선망과 폭력—허먼 멜빌의 『빌리 버드』
Envy and Violence: Herman Melville’s Billy Budd
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Melville explores envy’s destructiveness in Billy Budd. Melville shows civilization and intellectuality can drive envy into the worst case of violence and moral violation. Claggart’s envy of Billy Budd is driven by his keen insight into Billy’s innocence and its “moral phenomenon.” Claggart’s false accusation of Billy of inciting the crew to mutiny can be a case of meaningless violence as he intends to destroy the goodness because he cannot have it. Vere adopts the sovereign role to determine “the state of exception” and makes Billy a victim of the political violence with his argument of “military necessity” in convicting Billy of murder of Claggart, a superior, and sentencing him to death. Agamben writes, the sovereign decision “suspends law in the state of exception and opens a sphere permitted to kill without committing homicide” and without religious meaning. Captain Vere joins Claggart in hidden envy of a model. For Vere, Nelson becomes a model of leadership, and Vere makes Billy “a surrogate victim” in Girard’s sense. Girard sees that violence from mimetic rivalry “always finds a surrogate victim” “if the initial object remains persistently out of reach and continues to provoke hostility.” In this sense, Vere’s violence toward Billy can be seen as a case of substitution in mimetic rivalry and scapegoating.
Abstract
Melville explores envy’s destructiveness in Billy Budd. Melville shows civilization and intellectuality can drive envy into the worst case of violence and moral violation. Claggart’s envy of Billy Budd is driven by his keen insight into Billy’s innocence and its “moral phenomenon.” Claggart’s false accusation of Billy of inciting the crew to mutiny can be a case of meaningless violence as he intends to destroy the goodness because he cannot have it. Vere adopts the sovereign role to determine “the state of exception” and makes Billy a victim of the political violence with his argument of “military necessity” in convicting Billy of murder of Claggart, a superior, and sentencing him to death. Agamben writes, the sovereign decision “suspends law in the state of exception and opens a sphere permitted to kill without committing homicide” and without religious meaning. Captain Vere joins Claggart in hidden envy of a model. For Vere, Nelson becomes a model of leadership, and Vere makes Billy “a surrogate victim” in Girard’s sense. Girard sees that violence from mimetic rivalry “always finds a surrogate victim” “if the initial object remains persistently out of reach and continues to provoke hostility.” In this sense, Vere’s violence toward Billy can be seen as a case of substitution in mimetic rivalry and scapegoating.
참고문헌 (34)
- Agamben, Giorgio, "Homo Sacer : Sovereign Power and Bare Life. Trans. Daniel Heller-Roazen" (1995), Stanford UP
- Alweiss, Lilian, "On Moral Dilemmas : Winch, Kant and Billy Budd", Philosophy, 78(304), pp.205~218 (2003)
- Arendt, Hannah, "On Revolution" (1963), Penguin
- Ben-Ze'ev, Aaron, "Envy and Inequality", The Journal of Philosophy, 89(11), pp.551~581 (1992)
- Ben-Ze'ev, Aaron, "The Subtlety of Emotions" (2001), MIT Press
- Brodtkorb, Paul, Jr., "The Definitive Billy Budd: ‘But Aren't It All Sham?’", PMLA, 82(7), pp.602~612 (1967)
- Calhoun, Byron J, "Captain Vere as Outsider and Insider : Military Leadership in Billy Budd, Sailor", War, Literature & the Arts: An International Journal of the Humanities, 21(1, pp.2) (2009), 1~10
- Drysdale, David J, "Melville’s Motley Crew : History and Constituent Power in Billy Budd", Nineteenth-Century Literature, 67(3), pp.312~336 (2012)
- Freud, Sigmund, "Group Psychology and the Analysis of the Ego" (1959), Norton
- Gilmore, Michael T, "‘Speak, man!’ : Billy Budd in the Crucible of Reconstruction", American Literary History, 21(3), pp.492~517 (2009)
- Girard, René, "Deceit, Desire and the Novel: Self and Other in Literary Structure" (1966), Johns Hopkins UP
- Girard, René, "The Girard Reader", pp.9~19 (1996), Herder and Herder
- Girard, René, "The Girard Reader", pp.69~93 (1996), Herder and Herder
- Goodheart, Eugene, "Billy Budd and the World’s Imperfection", Sewanee Review, 114(1), pp.81~92 (2006)
- Hayford, Harrison, "Critical Essays on Melville’s Billy Budd, Sailor", pp.23~32 (1989), G. K. Hall
- Hume, David, "A Treatise of Human Nature" (1991), J. M. Dent &Sons
- Johnson, Barbara, "Critical Essays on Melville’s Billy Budd, Sailor", pp.185~198 (1989), G. K. Hall
- Ives, C. B, "Billy Budd and the Articles of War", American Literature, 34(1), pp.31~39 (1962)
- Kant, Immanuel, "Lectures on Ethics", pp.384~392 (1963), Harper & Row
- Kant, Immanuel, "The Metaphysics of Morals" (1996), Cambridge UP
- Klein, Melanie, "Envy and Gratitude and Other Works 1946-1963" (1975), Simon and Schuster
- Martin, Robert K., "Hero, Captain, and Stranger: Male Friendship, Social Critique, and Literary Form in the Sea Novels of Herman Melville" (1986), U of North Carolina P
- Melville, Herman, "Billy Budd, Sailor and Selected Tales" (1997), Oxford UP
- Milder, Robert, "Introduction. Billy Budd, Sailor and Selected Tales", pp.vii~xxxix (1997), Oxford UP
- Milder, Robert, "Critical Essays on Melville’s Billy Budd, Sailor", pp.1~22 (1989), G. K. Hall
- Nussbaum, Martha C., "Upheavals of Thought: The Intelligence of Emotions" (2001), Cambridge UP
- Phillips, Kathy J, "Billy Budd as Anti-Homophobic Text", College English, 56(8), pp.896~910 (1994)
- Phillips, Kathy J, "‘One of Those Aliens’ : Empire and Homosexuality in Melville's Billy Budd", Strategies, 13(2), pp.163~174 (2000)
- Sabini, J., "The Social Construction of Emotions", pp.167~183 (1986), Basil Blackwell
- Schoeck, Helmut, "Envy: A Theory of Social Behavior" (1966), Liberty Fund
- Sedgwick, Eve K, "Epistemology of the Closet" (1996), U of California P
- Wade, Francis C, "On Violence", The Journal of Philosophy, 12, pp.369~377 (1971)
- Weisberg, Richard, "How Judges Speak : Some Lessons on Adjudication in Billy Budd with an Application to Justice Rehnquist", New York University Law Review, 57(1), pp.1~69 (1982)
- Willett, Ralph W, "Nelson and Vere : Hero and Victim in Billy Budd, Sailor", PMLA, 82(5), pp.370~376 (1967)