Evaluation of portion size estimation aids for the Korea National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey
1
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
BACKGROUND/OBJECTIVES: This study aimed to improve portion size estimation aids (PSEAs) used in the nutrition survey of the Korea National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (KNHANES) and validate the accuracy and precision of the newly developed aids. SUBJECTS/METHODS: We conducted intensive interviews with survey experts in KNHANES and consulted with experts to collect opinions about improvement of PSEAs. Based on the results of the interviews, 5 types of PSEAs (rice bowl, earthen pots, mounds, measuring spoons, and thickness sticks) were newly developed using 3-dimensional (3D) modeling or modification of color or shape. Validation tests were conducted with 96 adults 20 years old or older. For the rice bowl and earthen pots, the participants were asked to select the more similar PSEA in size after being shown the real dishes. For the mounds, measuring spoons, and thickness sticks, the participants were presented with actual plates of food and asked to estimate the given portion sizes using the given PSEAs. RESULTS: The improved 2-dimensional (2D) picture aid for the rice bowl reflecting the size distortion by angle of view using 3D modeling was perceived more closely to the actual size than the current 2D picture (P < 0.001). The change of the color of 2D pictures and 3D models, the change of shape of the measuring spoons, and the 3-dimensionalization of the 2D mounds had no significant improvement in the subjects' perception. CONCLUSIONS: The currently used 2D PSEAs need to be fully redesigned using 3D modeling to improve subjects' perception. However, change of color or shape will not be necessary. For amorphous foods, it is suggested that more evaluation be performed before reaching a final conclusion in the use of PSEAs, or alternative ways to improve accuracy of estimation need to be explored.
Abstract
BACKGROUND/OBJECTIVES: This study aimed to improve portion size estimation aids (PSEAs) used in the nutrition survey of the Korea National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (KNHANES) and validate the accuracy and precision of the newly developed aids. SUBJECTS/METHODS: We conducted intensive interviews with survey experts in KNHANES and consulted with experts to collect opinions about improvement of PSEAs. Based on the results of the interviews, 5 types of PSEAs (rice bowl, earthen pots, mounds, measuring spoons, and thickness sticks) were newly developed using 3-dimensional (3D) modeling or modification of color or shape. Validation tests were conducted with 96 adults 20 years old or older. For the rice bowl and earthen pots, the participants were asked to select the more similar PSEA in size after being shown the real dishes. For the mounds, measuring spoons, and thickness sticks, the participants were presented with actual plates of food and asked to estimate the given portion sizes using the given PSEAs. RESULTS: The improved 2-dimensional (2D) picture aid for the rice bowl reflecting the size distortion by angle of view using 3D modeling was perceived more closely to the actual size than the current 2D picture (P < 0.001). The change of the color of 2D pictures and 3D models, the change of shape of the measuring spoons, and the 3-dimensionalization of the 2D mounds had no significant improvement in the subjects' perception. CONCLUSIONS: The currently used 2D PSEAs need to be fully redesigned using 3D modeling to improve subjects' perception. However, change of color or shape will not be necessary. For amorphous foods, it is suggested that more evaluation be performed before reaching a final conclusion in the use of PSEAs, or alternative ways to improve accuracy of estimation need to be explored.
참고문헌 (26)
- Nelson M, "Food photography II : use of food photographs for estimating portion size and the nutrient content of meals", Br J Nutr, 76, pp.31~49 (1996)
- Nelson M, "Food photography. I : the perception of food portion size from photographs", Br J Nutr, 72, pp.649~663 (1994)
- Lucas F, "Estimation of food portion size using photographs: validity, strengths, weaknesses and recommendations", J Hum Nutr Diet, 8, pp.65~74 (1995)
- Cypel YS, "Validity of portion-size measurement aids : a review", J Am Diet Assoc, 97, pp.289~292 (1997)
- Robson PJ, "An evaluation of food photographs as a tool for quantifying food and nutrient intakes", Public Health Nutr, 3, pp.183~192 (2000)
- Matheson DM, "Validity of children's food portion estimates : a comparison of 2 measurement aids", Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med, 156, pp.867~871 (2002)
- de Vlieger NM, "A systematic review of recall errors associated with portion size estimation aids in children", Appetite, 147, pp.104522~ (2020)
- "Korea Health Statistics 2018: Korea National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (KNHANES VII-3)" (2019)[URL]
- Ministry of Health and Welfare, Korea Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, "Guideline for Nutrition Survey in 6th Korea National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey", Korea Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, ~ (2015)
- Godwin S, "Evaluation of portion size estimation aids used for meat in dietary surveys", Nutr Res, 21, pp.1217~1233 (2001)
- Godwin S, "A new portion size estimation aid for wedge-shaped foods", J Am Diet Assoc, 106, pp.1246~1250 (2006)
- McGuire B, "Size categories most effective for estimating portion size of muffins", J Am Diet Assoc, 101, pp.470~472 (2001)
- Venter CS, "The development and testing of a food portion photograph book for use in an African population", J Hum Nutr Diet, 13, pp.205~218 (2000)
- Turconi G, "An evaluation of a colour food photography atlas as a tool for quantifying food portion size in epidemiological dietary surveys", Eur J Clin Nutr, 59, pp.923~931 (2005)
- Bernal-Orozco MF, "Validation of a Mexican food photograph album as a tool to visually estimate food amounts in adolescents", Br J Nutr, 109, pp.944~952 (2013)
- Thoradeniya T, "Portion size estimation aids for Asian foods", J Hum Nutr Diet, 25, pp.497~504 (2012)
- Almiron-Roig E, "Dietary assessment in minority ethnic groups : a systematic review of instruments for portion-size estimation in the United Kingdom", Nutr Rev, 75, pp.188~213 (2017)
- Yuhas JA, "The impact of training, food type, gender, and container size on the estimation of food portion sizes", J Am Diet Assoc, 89, pp.1473~1477 (1989)
- Slawson DL, "Intense practice enhances accuracy of portion size estimation of amorphous foods", J Am Diet Assoc, 97, pp.295~297 (1997)
- Ovaskainen ML, "Accuracy in the estimation of food servings against the portions in food photographs", Eur J Clin Nutr, 62, pp.674~681 (2008)
- Young LR, "Portion sizes in dietary assessment : issues and policy implications", Nutr Rev, 53, pp.149~158 (1995)
- Hwang IK, "Food Quality Management and Sensory Evaluation", pp.147~175 (2014), Kyomunsa
- Chambers E 4th, "Cognitive strategies for reporting portion sizes using dietary recall procedures", J Am Diet Assoc, 100, pp.891~897 (2000)
- Meilgaard MC, "Sensory Evaluation Techniques", pp.435~ (2007), CRC Press
- Korea Health Statistics 2016: Korea National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (KNHANES VII-1), "Ministry of Health and Welfare", Korea Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 169~ (2017)
- Nelson M, "Food photographs : practical guidelines I. Design and analysis of studies to validate portion size estimates", Public Health Nutr, 1, pp.219~230 (1998)