South Korea’s Renewable Energy Policy: Coming Together or Drifting Apart?
0
조회
0
다운로드
1
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
South Korea’s incumbent Moon Jae-in administration announced its ambitious policy goals of increasing renewable energy and cultivating the related domestic industry. The 20% target for renewable energy’s share by 2030 marks a clear departure from the conservative position of previous administrations. The proposed policy tools—including large-scale project-based aid, favorable loan terms, the RPS system with weighted REC, and the Korean-style FIT model—involve some elements of prohibited and actionable subsides under the ASCM. This study concludes that the direction of South Korea’s energy policy is right, but it needs to be depoliticized and its speed readjusted.
Abstract
South Korea’s incumbent Moon Jae-in administration announced its ambitious policy goals of increasing renewable energy and cultivating the related domestic industry. The 20% target for renewable energy’s share by 2030 marks a clear departure from the conservative position of previous administrations. The proposed policy tools—including large-scale project-based aid, favorable loan terms, the RPS system with weighted REC, and the Korean-style FIT model—involve some elements of prohibited and actionable subsides under the ASCM. This study concludes that the direction of South Korea’s energy policy is right, but it needs to be depoliticized and its speed readjusted.
참고문헌 (94)
- Abbasi, S. A., "The Likely Adverse Environmental Impacts of Renewable Energy Sources", Applied Energy, 65(1–4), pp.121~144 (2000)
- Aguirre, Mariana, "Determinants of Renewable Energy Growth: A Global Sample Analysis", Energy Policy, 69, pp.374~384 (2014)
- "President Moon at Hanhwa Qcell why?... U-turn, Renewable, Jobs, ‘Thumbs-up’ (Mun Daetongryeong, Hanhwa Qcell-e Wae…U-turn·Sinjaesaeng·Iljari ‘Eomjicheok’)" (2018)[URL]
- "Everybody Building Solar Generators… ‘Renewable Subsidy’ Over 2 Trillion Won for the First Time (Neodonado Jisneun Taeyanggwang Baljeonso.. ‘Sinjaesaeng Bojogeum’ 2Jo Won Cheot Dolpa)" (2018)[URL]
- Asmelash, Henok, "Energy Subsidies and WTO Dispute Settlement : Why Only Renewable Energy Subsidies Are Challenged", Journal of International Economic Law, 18, pp.261~285 (2015)
- Bohanes, Jan, "WTO Dispute Settlement and Industrial Policy", International Centre for Trade and Sustainable Development and World Economic Forum, pp.1~16 (2015)
- "Roadmap of State Affairs (Gukjeong Gwaje)" (2017)[URL]
- Charnovitz, Steve, "Canada–Renewable Energy: Implications for WTO Law on Green and Not-So-Green Subsidies", World Trade Review, 14, pp.177~210 (2015)
- "First Half Petroleum Product Export New Record of 237 Million Barrels (Sangbangi Seogyu Jepum Suchullyang 2 Eok 3700 Man Barrell ‘Singirok’)" (2018)[URL]
- "Waiting for the Paradigm Shift in Energy Policy of Roh Administration (Roh-muhyeon Jeongbu Energy Jeongchaek Geu Paradigmui Jeonhwaneul Gidarimyeo)" (2005)[URL]
- 정민정, "지속가능발전을 위한 신재생 에너지 보조금 제도와 통상조약의 조화 방안", 국제법학회논총, 62(2), pp.201~229 (2017), 대한국제법학회
- Collie, David. R., "A Rationale for the WTO Prohibition of Export Subsidies : Strategic Export Subsidies and World Welfare", Open Economics Review, 11, pp.229~245 (2000)
- Cosbey, Aaron, "A Turquoise Mess: Green Subsidies, Blue Industrial Policy and Renewable Energy: The Case for Redrafting the Subsidies Agreement of the WTO", Journal of International Economic Law, 17, pp.11~47 (2014)
