그리스도의 신성을 견지하면서도 보편성을 포용: 기독교의 본질에 대한 헤르만 바빙크의 변호
Upholding Christ’s Deity Yet Embracing Universality: Herman Bavinck’s Defense of the Essence of Christianity
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
18세기 이후 등장한 회의주의 정신은 기독교의 본질에 대한 일련의 심각하고 다양한 논쟁을 불러 일으켰다. 전통 기독교에 대한 이러한 도전은 기독교의 본질에 대한 의문을 제기하며 하르낙의 기독교의 본질에 대한 강연으로 절정에 이르렀다. 이 논문에서는 이러한 경향에 대한 헤르만 바빙크(Herman Bavinck, 1854-1921)의 반응을, 그리스도의 중심성과 그리스도의 신성에 대한 확증을 통해 기독교의 본질을 변호하면서도, 신학적 함의를 포함하여 다른 관점의 신학 및 타종교와의 관계에서 기독교의 보편성을 적용한 것에 초점을 맞추어 고찰한다. 이 논문의 결과는 그리스도의 신성과 관련된 교리에 대한 다양한 현대의 도전에 직면하여 기독교의 본질로서 그리스도의 신성을 변호하는 데 귀중한 통찰력을 제공한다. 첫째, 그리스도의 신성의 본질 측면에서, 바빙크는 기독교의 본질은 그 중심에 그리스도의 신성이 있는 기독교에서 그리스도의 위치에 있음을 논증함으로써 기독교의 본질을 변호한다. 이것은 기독교를 다른 종교와 구별 짓는 독특한 특징이며, 이러한 관점에서 바빙크는 기독교의 본질 추구의 문제는 방법론의 문제가 아니라 처음부터 성경이 증언하는 그리스도에 대한 믿음에 관한 문제라고 주장한다. 둘째, 신학적 함의 측면에서, 그리스도의 신성에 대한 믿음은 기독교 신앙과 신학을 평가하는 규범이며, 신학의 출발점이자 모든 신학 작업에서 신학의 근본 원리가 된다. 셋째, 보편적 관점에서 볼 때, 그리스도의 신성과 관련 교리는 이것이 없으면 기독교의 기반이 무너지는 균형추 역할을 한다. 살아 계신 그리스도, 즉 그리스도의 신성은 보편적이기 때문에 다른 관점을 가진 신학과 다른 종교와의 적절한 관계를 제공한다.
Abstract
The skeptical spirit that emerged since the eighteenth century gave rise to a series of severe and diverse debates about the essence of Christianity. These challenges to traditional Christianity questioned its very essence, reaching a peak with Harnack's lecture on the essence of Christianity. This paper examines Herman Bavinck's response to this tendency, focusing on his defense of the essence of Christianity through the centrality of Christ and the affirmation of Christ's deity, yet applying the universality of Christianity in the relationship with theology from other perspectives and with other religions. The result of this paper offers valuable insights into defending the deity of Christ as the essence of Christianity in the face of various contemporary challenges to the doctrine related to Christ's deity. Firstly, in terms of the essence of the deity of Christ, Bavinck defends the essence of Christianity by demonstrating that the essence of Christianity lies in place of Christ in Christianity, in which the deity of Christ is at its center. This is a unique characteristic that distinguishes Christianity from other religions. From this perspective, Bavinck posits that the issue of the pursuit of the essence of Christianity is not a matter of methodology but rather a matter of faith in Christ, as witnessed by the Bible from the beginning. Secondly, regarding theological implications, this faith in the deity of Christ serves as a norm for evaluating Christian faith and theology, as a starting point of theology, and as a foundational principle for theology in every theological enterprise. Thirdly, from a universal standpoint, the deity of Christ and the associated doctrines serve; without this, the foundation would collapse as a counterweight to Christianity. The living Christ, the deity of Christ, is universal and thus provides an appropriate relationship to other religions and theologies with different perspectives.
