
- Bill Devall, "Deep Ecology" (1985), Peregrine Smith Books
- Joseph, R. Desjardin, "Environmental Ethics, An Introduction to Environmental Philosophy" (2006), Thomson Wadsworth
- Murray Bookchin, "사회생태론의 철학" (1997), 솔출판사
- Peter Singer, "사회생물학과 윤리(The Expanding Circle)" (1999), 인간사랑
- Peter Singer, "실천윤리학" (2003), 철학과 현실사
- Anthony Weston, "Multicentrism: A Manifesto", Environmental Ethics, 26(Spring) (2004)
- Arne Naess, "Deep Ecology for the 21st Century" (1995), Shambhala Publication
- Arne Naess, "Environmental Philosophy -From Animal Right to Radical Ecology-" (1998), Prentice Hall
- David Barnhill, "Deep Ecology and World Religion" (2002), SUNY Press