- Status and Cultivation Strategy of Renewable Energy Industry (Sinjaesaeng Energy Saneop Hyeonhwanggwa Yukseong Jeonryak), "Federation of Korean Industries", Heo, Seoji, ~, pp.FKI Issue Paper 232 (2016)
- "Targeting 50 Thousand Jobs in Renewable Energy Sector (Sinjaesaeng Energy Iljarido 5mangae Changchul Mokpyo)" (2017)[URL]
- Ham, In-Seon, "New and Renewable Energy Legislation Policies and Residents Participation - From the Comparative Law’s Perspective of Korea and Japan (Sinjaesaeng Energy-beop Jeongchaekgwa Juminchamyeo – Hanil Bigyo-beopjeok Gwanjeomeseo)", Legal Studies, 38(1), pp.469~497 (2018)
- Henschke, Lauren, "Going It Alone on Climate Change a New Challenge to WTO Subsidies Disciplines : Are Subsidies in Support of Emissions Reductions Schemes Permissible under the WTO", World Trade Review, 11, pp.27~52 (2012)
- Huh, Sung-yoon, "The Economic Value of South Korea's Renewable Energy Policies (RPS, RFS, and RHO): A Contingent Valuation Study", Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 50, pp.64~72 (2015)
- "Foreign and Domestic Energy New Industry – Trends and Challenges (Guknaeoe Energy Sin-saneop Trend Mit Hwalseonghwa Gwaje)" (2018)[URL]
- "Industry, Renewable Energy Transition 1 Trillion 530 Billion (Saneop, Sinjaesaeng Energy Jeonhwan 1jo 5300eok)" (2018)[URL]
- 김호철, "WTO 보조금협정과 탄소배출권 무상할당", 통상법률, (101), pp.74~113 (2011), 법무부
- "2018 Direction of Energy New Industry? 4th Industrial Revolution New Technology Convergence Extends IOE-Based Energy New Industry (2018 Energy-saneop Hyangbangeun?_4Cha Saneop-Hyeokmyeong Singisul Yunghabeuro IoE Giban Energy-sin-saneop Balgul·Hwaksanhanda)" (2018)[URL]
- Kim, Jihyo, "Renewable Electricity as a Differentiated Good? - The Case of the Republic of Korea", Energy Policy, 54, pp.327~334 (2013)
- 김종완, "의무할당제도 개선을 통한 신재생에너지 산업의 발전 전략 : 태양광, 풍력에너지 중심", 에너지공학, 25(4), pp.110~123 (2016), 한국에너지학회
- 김세규, "환경친화적 신․재생에너지의 보급 확대를 위한 법․정책적 개선방안 - 신․재생에너지 의무할당제와 관련하여 -", 공법학연구, 18(1), pp.205~232 (2017), 한국비교공법학회[DOI]
- 김태은, "신재생에너지 성장의 영향요인 연구: FIT와 RPS의 효과성 검증을 중심으로", 한국행정학보, 45(3), pp.305~333 (2011), 한국행정학회
- 구민교, "우리나라의 발전차액지원제도 사례 분석: 신산업정책론 시각에서", 한국행정연구, 22(1), pp.1~27 (2013), 한국행정연구원[DOI]
- "2016 Renewable Energy Industry (Final) Statistics (2016Nyeon Sinjaesaeng Energy Bogeup-Tonggye (Hwakjeongchi) Gyeolgwa)" (2016)[URL]
- "Financial Support for Renewable Energy (Sinjaesaeng Energy Geumyungjiwon)" (2018)[URL]
- "Energy Info Korea" (2017)[URL]
- "Mega-scale Solar Wind Cluster at Saemangeum… “Omitted Public Debate” Some Criticize (Summary) (Saemangeum Chodaehyeong Taeyanggwang Pungnyeok Danji “Gongnonhwa Saengnyang” Jijeokdo (Jonghap)" (2018)[URL]
- "2016 Technology Level Evaluation (2016 Gisul Sujun Pyeongga)" (2017)[URL]
- Korea Institute of S&T Evaluation and Planning, "R&D Investment Direction According to Administration’s Energy Transition Policy (Jeongbuui Energy Jeonhwan Jeongchaege Ttareun Jeonryeok Bunya R&D Tooja Banghyang)", KISTEP Issue Weekly, 228 (2018)
- "2018 Renewable Energy Industry Statistics (2017 Achievements) (2018Nyeon Sinjaesaeng Energy SaneopTonggye (2017Nyeon Siljeok))" (2018)[URL]
- "2018 2nd Round of Call for Proposals on Renewable Energy Financial Support (2018Nyeon Sinjaesaeng Energy Geumyoong Jiwon 2Cha Jiwon Gonggo)" (2018)[URL]
- "Korea Trade Insurance Corporation" (2018)[URL]
- Ku, Se-Ju, "Willingness to Pay for Renewable Energy Investment in Korea: A Choice of Experiment Study", Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 14, pp.2196~2220 (2010)
- Renewable Energy 3020 Implementation Plan and Policy Implications (Jaesaeng Energy 3020 Ihaeng-gyehoekgwJjeongchaekjeok Sisajeom), "Kwak, Dae Jong", KIET, ~ (2018)