참고문헌 (54)
- Bavinck, Herman, "The Catholicity of Christianity and the Church", Trans. John Bolt, Calvin Theological Journal, 27, pp.22~51 (1992)
- Bavinck, Herman, "The Certainty of Faith" (1980), Paideia
- Bavinck, Herman, "Groote Godsdiensten, Serie II. No. 7", pp.277~338 (1912), Hollandia Drukkerij
- Bavinck, Herman, "Christelijke Wereldbeschouwing" (1913), J. H. Kok
- Bavinck, Herman, "Christian Worldview" (2019), Crossway
- Bavinck, Herman, "Christ and Christianity", Trans. A. A. Pfanstiehl, Biblical Review, 1, pp.214~236 (1916)
- Bavinck, Herman, "Christological Movements in the Nineteenth Century", Trans. B. B. Warfield, Bibliotheca Sacra, 68, pp.381~404 (1911)
- Bavinck, Herman, "Reformed Dogmatics, 4 vols" (2003), Baker
- Bavinck, Herman, "Magnalia Dei" (1909), J. H. Kok
- Bavinck, Herman, "Our Reasonable Faith" (2016), Eerdmans Publishing Company
- Bavinck, Herman, "The Theology of Albrecht Ritschl", Trans. John Bolt, The Bavinck Review, 3, pp.123~163 (2012)
- Bavinck, Herman, "The Philosophy of Revelation: The Stone Lectures for 1908-1909 Princeton Theological Seminary" (1909), Longmans, Green, and Co
- Bavinck, Herman, "Recent Dogmatic Thought in the Netherlands", The Presbyterian and Refrained Review, III, pp.209~228 (1892)
- Bavinck, Herman, "Essays on Religion, Science, and Society", pp.33~48 (2008), Baker Academic
- Bavinck, Herman, "Verzamelde opstellen op het gebied van godsdienst en wetenschap" (1921), J. H. Kok
- Abraham, William J., "The Oxford Handbook of the Epistemology of Theology" (2017), Oxford University Press
- Berkhof, L., "Systematic Theology" (1938), Wm. B. Eerdmans publishing co
- Berkhof, L., "New Testament Introduction" (1915), Eerdmans-Sevensma Co
- Bock, Darrell L., "Studying the Historical Jesus: A Guide to Sources and Methods" (2002), Baker Academic
- Bowman, R. M., "Putting Jesus in His Place : The Case for the Deity of Christ" (2007), Kregel
- Bray, Gerald, "The deity of Christ" (2011), Crossway
- Brown, D., "Divine Humanity: Kenosis and the Construction of a Christian Theology" (2011), Baylor University Press
- Brown, Harold O., "Heresies : The Image of Christ in the Mirror of Heresy and Orthodoxy" (1984), Baker Books
- Bruce, F. F., "The Deity of Christ: Was Jesus a Fraud or Was He, God? Bath, and Nashville", pp.42~46 (2018), Copyright International, Inc.
- Carroll, James, "Reimagining Faith in the Modern Age" (2015), Penguin
- Cremer, Hermann, "The Christian Doctrine of the Divine Attributes" (2016), Wipf and Stock Publisher
- Dunn, J. D. G., "Did the First Christians Worship Jesus? The New Testament Evidence" (2010), SPCK
- Edwards, Jonathan, "The Works of Jonathan Edwards, vol. 2" (1974), Banner of Truth Trust
- Erickson, Millard J., "The Word Became Flesh" (1991), Baker Books
- Frame, John M., "The Doctrine of the Knowledge of God, A Theology of Lordship" (1987), P&R Publishing
- Giussani, Luigi, "At the Origin of the Christian Claim" (1998), McGill-Queen's Univerity Press
- Gomes, Gerald Alan W., "The deity of Christ" (2011), Crossway
- Harnack, Adolf, "What is Christianity? Lectures Delivered in the University of Berlin during the Winter-Term 1899-1900" (1899), Christian Classics Ethereal Library
- Harris, M. J., "Three Crucial Questions about Jesus" (1994), Baker
- Horton, Michael, "Christless Christianity: The Alternative Gospel of the American Church" (2008), Baker Books
- Kreeft, Peter, "Handbook of Christian Apologetics: Hundreds of Answers to Crucial Questions" (1994), IVP Academic
- Loke, Andrew T., "The Origin of Divine Christology" (2017), Cambridge University Press
- Overman, Dean L., "A Case for the Divinity of Jesus : Examining the Earliest Evidence" (2010), Rowman & Littlefield Publishers
- Plantinga, Alvin, "Warranted Christian Belief", Oxford Scholarship Online, ~ (2000)
- Plantinga, Alvin, "Warrant and Proper Function", Oxford Scholarship Online, ~ (2003)
- Plantinga, Alvin, "Warrant : The Current Debate", Oxford Scholarship Online, ~ (2003)
- Porter, Frank Chamberlin, "The Messages of the Apocalyptical Writers, vol. VIII, The Messages of the Bible" (1911), Charles Scribner’s Sons
- Riley, G. J., "How Jesus Inspired Not One True Christianity, But Many: The Truth About Christian Origins" (1997), HarperCollins
- Shenk, Richard, "The Virgin Birth of Christ" (2016), Paternoster
- Vanhoozer, Kevin J., "Christianity and the Postmodern Turn: Six Views", pp.105~156 (2005), Brazos Press
- Van den Belt, Henk, "Religion as Revelation? The Development of Herman Bavinck’s View from a Reformed Orthodox to a Neo-Calvinist Approach", The Bavinck Review, 4, pp.1~31 (2013)
- Van den Belt, Henk, "The Authority of Scripture in Reformed Theology: Truth and Trust", pp.301~336 (2008), Brill
- Vos, Geerhardus, "Redemptive History and Biblical Interpretation: The Shorter Writings of Geerhardus Vos" (2001), P&R Publishing
- Warfield, "The Works of Benjamin B. Warfield: Critical Reviews, Vol. 3,10" (2008), Logos Bible Software
- Wolterstorff, Nicholas, "Herman Bavinck—Proto Reformed Epistemologist", CTJ, 45, pp.133~146 (2010)
- Wright, N. T., "Jesus and the Victory of God, Christian Origins and the Question of God" (1996), Society for Promoting Christian Knowledge
- Zachariades, Theodore, "The Omnipresence of Jesus Christ: A Neglected Aspect of Evangelical Christology" (2015), Paternoster
- Kim, Sangyeup, "Warfield’s Apologies for the Doctrine of Two Natures of Christ: Focused on the Criticism of the Ritschlian School in America", Korea Reformed Theology, 63, pp.256~284 (2019)
- Kwon, Hoduck, "A Study on a Meaning of 'ego eimi' in John", Korea Reformed Theology, 49, pp.72~100 (2016)