Differences in Perceptions towards Japanese Colonial Era Heritage: A Case Study of Gunsan City’s Old Downtown
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Modern cultural heritage has clear significance and value as part of the historical record of a given country. However, perspectives on the value and role of cultural heritage can vary. This study compares the perceptions of various subjects on urban colonial cultural heritage. The similarities and differences between the direction of local culture pursued by local experts and the perceptions of different subjects are analyzed, and the reinforced image of a multifaceted city image is examined. The results reveal that, first, differences exist within the reference group. The reference group determined the city of Gunsan’s resources, which led to regional revitalization projects to improve the city’s image. Second, commonalities were observed between the perceived images of local residents, visitors, and non-visitors. All three groups understood Gunsan as a city of modern history and a city where past and present coexist. Third, examining non-visitors’ perceptions of Gunsan as a reinforced image revealed that their perceptions were similar to those of visitors. The public’s view of colonial history is the same: it is a painful history but one that must be remembered. However, the interpretation and use of that heritage differ widely. The administration of Gunsan should manage the city’s image to prevent historical distortion or the misunderstanding of history by the perceiving subjects.
Abstract
Modern cultural heritage has clear significance and value as part of the historical record of a given country. However, perspectives on the value and role of cultural heritage can vary. This study compares the perceptions of various subjects on urban colonial cultural heritage. The similarities and differences between the direction of local culture pursued by local experts and the perceptions of different subjects are analyzed, and the reinforced image of a multifaceted city image is examined. The results reveal that, first, differences exist within the reference group. The reference group determined the city of Gunsan’s resources, which led to regional revitalization projects to improve the city’s image. Second, commonalities were observed between the perceived images of local residents, visitors, and non-visitors. All three groups understood Gunsan as a city of modern history and a city where past and present coexist. Third, examining non-visitors’ perceptions of Gunsan as a reinforced image revealed that their perceptions were similar to those of visitors. The public’s view of colonial history is the same: it is a painful history but one that must be remembered. However, the interpretation and use of that heritage differ widely. The administration of Gunsan should manage the city’s image to prevent historical distortion or the misunderstanding of history by the perceiving subjects.
참고문헌 (23)
- "Burra Charter" (1979)[URL]
- "Geundae munhwa yusan bojon eul wihan deungnok munhwajae jedo (Registered Cultural Property System for Preserving Modern Cultural Heritage)" (2007)[URL]
- Formed during the Japanese Occupation and Researching Ways to Preserve and Utilize It), "Paper presented at a public hearing by the Cultural Heritage Administration and Korea Architects Institute", 2019, ~, pp.National Palace Museum of Korea
- Cheer, Joseph M, "Colonial Heritage and Tourism : Ethnic Landscape Perspectives", Journal of Heritage Tourism, 10(2), pp.151~166 (2015)[DOI]
- "European Landscape Convention and Reference Documents" (2000)[URL]
- Echtner, Charlotte M., "The Context of Third World Tourism Marketing", Annals of Tourism Research, 30(3), pp.660~682 (2003)
- Je, Jum-suk, "Busan jiyeok-ui geundae munhwa yusan gwa yeoksa insik munje: Busan-ui deungnok munhwajae-reul jungsim-euro (Modern Cultural Heritage in Busan and Issues of Historical Awareness:Focused on ‘Registered Cultural Properties’ in Busan)", Hangdo Busan (Journal of Busan Studies), 33, pp.141~172 (2017)[DOI]
- Jeong, Hee-sun, "Haebang ihu joseon chongdokbu cheongsa-ui byeoncheon gwa geu uimi (Japanese Government-General Building’s Changes and Its Meaning After the Liberation of Korea)", Hanguk minjok undongsa yeongu (Journal of Studies on the Korean National Movement), 94, pp.193~222 (2018)
- Jeong, Su Jin, "Singminji yusan-eseo hanguk-uIi munhwa yusan-euro: Geundae munhwa yusan deungnok jedo-reul jungsim-euro (From the Colonial Residue to Korean Cultural Heritage: Focusing on the Modern Cultural Heritage Registration System)", Bigyo minsokhak (Asian Comparative Folklore), 71, pp.187~217 (2020)
- Jung, Carl Gustav, "Man and His Symbols" (1964), Dell Publishing
- Jung, Chan-young, "Gwangwanggaek-ui jipdan gieok-eul tonghan jangso jeongcheseong hyeongseong: Geundae munhwa yusan-eul jungsim-euro (Formation of Place Identity Through Tourists’ Collective Memory: Focusing on Modern Cultural Heritage)", PhD, pp.2018
- Keller, Nadine, "New Media Travel Writing and the Renegotiation of Postcolonial Discourses: A Critical Discourse Analysis of Representations of the ‘Middle East’ on Travel Blogs", Master, pp.2018
- "Geundae munhwa yusan gwangwang jawonhwa bangan-e gwanhan yeongu bogo (Research Report on the Tourism Resourceization of Modern Cultural Heritage)" (2005)[URL]
- Marine-Roig, Estela, "A Detailed Method for Destination Image Analysis Using User-generated Content", Information Technology & Tourism, 15, pp.341~364 (2016)[DOI]
- Moon, Ye Eun, "Geundae munhwa yusan-eul dulleossan damron-ui gyeong jaeng yangsang bunseok: Gunsan-si-reul jungsim-euro (The Competition Analysis of Discourse on the Modern Cultural Heritage: Focused on the Case of Gunsan City)", Jibangsa-wa jibang munhwa (Journal of Local History and Culture), 14(2), pp.265~304 (2011)[DOI]
- Park, Jong Hyun, "Ilje sindosi gonggangujo-ui seongjang-gwa byeonhwa-e gwanhan yeongu: Gunsansi-ui sarye-reul jungsim-euro (Analysis on Develop ment and Change of the New Town Spatial Structure with the Use of Space Syntax under Japanese Imperialism: Focusing on the Case of Gunsan City)", Master, pp.2006
- Sun, Minghui, "Using Chinese Travel Blogs to Examine Perceived Destination Image: The case of New Zealand", Journal of Travel Research, 54(4), pp.543~555 (2015)[DOI]
- Tuan, Yi-Fu, "Space and Place: The Perspective of Experience" (1977), University of Minnesota Press
- "Cultural Landscapes" (1992)[URL]
- "Vienna Memorandum on ‘World Heritage and Contemporary Architecture—Managing the Historic Urban Landscape’ and Decision 29 COM 5D" (2005)[URL]
- Wong, Cora Un In, "The Sanitization of Colonial History: Authenticity, Heritage Interpretation and the Case of Macau’s Tour Guides", Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 21(6), pp.915~931 (2013)[DOI]
- Yang, Eun-Jung, "Gunsansi wondosim-e gwanhan gyehoek bangsik-ui byeonhwa-wa teukseong: 1960-nyeondae buteo 2010-nyeondae kkaji-ui gunsansi dosi gyehoekan naeyong bunseok-eul jungsim-euro (Changes and Characteristics of Planning for the Historic Urban Core in Gunsan City—Based on a Content Analysis of Gunsan’s Municipal Plans from the 1960s to the 2010s)", Hanguk dosi seolgye hakhoeji (Journal of the Urban Design Institute of Korea), 18(5), pp.5~17 (2017)
- Youn, Seung Ho, "The Young Generations’ Conceptualisa tion of Cultural Tourism : Colonial Heritage Attractions in South Korea", Asia Pacific Journal of Tourism Research, 21(12), pp.1324~1342 (2016)[DOI]