[씬트라조약에 관하여]에 나타난 워즈워스의 애국심
Wordsworth’s Patriotism in _Concerning the Convention of Cintra_
0
조회
0
다운로드
1
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
This paper examines Wordsworth’s idea of patriotism in his Concerning The Convention of Cintra (1809) in the context of the political debate between Richard Price and Edmund Burke over the nature of patriotism. I survey the idea of patriot from its Greco-Roman etymology to its various usages in 18th-century Britain before comparing Price’s idea of cosmopolitan patriotism based on “universal benevolence” with Burke’s “chivalric” patriotism based on filial love and regional loyalty. I then turn to Coleridge’s idea of “modern patriotism,” which illuminates the cosmopolitan aspects of Wordsworth’s patriotism in the early 1790s. A passage in Wordsworth’s The Prelude (1805) agonizingly recollects the moment of moral dilemma in 1793 when he heard the news of the debacle of the British army. His use of Burkean expressions such as “this most unnatural strife” and “the blessed tree of my beloved country” clearly indicate that his cosmopolitan patriotism was seriously weakened in the aftermath of Napoleon’s coronation in 1804. This position, however, was decisively reversed four years later in his Concerning The Convention of Cintra where he reaffirms his republican sympathy in his enthusiastic support for the Spanish-Portuguese people’s brave resistance to the invading Napoleonic army, reclaiming the cosmopolitan patriotism he had begun to lose sight of when he began to be disillusioned with the French Revolution.
Abstract
This paper examines Wordsworth’s idea of patriotism in his Concerning The Convention of Cintra (1809) in the context of the political debate between Richard Price and Edmund Burke over the nature of patriotism. I survey the idea of patriot from its Greco-Roman etymology to its various usages in 18th-century Britain before comparing Price’s idea of cosmopolitan patriotism based on “universal benevolence” with Burke’s “chivalric” patriotism based on filial love and regional loyalty. I then turn to Coleridge’s idea of “modern patriotism,” which illuminates the cosmopolitan aspects of Wordsworth’s patriotism in the early 1790s. A passage in Wordsworth’s The Prelude (1805) agonizingly recollects the moment of moral dilemma in 1793 when he heard the news of the debacle of the British army. His use of Burkean expressions such as “this most unnatural strife” and “the blessed tree of my beloved country” clearly indicate that his cosmopolitan patriotism was seriously weakened in the aftermath of Napoleon’s coronation in 1804. This position, however, was decisively reversed four years later in his Concerning The Convention of Cintra where he reaffirms his republican sympathy in his enthusiastic support for the Spanish-Portuguese people’s brave resistance to the invading Napoleonic army, reclaiming the cosmopolitan patriotism he had begun to lose sight of when he began to be disillusioned with the French Revolution.
참고문헌 (35)
- 곽준혁, "민족주의 없는 애국심과 비지배 평화원칙", 아세아연구, 46(4), pp.311~340 (2003), 아세아문제연구원
- 박찬길, "윌리엄 워즈워스의 급진적 정치관 재론", 안과밖, 1, pp.214~240 (1996)
- Bainbridge, Simon John Julian, "The Oxford Handbook of William Wordsworth", pp.116~135 (2015), Oxford UP
- Bromwich, David, "Romantic Nationalism and the Convention of Cintra", Studies in Romanticism, 49(4), pp.601~610 (2010)
- Brownlow, Anne E, "Eighteenth Century English Patriotism and the French Revolution", History of European Ideas, 15(1), pp.289~296 (1992)
- Burke, Edmund, "Burke: Reflections on the Revolution in France" (1968), Penguin
- Coleman, Deirdre, "Re-Living Jacobinism: Wordsworth and the Convention of Cintra", Yearbook of English Studies, 19, pp.144~161 (1989)
- Coleridge, Samuel Taylor, "The Watchman" (1969), Routledge & Kegan Paul
- Colley, Linda, "Patriotism: the making and unmaking of British national identity. Volume I, History and Politics", pp.169~187 (2017), Routledge
- Commissiong, Anand Bertrand, "Cosmopolitan Patriotism", PB & J: Politics, Bureaucracy, and Justice, 4(2), pp.34~42 (2014)
- Connell, Philip, "Wordsworth’s ‘Sonnets Dedicated to Liberty’ and the British Revolutionary Past", ELH: English Literary History, 85(3), pp.747~774 (2018)
- Cottrell, Stella, "Patriotism:the making and unmaking of British national identity. Volume I, History and Politics", pp.259~274 (2017), Routledge
- Cronin, Richard, "Wordsworth’s Poems of 1807 and the War Against Napoleon", Review of English Studies, 48(189), pp.33~50 (1997)
- Cunningham, Hugh, "The Language of Patriotism, 1750-1914", istory Workshop, 12, pp.8~33 (1981)
- Dicey, A. V, "Wordsworth’s Tract on the Convention of Cintra" (1915), Humphrey Milford
- Dietz, M. G, "Patriotism", pp.177~193 (2002), Humanity
- Esṕindola, Juan, "A Criticism of Edmund Burke’s Conception of Patriotism", Tópicos, Resvista de Filosofía, 46, pp.121~149 (2014)
- Gravil, Richard, "Concerning the Convention of Cintra: A Critical Edition", pp.16~29 (2009), Humanities-Ebooks
- Green, Georgina, "The People and the Poet Redeemed: William Wordsworth and the Peninsular Uprising", ELH, 79, pp.935~962 (2012)
- Griffin, Dustin H, "Patriotism and Poetry in Eighteenth-Century Britain" (2005), Cambridge UP
- Magnuson, Paul, "Bloom’s Modern Critical Views: Samuel Taylor Coleridge New Edition", pp.51~70 (2019), Infobase
- Moorman, Mary, "William Wordsworth: A Biography: The Early Years, 1770-1803" (1968), Oxford UP
- Mori, Jennifer, "Languages of Loyalism: Patriotism, Nationhood and the State in the 1790s", The English Historical Review, 118(475), pp.33~58 (2003)
- Nussbaum, Martha, "For Love of Country?", pp.3~17 (2010), Beacon
- Price, Richard, "Richard Price:Political Writings", pp.176~196 (1991), Cambridge UP
- Primoratz, Igor, "Patriotism" (2009), Humanity
- "Patriotism" (2019)[URL]
- Primoratz, Igor, "Patriotism: Philosophical and Political Perspectives" (2008), Ashgate
- Radcliffe, Evan, "Burke, Radical Cosmopolitanism, and the Debates on Patriotism in the 1790s", Studies in Eighteenth-Century Culture, 28, pp.311~339 (1999)
- Thompson, E. P, "The Romantics: England in a Revolutionary Age", pp.75~95 (1997), New Press
- Vincent, Patrick, "Concerning the Convention of Cintra: A Critical Edition", pp.53~62 (2009), Humanities-Ebooks
- Woof, Robert, "William Wordsworth: The Critical Heritage, Vol. 1:1793-1820" (2004), Routledge
- Wordsworth, William, "Poems, Volume II" (1977), Penguin
- Wordsworth, "The Prelude: A Parallel Text" (1988), Penguin
- Wordsworth, William, "Concerning the Convention of Cintra: A Critical Edition" (2009), Humanities-Ebooks