그루지야의 혁명가에서 소련의 독재자로: 스탈린의 신화와 현실
From a Georgian Revolutionary to the Dictator of the Soviet Union: Myths and Truths of Stalin
0
조회
0
다운로드
1
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
This paper aims to reexamine Stalin as a Bolshevik revolutionary and the dictator of the Soviet Union, using recent researches about his biography which revise the general images of his life. As many scholars show on the basis of primary sources including recently declassifying archival materials, Stalin was a contradictory and complicated person, who can not be judged simply as “a great man” or “an incarnation of evil.” Stalin can not abandon Georgian identity, even though he wanted to be a Russian. He had the courage to challenge Lenin if he needed, while he worshiped Lenin as his hero. He was always doubtful of those close to him, even after he obtained autocratic power to condemn them to death if he wanted to. Moreover, he depended on informal “inner circle” consisting of a few people when he had to made a decision, but, on the other hand. he continued to decentralize the structure of government formally. He personally decided on some policies, but he did not even look at many other policies, leaving them in the hands of his subordinates. In this respect, a final version of Stalin’s biography is not completed, although many scholars, Russian and Western, have attempted to reevaluate his entire life in earnest particularly since the collapse of the Soviet Union. In addition, it does not seems to be written even after all the materials concerning him are available. It is because Stalin himself showed ambivalent and unclear attitudes and actions at every crucial moments of his life, which make possible conflicting interpretations at any time. Thus, Stalin will remain “a fascinating man,” attracting the attentions of many biographers in the future as before.
Abstract
This paper aims to reexamine Stalin as a Bolshevik revolutionary and the dictator of the Soviet Union, using recent researches about his biography which revise the general images of his life. As many scholars show on the basis of primary sources including recently declassifying archival materials, Stalin was a contradictory and complicated person, who can not be judged simply as “a great man” or “an incarnation of evil.” Stalin can not abandon Georgian identity, even though he wanted to be a Russian. He had the courage to challenge Lenin if he needed, while he worshiped Lenin as his hero. He was always doubtful of those close to him, even after he obtained autocratic power to condemn them to death if he wanted to. Moreover, he depended on informal “inner circle” consisting of a few people when he had to made a decision, but, on the other hand. he continued to decentralize the structure of government formally. He personally decided on some policies, but he did not even look at many other policies, leaving them in the hands of his subordinates. In this respect, a final version of Stalin’s biography is not completed, although many scholars, Russian and Western, have attempted to reevaluate his entire life in earnest particularly since the collapse of the Soviet Union. In addition, it does not seems to be written even after all the materials concerning him are available. It is because Stalin himself showed ambivalent and unclear attitudes and actions at every crucial moments of his life, which make possible conflicting interpretations at any time. Thus, Stalin will remain “a fascinating man,” attracting the attentions of many biographers in the future as before.
참고문헌 (33)
- "스탈린과 히틀러의 전쟁" (2003), 서울: 지식의 풍경
- "20세기 러시아 현대사" (2004), 서울: 사회평론
- "Как Москву чуть не переименовали" (2007)
- "Кто стоял за спиной Сталина Москва-Ст" (2004), Петербург: Центролиграф МиМ-Дельта
- "Политбюро: Механизмы полиической власти в 1930-е годы" (1996), Москва
- "A Social and Economic History of the USSR in World War II"
- "Stalin, the Red Army, and the ‘Great Patriotic War", pp.185~207 (1997), Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
- "The Struggle With the Right Opposition Foundations of Soviet Totalitarianism", tion, pp.22~39 (1972), Lexington
- "Soviet History in the Gorbachev Revolution" (1989), Indiana University Press
- "Soviet History in the Yeltsin Era" (1997), New York: St. Martin’s Press
- "Stalin As Economic Policy-Maker: Soviet Agriculture, 1931~1936", pp.121~139 (2005), Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
- "Stalin As Prime Minister: Power and the Politburo", pp.83~107 (2005), Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
- "Stalin’s Cabinet: The Politburo and Decision Making in the Post-war Years", 53(2), pp.291~312 (2001)
- "Cold Peace: Stalin and the Soviet Ruling Circle, 1945~1953" (2004), Oxford: Oxford University Press
- "Stalin As General Secretary The Appointments Process and the Nature of Stalin’s Power", pp.63~82 (2005), Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
- "Stalin As Dictator The Personalization of Power", pp.108~120 (2005), Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
- "Stalin: Profiles in Power" (2005), Harlow: Pearson Longman
- "Socialism in One Country The Modern Encyclopedia of Russian and Soviet History", pp.80~84 (1983), Academic International Press
- "Stalin’s Biography", pp.32~47 (2005), London and New York: Routledge
- "Stalin" (2006), Palgrave
- "The Modern Encyclopedia of Russian and Soviet History", iosif vissario(vich), pp.63~72 (1984), Academic International Press
- "Stalin: The First In-depth Biography Based on Explosive New Documents from Russia’s Secret Archives" (1996), New York: Doubleday
- "Stalin, Man of the Borderlands", 106(5), pp.1651~1691 (2001)
- "Stalin As Georgian: The Formative Years", pp.18~44 (2005), Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
- "The Georgian Affair of 1922: Policy Failure, Personality Clash or Power Struggle", 50(3), pp.519~544 (1998)
- "Stalin As Commissar for Nationality Affairs", pp.45~62 (2005), Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
- "A Journeyman for the Revolution Stalin and the Labour Movement in Baku", pp.373~394 (1972)
- "The Making of the Georgian Nation" (1988), Indiana University Press
- "The Young Stalin in Georgia", pp.48~58 (1991)
- "Stalin As Revolutionary"
- "Stalin As Marxist: The Western Roots of Stalin’s Russification of Marxism", pp.159~180 (2005), Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
- "원고 접수일: 2007년 3월 28일" (2007)
- "게재 결정일: 2007년 5월 21일" (2007)