- 권태형, "신재생에너지 시장 확대를 위한 정책수단의 비교: 가격정책과 수량정책의 정책결합", 한국정책과학학회보, 18(2), pp.1~23 (2014), 한국정책과학학회
- "Saemangeum Renewable Energy Project Call for 10 Trillion Specific Plan in Urgent Need (Saemangeum Sinjaesaeng Energy Saeop 10jo Yuchi Deung Sebugyehoek Sigeup)" (2018)[URL]
- "Zero Nuclear Policy Requires 232 Trillion Over 21 years… Increase of Electricity Price at Least 20% (Talwonjeon Jeongchaek 21Nyeongan 232Jo Piryo…Jeongiyogeum Choeso 20% Oreunda)" (2017)[URL]
- Lee, Jaemin, "SCM Agreement Revisited: Climate Change, Renewable Energy, and the SCM Agreement", World Trade Review, 15(4), pp.613~644 (2016)
- 이재민, "환경친화 보조금과 WTO 보조금 협정", 국제.지역연구, 26(2), pp.127~150 (2017), 국제학연구소
- 이길원, "인도의 미국산 태양전지ㆍ모듈 제품의 차별에 관한 WTO 판례 연구", 미국헌법연구, 28(3), pp.187~213 (2017), 미국헌법학회
- "Presidency Transition from Roh Tae-Woo to Park Geun-Hye – Focus on Energy and Climate Policies (Roh Tae-Woo-eseo Park Geun-Hye-kkaji Daetongryeongjik Insu Gwajeongeseo Teukjinggwa Sisajeom – Energy Guihoobunya Jeongchaegeul Joongsimeuro)" (2018)[URL]
- 이상훈, "한국에서 재생에너지 확대를 위한 정책적 과제", 환경법과 정책, 12, pp.63~82 (2014), 비교법학연구소[DOI]
- "Alleged Government Pressure on Nong-hyup·Shin-han for ‘Solar Loans’ (Jeongbu, Nonghyeop·Sinhaneunhaenge 'Taeyanggwang Saeop Daechul' Oeap Uihok)" (2018)[URL]
- 이수진, "재생가능에너지 의무할당제의 이론과 실제: RPS 도입국가들에 대한 분석을 바탕으로", 환경정책, 19(3), pp.79~111 (2011), 한국환경정책학회
- Lewis, Joanna I, "The Rise of Renewable Energy Protectionism : Emerging Trade Conflicts and Implications for Low Carbon Development", Global Environmental Politics, 14(4), pp.10~35 (2014)
- 임형우, "RPS 및 FIT 제도가 신재생에너지 보급에미치는 효과 분석 : 104개국 패널토빗분석", 에너지경제연구, 16(2), pp.1~31 (2017), 재단법인 에너지경제연구원[DOI]
- Lodefalk, Magnus, "Climate Measures and WTO Rules on Subsidies", Journal of World Trade, 39, pp.23~44 (2005)
- "Press Releases"[URL]
- "Execution Guideline to Renewable Energy Foreign Market Entry Support (Sinjaesaeng Energy Haeoe Jinchul Jiwon Saeop Unyeong Yoryeong)" (2015)[URL]
- "3020 Implementation Plan (Jaesaeng Energy 3020 Ihaeng Gyehoek)" (2017)[URL]
- "Direction of Industrial Policy of the New Administration (Sae Jeongbuui Saneop Jeongchaek Banghyang)" (2017)[URL]
- "The 8th Basic Plan for Long-Term Supply & Demand (Je8cha Jeonryeok Sugeup Gibon Gyehoek)" (2017)[URL]
- "New Industry in Energy - Policy Briefing (Energy Sinsaneop Jeongchaek Briefing)" (2018)[URL]
- "Project Explanation for 2018 Budget Implementation Plans (Electricity Industry Budget) (2018Nyeon Yesan Mit Gigeumun Ounyong Gyehoek Saeop Seolmyeong Jaryo (Jeonryeok Saneop Giban Gigeum))" (2018)[URL]
- "New and Renewable Energy White Paper" (2016)[URL]
- "Energy New Industry · New and Renewable Energy Policy Presentation (Energy-sin-saneop Sinjaesaeng Energy Jeongchaek Seolmyeonghoe Jaryo)" (2017)[URL]
- "100 Trillion Won to be Invested in Renewable Energy by 2030 (2030Nyeonkkaji 100Jo Gyumo Jaesaeng Energy Toojadoenda)" (2017)[URL]
- "MSIT, Renewable Energy R&D budget 1/3 Level of Nuclear (Gwagibu, 5Nyeongan Sinjaesaeng R&D Yesan Wonjaryeok 1/3 Sujune Bulgwa)" (2018)[URL]
- "'Shadow of Zero-Nuclear’ … Germany Puts 30 Trillion Won Burden on Consumers for Renewable Energy (‘Talwonjeonui Geuneul’…Dogil, Sinjaesaeng Energy Kiuryeo Yeon 30Jo Won Sobijae Budam)" (2017)[URL]
- Jennifer Sejin Oh, "Comparative Analysis of Japan and Korea’s Renewable Energy Politics: 2002-2016", 사회과학연구, 29(2), pp.133~154 (2018), 사회과학연구소[DOI]
- Panwar, N. L., "Role of Renewable Energy Sources in Environmental Protection: A Review", Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 15(3), pp.1513~1524 (2011)
- "140 Trillion Won … Renewable Energy Investment 25% Increase (2030Nyeonkkaji 140Jo… Sinjaesaeng Energy Tooja 25% Hwakdae)" (2017)[URL]
- Park, yoonseok, "New Administration’s ‘Grand Transition’ … Speed Adjustment Needed (Sae Jeongbu Energy Jeongchaek ‘Daejeonhwan’… Sokdojojeol Piryo)", Electric Power, 11(8), pp.50~53 (2017)
- "Trump Says Solar Tariff Will Create ‘A Lot of Jobs.’ But It Could Wipe Out Many More" (2018)[URL]
- "Renewables 2017 Global Status Report" (2017)[URL]
- Rubini, Luca, "Ain’t Wasitn’ Time No More: Susbsidies for Rnewable Energy, the SCM Agreement, Policy Space, and Law Reform", Journal of International Economic Law, 15(2), pp.525~579 (2012)
- PV Sector Global Innovation and Trends (Taeyanggwang(PV) Bunya Geullobeol Hyeoksinseonggwa Donghyang), "Science and Technology Policy Institute", STEPI, ~ (2017)
- Seager, Thomas P., "Land use and geospatial aspects in life cycle assessment of renewable energy", Proceedings of the IEEE Symposium on Sustainable Systems and Technology Phoenix AZ (2018)
- Shadikhodjaev, Sherzod, "First WTO Judicial Review of Climate Change Subsidy Issues", American Journal of International Law, 107, pp.864~878 (2013)
- Shadikhodjaev, Sherzo, "Renewable Energy and Government Support : Time to ‘Green’ the SCM Agreement?", World Trade Review, 14, pp.479~506 (2015)
- "Numerous Exiting Korea, Few U-turns... SME’s at Hardships (Tal Hanguk Manhgo, U-turn Jeokgo… Siryeonui Jungso)" (2018)[URL]
- 심성희, "RPS and FIT with Transaction Costs", 환경정책연구, 13(1), pp.49~68 (2014), 한국환경연구원[DOI]
- Sim, Sang-min, "Implication on Korean Energy Security from Experience of Countries After Energy Transition Implementation (Energy Jeonhwan Sihaeng Gukgadeurui Gyeongheomi Hanguk Energy Anboe Juneun Hamui)", IFANS Critical International Issues Analysis, 2018(7) (2018)
- Problems of Zero Nuclear, Zero Coal Policies: The Economic Aspect and Sustainability (Talwonjeon·Talseoktan Jeongchaegui Munjejeom: Geu Gyeongjeseonggwa Jisokganeungseongeun?), "The Asan Institute for Policy", ~ (2018)
- Energy Industry Outward-Bound Status and Prospective Countries (Jeonryeoksaneop Haeoejinchul Hyeonhwang Mit Jinchul Yumang Gukga), "The Export-Import Bank of Korea", ~ (2017)
- The Export-Import Bank of Korea, "2018 First Quarter Solar Industry Trend (2018Nyeon 1bungi Taeyanggwang Saneop Donghyang)", Quarterly Briefing, 2018(05) (2018)
- "Module 3.7 Subsidies and Countervailing Measures" (2003)[URL]
- "Country Analysis Brief: South Korea" (2018)[URL]
- "World Energy Trilemma 2016 – Defining Measures to Accelerate the Energy Transition" (2016)[URL]
- "Analytical Index: Subsidies and Countervailing Measures: Agreement on Subsidies and Countervailing Measures" (2018)[URL]
- "WTO Dispute Documents Online Database" (2018)[URL]
- "Canada - Aircraft (WT", DS70, R)[DOI]
- "US - Softwood Lumber IV (WT", DS257, DS257, pp.AB, R)
- "US – Subsidies on Upland Cotton (WT", DS267, ~
- "Canada - Renewable Energy", Canada - FIT Program (WT, R, WT, pp.DS412, AB[DOI]
- "India - Solar Cells (WT", DS456, ~
- "World Running.. South Korea Going Backwards (Segyeneun Ttwineunde..Geokkuro Ganeun Hanguk)" (2013)[URL]
- 유진만, "신재생에너지산업 국제경쟁력 분석", 무역학회지, 40(3), pp.91~118 (2015), 한국무역학회
- Yoon, Jong-Han, "Why is South Korea's Renewable Energy Policy Failing? A Qualitative Evaluation", Energy Policy, 86, pp.369~379 (2015)
- Yoon, Kyung Jun, "Moon Administration’s Energy Policy – Direction, Speed, and Governance (Moon Jae-in Jeongbuui Energy Jeongchaek – Banghyang, Sokdo Geurigo Governance)", Presentation from 2017 Winter Conference of Korean Association for Policy Studies (2017)
